April May 2021 Archives - The Instrumentalist /category/april-may-2021-flute-talk/ Fri, 30 Apr 2021 17:48:18 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 Paul Hindemith’s Flute Music /april-may-2021-flute-talk/paul-hindemiths-flute-music/ Fri, 30 Apr 2021 17:48:18 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/paul-hindemiths-flute-music/    German composer, theorist, teacher, violist, and conduc­tor Paul Hindemith rose to popularity between the two world wars and became one of the dominant musicians of the 20th century. When his music was banned in Germany in 1936, the composer fled to Switzerland and then to the United States. Born in Hanau, Germany in 1895, […]

The post Paul Hindemith’s Flute Music appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

   German composer, theorist, teacher, violist, and conduc­tor Paul Hindemith rose to popularity between the two world wars and became one of the dominant musicians of the 20th century. When his music was banned in Germany in 1936, the composer fled to Switzerland and then to the United States. Born in Hanau, Germany in 1895, the eldest of three children, Hindemith entered the Hoch Conservatory at age 14 to study violin with Adolf Rebner. Later he learned music theory and composi­tion from Arnold Mendelssohn, sec­ond cousin of Felix Mendelssohn-Bar­tholdy. At this stage of his career Hindemith admired the music of Brahms, Dvorak, Tchaikovsky, Mahler, Reger, Franz Schreker, Arnold Schoen­berg, and Richard Strauss. He played first violin in the Frankfurt Opera Orchestra in 1914 and eventually became concertmaster.

First Composition Period (1918-23)
   At the onset of World War I Hinde­mith was drafted and played in a string quartet and a regimental band, but toward the end of the war he fought in the trenches, an experience that prob­ably influenced his late-compositional style. Early 20th-century composers, such as Schoenberg and other 12-tone advocates, rejected traditional har­mony and form and were known as expressionists. Like them Hindemith wrote such works as Sonata for Cello and Piano (1919), the one-act operas, Das Nusch Nuschi, Op. 20 (1920), and Sancta Susanna, Op. 21 (1921), and the song cycles Des Tades Tod, Op. 23a (1922) and Die junge Magd, Op. 23, # 2 (1922) in this style during his early career. He balanced the tension of the expanded harmonies with formal, tra­ditional designs, such as sonata allegro form and theme and variations, although he did not write strictly in a 12-tone style.

Second Compositional Period (1924-33)
   Historian Gustav Fredrich Hartlaub (1884-1963) first used the phrase Neue Sachlichkeit (new objectivity) to des­cribe the social trend toward democ­racy in all areas of life. Music in this compositional style was functional and practical. During this stage in his development, Hindemith rejected ex­pressionism and returned to writing clear musical lines, textures, and forms. He wrote Kammermusiken #2-7, a series of concertos that are similar to Bach’s Brandenburg Concertos. In Concerto for Orchestra (1925) Hinde­mith used a ritornello theme, and in vocal music he incorporated the text into the structure of the music. In Cardillac, an opera he wrote in 1925-6, Hindemith used such Baroque forms as fugues, passacaglia, variations, osti­natos, and arias.
   From 1920 to 1930 Hindemith per­formed in the Amar Quartet and was on the program committee of the Donaueschingen Festival, one of the most important contemporary music centers of the day. While teaching at the Berlin Musikhochschule in 1927, he studied theory, acoustics, and also learned Latin and math in order to read the text of old treatises. Hindemith learned to play many of the early instru­ments in the Hochschule’s collection and gave private lessons. As technology developed, Hindemith dabbled in exper­imental music for the gramophone and taught a course in film music.

Third Compositional Period (1933-63)
   Hindemith refused to stop perform­ing with Jewish musicians after the National Socialists came into power in 1933. His wife was part Jewish, and he helped several Jewish friends escape from Germany. During this period Hindemith worked on Mathis der Maler, which became his most famous opera. It depicts a painter who tem­porarily leaves his art but triumphs after great tragedy and returns to being an artist. He used excerpts from the operatic score and some other material to create the symphonic work, which was premiered by the Berlin Philhar­monic in 1934 with Wilhelm Furt­wangler conducting. The work was well received, but within the year the political climate changed, and Hinde­mith swore a formal oath of allegiance to Hitler in an effort to appease the government. Furtwangler wrote a let­ter in support of Hindemith that was published in a major German newspa­per, but despite this Goebbels accused Hindemith of cultural Bolshevism and banned his works in that country. Hindemith and Furtwangler conse­quently resigned their positions, and Hindemith focused on music theory and composition because he was unable to teach or conduct. He wrote The Craft of Musical Composition in 1937, a book that explained a new harmonic system based on natural laws of sound and the overtone series. This new tonal language, for which Hinde­mith is known, used perfect fourths and fifths instead of the triadic empha­sis on thirds.
   For a short period the Hindemiths lived in Switzerland but left for the U.S. a few months after the outbreak of World War II. Surprisingly, he com­posed 25 sonatas for almost every orchestral instrument during this time, as well as the Violin Concerto (1939), the Cello Concerto (1940), and the Symphony in Eb (1940). All of these works point to a more conventional style of composition. Yet intervals of the fourth and fifth governed his har­monic lines because Hindemith believed that they expanded the har­monic content of music.
   In the United States Hindemith taught composition and theory at sev­eral major universities, most notably at Yale, and he wrote Exercises in Two-Part Writing (1939), A Concentrated Course in Traditional Harmony (1943), and Ele­mentary Training for Musicians (1946). His continued fascination with early music led him to found the Yale Col­legium Musicum (1945-1953), which performed early music in a historically-­based style, long before Baroque per­formance practice became popular. He began to include isorhythmic passages, fugues, canons, and other contrapuntal devices in his music, culminating in Ludus tonalis (1942), a 20th-century counterpart to J.S. Bach’s Well­Tempered Clavier.
   Hindemith became an American citizen in 1946 and later commuted between Zurich and New Haven as he taught in two universities. In this compositional period Hindemith often wrote for wind instruments because he thought they were underrepresented in the repertoire. He wrote in a style that reflects his return to discernable tonalties.
   The city of Hamburg gave Hinde­mith the Bach Prize in 1952 for "dis­tinguished service to German music." In his acceptance speech Hindemith said of Bach, "The literal heritage, his music proper, has conquered our souls as has hardly another master’s work. It was hidden and forgotten for a long time, like buried treasure in romantic tales, but finally several generations ago we found it again. We acquired it to possess it, to quote Fauste."1

Music for Flute
   The most notable compositions Hindemith wrote for flute are the Canonic Sonatine for two flutes, Op. 31, # 3 (1924), 8 Pieces for Solo Flute (1927), Sonata for flute and piano (1936), and Echo for flute and piano (1942). Hindemith also composed sev­eral chamber works that include flute, most notably the woodwind quintet, Kleine Kammermusik, Op. 24, # 2 (1924 ). Other chamber works are the Septet for flute, oboe, clarinet, trumpet, horn, bass clarinet/bassoon, and bas­soon (1948), and Speilmusik, Op. 43, # 1 for flute, oboe, and strings.
   Hindemith wrote the flute sonata while working on Mathis der Maler. Richard Taruskin explained in The New York Times2 how this opera was a para­digm shift in the composer’s life. The main character of the opera, Matthias Grunewald, mirrors Hindemith’s life as he retreats from a world of class warfare and book burnings into the timeless world of art. Hindemith also admired Bach and during this time described him as one "who, two centuries later, proves to be a traditionalist in the stream of musical development."3 Baroque polyphony and the musical forms of the 17th and 18th centuries clearly inspired many of Hindemith’s works, including his flute sonata.
   At the invitation of Oliver Strunk (1901-1980), chief of the Music Divi­sion of the Library of Congress, Hinde­mith was the featured guest at the 1936 Eighth Washington Festival of Contemporary Music, which was attended by the musical elite from all over the country. Georges Barrere (1876-1944) and pianist Jesus Maria Sanroma ( 1902-1984) premiered the flute sonata; other works on the pro­gram were Holderline Songs for tenor and piano, the Solo Viola Sonata, Op. 25.1, which Hindemith played; Four Songs on Old Texts for chorus, and a third piano sonata. In a subsequent let­ter to his wife, Hindemith wrote, "Barrere and Sanroma blew the flute sonata magnificently. They made a very good impression, the large audi­ence responded warmly at once."
   Less severe than many of Hindemith’s works, the flute sonata has three move­ments, the third of which is divided into two distinct and contrasting sections, a form that none of his other brass or wind sonatas use. The tonal language denies reference to any key, and key signatures do not occur in the score, although the tonal relationships between movements are Bb, B natural, Bb. Contrapuntal writing includes imitation, non-imitative coun­terpoint, pedal points, repetition, and sequences, as well as more modern tech­niques of planing or parallelism and quartal harmonies.
   At first Hindemith referred to the sonata as an example of Gebrauchs­musik or music for a purpose, such as music written specifically for amateurs to play. Later he objected to the term and said that music should be "human, purposeful, absolute, and above all, accessible to all and utilitarian."4 That the work is now considered standard repertoire proves that Hindemith’s goal was met.

1 Paul Hindemith, Johann Sebastian Bach (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1952) p. 25.
2 Richard Taruskin, "In Search of a ‘Good’ Hindemith Legacy," New York Times (January 8, 1995), p. 30
3 Taruskin, "Hindemith Legacy," p. 30.
4 Jean Mary Ohlsson, "Paul Hindemith’s Music for Flute: Analysis of Solo Works and Stylistic and Formal Considerations of Chamber Works," (D.M.A. diss., Ohio State University, 1975), p. 14.
 

The post Paul Hindemith’s Flute Music appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
A Tribute to Murray Panitz /april-may-2021-flute-talk/a-tribute-to-murray-panitz/ Fri, 30 Apr 2021 16:58:39 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/a-tribute-to-murray-panitz/       A few months before Murray Panitz died from an aneurism on April 13, 1989 at the age of 63, he announced his retire­ment, effective in September 1990, as principal flutist of the Philadelphia Orchestra. His death was a shock to the musical community and violist Sidney Curtis said he had never seen the […]

The post A Tribute to Murray Panitz appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

  

   A few months before Murray Panitz died from an aneurism on April 13, 1989 at the age of 63, he announced his retire­ment, effective in September 1990, as principal flutist of the Philadelphia Orchestra. His death was a shock to the musical community and violist Sidney Curtis said he had never seen the Philadelphia Orchestra so demoralized. At a memorial service at the Academy of Music fami­ly, friends, and colleagues spoke of Panitz’ warmth, generosity, wit, and magnificent play­ing. He endeared himself to others not only with his sense of humor, but also with his effortless musical ability.
   One month before his death Panitz spoke lightheartedly about his retirement, saying he planned to move to Louisville, Kentucky where he would enjoy teaching, giving master classes, and gardening. "I’ll have more time to myself. I might even practice."
   Reminiscing about his early music study Panitz said, "When I was only five years old, I went to the Settlement Music School in New York but was too young to study the piano. I was placed in a boys’ chorus where I sang soprano. I ap­peared as a soloist in two film shorts with two singers from the Metropolitan Opera: baritone Lawrence Tibbett and tenor Richard Crooks. The only thing I remember about my experience is that each singer gave me a box of candy, but my father and brother devoured them before I could."
   Panitz began to study the piano when he was seven years old. He was a talented student with an excellent memory, and could finish a book in a week. Panitz later entered the High School of Music and Art, now Performing Arts High School, in New York City. Two of his fellow students were pianist Myrna Rubinstein whom he later married, and bassoonist Bernard Gar­field, who became the principal bassoonist in the Philadelphia Orchestra.
   The school required each music student to study a second instrument and a teacher told him he would play the flute. "I didn’t even know what a flute was, and wasn’t interested in it. One teacher, a clarinet player, taught me so many wrong fingerings I’m surprised I could get a sound out of the instrument. When I took my first real lesson, however, I was hooked."
   Panitz studied in New York with Harry Moskowitz and William Heim, a former piccolo player in the New York Philharmonic. "My claim to fame in high school was that future Miss America Bess Myerson was in my class and she also played the flute, sitting next to me in the band. Frequently I heard, ‘Sonny, move over’ while they took her picture."
   When he was only 16, Panitz entered the Eastman School of Music. The flutists who at­tended Eastman at the same time included Doriot Anthony Dwyer, Robert Willoughby, Walfrid Kujala, and Roger Stevens. They all studied with Joseph Mariano. "He was one of the world’s greatest flutists. Most things came easily to me so that I didn’t have to work too hard. Who knows? I could have been a success if I had practiced."
   During Panitz’ freshman year, Mariano en­couraged him to audition for the Chicago Sym­phony. "I could play a lot of notes, but I only knew a few lines of orchestral pieces from an ex­cerpt book. At the audition the conductor pointed to other passages in the music, but I didn’t have any idea how they should be played. From that point on I never wanted to see an ex­cerpt, only a complete part."
   After graduating from Eastman, Panitz was named principal flutist of the National Sym­phony. A short time later he was drafted into the U.S. Air Force and stationed in Washington D.C. where he played in the Air Force Band.
   "The concert master of the orchestra suggested that I play in the orchestra, but the command­ing officer disliked me because I was not a career man. He said, ‘I wouldn’t use Murray Panitz if he were the first flute in the Philadelphia Or­chestra.’"
   When Panitz left the Air Force, he moved to New York rather than re­turn to the National Symphony. He studied at the Manhattan School of Music where he earned a graduate degree in music theory. Eventually he became a successful free-lance flutist in New York. He enjoyed playing first flute in the Symphony of the Air, the Little Orchestra Society of New York, the New York City Ballet, as well as for shows and television productions such as The Producer’s Showcase, The Defenders; and The Bell Telephone Hour.
   "My first break in New York was when Albert Goltzer, an oboist who later joined the New York Philhar­monic, was walking down the street with one of the biggest contractors in town. We stopped and greeted each other. The contractor needed a flutist and had exhausted his entire list of flute players. Goltzer said, ‘Why don’t you use Murray Panitz?’ He did.
   "Playing in New York was fun be­cause there were excellent musicians. At that time, the option to take a sym­phonic job was not ideal because the salary was poor. When I joined the Philadelphia Orchestra, we played a 30-week season, maybe 6 weeks in the summer, and the pay was around $6500 a year. Most of the players had to sell ice cream or used cars in the off season to make ends meet. I took a pay cut to join the orchestra, but this was my life’s dream."
    Conductor Eugene Ormandy in­vited Panitz to audition for the Philadelphia Orchestra in 1961 along with 13 other flutists. "I played for about 20 minutes. Afterwards, Or­mandy asked me to come into his of­fice, and he offered me the job. One of my closest friends told me I was crazy to leave New York to go to Philadelphia. He told me I would be giving up 50 tax withholding slips for one.
   "As soon as I arrived in Philadel­phia the orchestra went on strike for six weeks. Never being a saver but rather a spender, I found it was very difficult to make ends meet. People were still calling me for jobs in New York, but I had to be in Philadelphia when they settled the contract nego­tiations.
   "During the strike, the orchestra per­formed a memorial concert for Dag Hammarskjold at the U.N., and we played Beethoven’s 9th. This was the first time I played with the orchestra and Eugene Ormandy. I have to thank my bassoonist friend Bernie Garfield for warning me not to play with the conductor’s beat, especially because I was used to television where one needs to react immediately to the beat. This orchestra under Ormandy had a delayed beat, but it was incredi­ble how accurately everyone played. The attacks were fantastically together. I could see Ormandy’s hand go down and then, somehow, every­one came in at the right time. It was scary. The concert went well, and I didn’t get a pioneer medal, as we said in those days, for making an early at­tack.
   "Once when we were on tour, we tried to get Ormandy to make us play with the beat. After our concert­master, Anshel Brusilow, had spoken to the maestro about the idea, Or­mandy called me backstage before the concert. ‘You’re the concertmaster of the winds,’ he said. ‘From now on we play with the beat.’
   "I returned to the stage and gave the winds the message. The first half of the concert was chaotic. At intermis­sion, I was again summoned by an up­set and irate Ormandy. Glaring at Brusilow, he said, ‘It’s all your fault. We go back to the way we always play.’"
   When Panitz won the position of principal flute in the Philadelphia Or­chestra, the playing of former prin­cipal flutist William Kincaid was a vivid memory for Philadelphia audi­ences. "Following a legend like Kin­caid was difficult. He was a great player, and, besides, he had much more hair."
   Soon after he took the job in the Philadelphia Orchestra, Panitz realized that it would be important for him to establish his own musical personality. "A few weeks before one of the first recording sessions I did with orches­tra, Ormandy asked me if I had ever played Scheherazade. ‘No, sir,’ I replied.
   "’Do you know that we’re going to record it?’ ‘That’s nice,’ I said.
   "’Have you ever heard our orches­tra play it?’ ‘No.’
   "’Have you ever heard Kincaid do the solos?’ ‘No.’ I could see that Or­mandy was getting edgy. ‘Well, I’ll let you have another recording of Scheherazade we made, and you can listen to it.’ ‘Thank you very much, Maestro. I’ll listen to it as soon as the recording session is over.’
   "I had decided that as great as Kin­caid was, I was not going to be his mimic. Either I was going to stay in Philadelphia under my own name or leave."
   Although Panitz wanted to express his own musical ideas, he admired Kincaid and acknowledged Kincaid’s influence on American flute playing.
   "Basically it’s a concept of sound. Kincaid was able to produce a big sound by using more embouchure, unlike the Quantz method of covering more of the hole while ascending into the upper register. I don’t enjoy a trumpet-like sound in the low register and a shrill piccolo sound in the up­per register. I want consistent sound in all registers. A more edgy sound is possible in the low register, for exam­ple, as an alternate color.
   "I use vibrato as a variation in tone color. I use a range of depths and speeds to help me interpret the music. That doesn’t mean everyone will agree with my interpretation, but I have to work within my natural abili­ty. A flutist can’t play the Afternoon of a Faun solo and the Brahms 4th solo with the same vibrato. If the vibrato is too fast for the Debussy solo, it sounds like the Faun is neurotic and in need of a psychiatrist; rather, the sound should be placid and warm, not edgy. On the other hand, Brahms’ 4th needs an electric, exciting tone because that is what the music demands.
   "It’s not sufficient to have a beautiful sound. I like to hear a flutist interpret with a full range of dynamics and a controlled sound. A musician should know how to interpret music, giving it direction and flow, adding rubato to give the music a human ele­ment. We are not metronomical in­struments. If you put a metronome to any recorded piece of music, you won’t be able to keep it with the beat for more than a few measures.
   "The push today is towards robot­like playing, perfect technique, perfect rhythm, without saying much. Music is an emotional and aural response. If given a choice I would rather have the emotional response. I tire of a beau­tiful sound that says nothing."

The post A Tribute to Murray Panitz appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Tonguing and Attacks /april-may-2021-flute-talk/tonguing-and-attacks/ Thu, 29 Apr 2021 20:47:03 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/tonguing-and-attacks/    Flutists argue about ways to tongue. Some allow the tip of the tongue to show between the lips, whereas others feel such a practice is obscene or tabu. On the other hand, some conclude the French tongue faster, which does not mean better, because their enunciation is dryer and crisper than those who speak […]

The post Tonguing and Attacks appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

   Flutists argue about ways to tongue. Some allow the tip of the tongue to show between the lips, whereas others feel such a practice is obscene or tabu. On the other hand, some conclude the French tongue faster, which does not mean better, because their enunciation is dryer and crisper than those who speak other languages. Practicing solfege helps articulation, but those who tongue fastest and best are those who practice tonguing, for which there are no shortcuts. During practice one discovers fascinating things about the flute and self. If something works, by all means do it, even if it means sticking out your tongue.
   Consider logically what tonguing and attacks should not do:

 

  • Break the notes, which can happen if the lip aperture is either too close or too far from the edge of the mouthpiece.
  • Alter the quality of the sound; staccato at whatever speed only slightly interrupts the tone.
  • Weaken the dynamics.
  • Slow the tempo.
  • Be too obvious to the listener.
  • Be without variation.


   The range of articulation begins with legato, meaning tied, for slurred notes; staccato, which means separated or detached; louré, comparable to a slightly interrupted bowing (sometimes erroneously called legato); modulated tonguing to be separated without interrupting the sound; to dotted; to spiccato. Years ago the tear drop mark over the notes did not imply the note should be louder, but rather, there should be space around the note; for example, see Couperin’s Concert Royal No. 4, "Rigaudon."
   Neither the tempo of the passage nor the player’s musical taste should dictate single or double tonguing. No listener should be able to detect one from the other; in fact, practicing scales correctly allows the player to switch from single to double tonguing unnoticeably.
   If the tongue is too far back in the mouth, the attack will be fuzzy, broken, or too loud. Without placing the tongue between the lips, it should be as close to the aperture as possible. By tonguing long notes between the lips, the tongue moves only back­wards. When preparing to tongue a long note, the tip of the tongue shows slightly. With support also prepared, (the softer or more difficult the attack, the stronger the support) impercep­tibly release a bit of air through the nose; then to start the sound, pull fast on the tongue to make a proper at­tack. During my tenure with the Or­chestre de Paris, I developed this tech­nique playing under great conductors, some who had unclear beats. If this type of attack helps create a better sound, live with it and develop the procedure.
   For a proper concept of staccato, do not use too much air. Experiment by listening to the way a staccato run sounds at the end of your breath just before you run out. For a forte low register or pianissimo high register stac­cato inhale very little if you can afford it; if the passage is long, support the tone but hold back on the volume. For staccato runs, it is not possible to let the tongue show on every note. Although some French teachers re­quest entire passages be played in this manner, they are not in the majority.
   Try to create the staccato sound more through the stability of the left hand than with the volume of air. Don’t blow like an ox to get a big sound, and don’t let the cheeks be flappy. Otherwise you will have slop­py attacks and a fuzzy staccato. The air should vibrate, not the face. Keep in mind the staccato articulation inter­rupts the sound on every note and takes the dynamic level down at least one level: forte becomes mezzo forte, and piano becomes pianissimo. If you need to play a louder staccato focus more and keep the stability in the left hand. For an echo effect, play forte to fortissimo, then echo by playing a stac­cato articulation, which is better than systematically fighting the instru­ment.
   Adapt the staccato to the music being played. You will not tongue the same way in Syrinx as you would for Berio’s Sequenza or in Brahms’ Sym­phony No. 2. Practice staccato on a wide array of scales in all keys at all tempos and at every dynamic level each week. The tempo should be com­fortable, not fast. Establishing the proper tempo is essential and is the common denominator between fin­gers and tonguing. Don’t try to slam the tongue with clumsy fingers, or slap the fingers using a heavy tongue.
   Practice by repeating notes: play twice each note of a scale using double or triple tonguing; on another scale repeat each note three times, then four, six, and finally eight times using Scale Games 12-16. Practice eight notes plus one, as in Scale Games 39, and use off-balance attacks and stac­cato for Scale Games 41-42. Try single tonguing without the tongue, using support only, as in Scale Game 5. Then practice double tonguing with only the ku syllable in Scale Game 58. Finally, use a composite of single and double tonguing for Scale Games 29 and 30.
   Although this is a slow process, it is the only way to practice staccato. A solid articulation is like having a set of tools in your pocket that you can use without thinking about it, just as we speak in our native tongue. 





The post Tonguing and Attacks appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Memorizing Concerti Through Positive Visualizations /april-may-2021-flute-talk/memorizing-concerti-through-positive-visualizations/ Tue, 27 Apr 2021 22:34:17 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/memorizing-concerti-through-positive-visualizations/    Preparing to give high-pressure performances is a process many flutists experience throughout their careers. This can be an incredibly revealing and rewarding process, allowing an opportunity to discover many things about yourself as a musician and person. This past fall, I performed the Trail of Tears Concerto for Flute and Chamber Orchestra by Michael […]

The post Memorizing Concerti Through Positive Visualizations appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

   Preparing to give high-pressure performances is a process many flutists experience throughout their careers. This can be an incredibly revealing and rewarding process, allowing an opportunity to discover many things about yourself as a musician and person. This past fall, I performed the Trail of Tears Concerto for Flute and Chamber Orchestra by Michael Daugherty with the Manhattan School of Music Chamber Sinfonia. This performance was by far the most nerve-wracking performance of my life, but it was also one of the most incredible experiences. It served as a true test of my ability to control my thoughts and commit to positivity throughout my preparation process.
   During this process, I had to navigate a lot of negative thoughts. Over the past few years, I’ve spent much of my time trying to manage common feelings of fear, self-doubt and insecurity that nearly all flutists experience at some point throughout their careers. I began researching effective memorization strategies and practicing them through trial and error the summer before this performance. I failed a lot during this process, but these failures led me to discover an incredibly reliable and effective method of preparation that I will continue to use. The final performance of this piece was incredibly successful, and something I am very proud of.
   After spending months working closely with my private teacher, Linda Chesis, and performing this piece in a masterclass for Christina Jennings, I was encouraged to try out the “positive visualization” method of preparation. At this point, I had already put in a great amount of memorization work through score studying and individual practice. I had performed movements of this piece from memory and had given one full run-through for an audience. Before I implemented this element of mental preparation, I was unable to make it through a complete run through of this piece from memory for an audience without feeling extremely uncomfortable or having at least one memory slip. My greatest challenge was overcoming self-doubt, and this positive visualization method allowed me to work through my fears and insecurities rooted in performance anxiety.




One Month Prior

   Beginning 30 days before my performance, I started to set aside 20 minutes each day to conduct one positive visualization of myself performing this concerto. A positive visualization is a form of meditation that includes visualizing something you want, seeing it, feeling it, and believing it. For musicians, this involves visualizing all aspects of a performance or audition in as much detail as possible from start to finish. These visualizations can be done sitting in a comfortable position or lying on your back. They can be done with your eyes open in a soft gaze or closed. I recommend picking a time of day that you feel most energetic to conduct your visualizations. For me, this was in the morning before my first class of the day. It is crucial to leave enough time for this visualization so that you do not feel rushed. Feeling rushed may compromise your ability to focus which is the most important part. I chose to conduct most visualizations away from my flute so that I could really test my memory with each and every note of this piece and not be tempted to play along.
   I began each positive visualization in a comfortable and quiet place in my room and closed my eyes, beginning by visualizing how standing backstage would feel before I walked out in front of the audience for this concerto performance. Since I was performing in the Manhattan School of Music’s Neidorff-Karpati Hall, I was fortunate to have a good mental image of how this hall looked and felt as it served as the home of all orchestra rehearsals and concerts. This allowed me to visualize the backstage area in great detail. If you are beginning a positive visualization, and you do not know how the backstage area looks, you can imagine a generalized version of a backstage area. If you are able, search online for a picture of the hall and the backstage area or consider reaching out to a personnel manager to ask if they can describe the stage for you.
   After becoming visually comfortable backstage, I imagined myself walking out to the center of the main stage with confidence in the exact shoes and dress that I was planning to wear for the performance. This element of the visualization is incredibly important, especially if you have not yet performed in the outfit you plan to wear. I imagined myself greeting a full audience and smiling at them, thanking them all for being there. At this point, I began to feel waves of self doubt entering my mind. I noticed my mind beginning to convince myself that I would have a memory slip or make a mistake, causing the audience to boo me off the stage. Each time this happened, I would acknowledge this thought and tell it “no,” immediately following with a positive counterthought such as “I am excited to share this work I have done with the audience” or “I feel prepared and confident to give the best performance of my life.” Acknowledging and shutting down negative thoughts proved to be difficult at first, but the more I did it during mental visualizations, the more effectively I was able to do so during my physical run-throughs.
   During the first two weeks I conducted my visualizations while listening to Amy Porter’s incredible recording of the Trail of Tears Concerto since I had not yet had the opportunity to work with the orchestra. It was important for me to continue hearing the orchestrated version in order to aurally memorize where the different parts of the accompaniment would switch instruments. When preparing for a concerto performance, it is helpful to know where each new sound is coming from in the orchestra so that you are prepared for these differences from the piano reduction during the first rehearsal. Being able to sing the flute melody in your head as you are playing adds an additional level of security to your memorization, and spending this time listening to this recording improved my overall level of understanding and connection to the piece.
   After I visualized myself walking out confidently in front of the audience, I turned on the recording on my phone and imagined myself playing it from start to finish, deciding how I would use the time in between movements and the time I had onstage when I was not playing. Positive visualizations take an incredible amount of focus and concentration, something that proved very difficult at first. Starting this process 30 days before the performance gave me enough time to develop this level of concentration so that it was resilient by the time I stepped in front of the audience.

Two Weeks Prior
   I stopped listening to the recording during my daily positive visualizations two weeks before the date of my performance. The first few attempts after removing this element provided many new challenges, but it also helped me to level up in my preparation. My daily visualizations now became a test of my memorization of the orchestral accompaniment and generating a deeper understanding of how my solo part fit into the overall piece. This step forward included a much higher level of concentration as I no longer allowed myself to have a solid recording to rely on. I experienced days where I had complete memory slips in my visualizations and was unable to keep going. When these memory slips happened in my visualizations, I made a mental note to go back and work on this spot later, but I also forgave myself and told myself, “these things happen, and it does not define your worth as a musician.” As soon as I completed the visualization, I took out a hard copy of my score to study and mark that specific part to prioritize it in my next practice session.
   Experiencing all of these memory slips during my visualization process strengthened my confidence overall. The memory slips never occurred in the same place, meaning that I was working through all of the possible pitfalls I might have, decreasing my chances of having memory slips in the actual performance. I identified and strengthened all of the spots I was least comfortable with. I have learned to love failure as a part of the learning process. If you never fail, that means you are never allowing yourself to take risks and push your boundaries.

One Week Prior
   I started to experience physical symptoms of nerves and performance anxiety one week before the performance. Rehearsals with the orchestra had begun, and although they were going really well, I was experiencing a loss of appetite, constant jitters and a general inability to focus. My daily positive visualizations helped me work through how to handle these symptoms and center my mind. The mental and physical preparation I had put in both on and away from my instrument provided a vital safety net during times of low energy and focus levels, and the meditative component of these daily positive visualizations provided me with an ability to calm myself down during times of high energy and anxiety. Although my mind continued to jump to all of the “what ifs,” I was able to effectively acknowledge these negative thoughts, counteract them, and re-center to a positive and confident mindset.
   This week posed unique challenges that I had prepared myself for during my visualizations. In the hall that I was performing in, there are multiple windows on the back doors that allow you to see people walking by in the hallway, sometimes stopping to watch you perform through the glass. Some people even walked in and out during the dress rehearsals and recorded bits of my playing. I asked friends and colleagues to sit in on the dress rehearsals so that I could better visualize faces of people I may see during my performance, which was incredibly helpful and supportive of them. Although I thoroughly prepared for all of these possible situations to occur throughout my daily visualizations, it was helpful to experience everything in person and greatly improved the details of my positive visualization the next day.

Day of Performance
   The day of my concerto performance of Trail of Tears began with a dress rehearsal with the orchestra. After thoroughly warming up on my instrument, I actively chose not to do a visualization in the morning because I wanted to give myself one last chance to test my memorization without my usual safety net. During the dress rehearsal I felt calm and confident, and I used my positive visualization skills to visualize myself wearing the dress and shoes I had chosen for my performance later that evening while I was physically playing with orchestra. I welcomed any and all distractions. During this run-through, people were coming in and out of the hall with cameras, taking photographs and recordings to post on the Manhattan School of Music social media accounts. I convinced myself that if I was able to fully concentrate through all of this, then I was set for nearly anything that may happen during the performance. I left the dress rehearsal feeling confident and I tried to manifest positivity for the remainder of the day by putting away my flute and focusing on the present.
   This plan worked for a few hours until the usual symptoms of performance anxiety began to settle in. I took the afternoon to greet my family that came in town for this performance to take my mind off of things, and then I returned to my room three hours prior to the performance to make sure I ate a nutritious meal, drank water, and gave myself time to re-center. My piece was scheduled at the very end of the concert, so I also had to account for the time that I would have sitting backstage in a dressing room. An hour and a half prior to the beginning of the concert, I took my dress and makeup into the dressing room and began to get ready. This left one hour during the concert to make any final mental preparations. I found myself pacing back and forth in the dressing room, growing increasingly distracted and anxious. I took this time to go through one final positive visualization, and this one proved to be the most difficult and the most important. Since the performance was so close, I made sure to incorporate the energy and passion I wanted to share with the audience into this visualization. I also recited positive mantras to myself throughout including “I am prepared,” “I am confident.” “I am excited to give this performance.” This final visualization helped me to center and quiet my mind, focusing all of my energy on giving the best performance of my ability.
   As it became time to wait backstage, my heart was pounding and I noticed feelings of self-doubt starting to creep in again. I was able to acknowledge these thoughts and let them go because I was used to doing so every time they would appear throughout my daily visualizations. Once I was on the stage, I felt in control and confident. I was able to effectively manage and play confidently through any minor mistakes that happened, and I experienced an overwhelming feeling of connection to the audience throughout. I was truly able to let go and trust my preparation.
   This performance was one of my most successful performances to date, and I credit most of this success to all of the mental work I did in preparation. Prior to this performance, mental work played a minor role in my preparation process for auditions, competitions and performances. I now realize how important mental preparation is for all musicians, especially if you frequently experience performance anxiety like I do. Positive visualizations can benefit musicians in any setting including orchestral auditions, school placement auditions, competitions, and any type of performance. The most important thing is committing to the details during these visualizations and acknowledging any negative thought that may come up and counteracting it with a positive one. The more you continue doing these positive visualizations, the more confident you will become with your playing. This mental preparation allows you to work through any insecurity and self-doubt you may experience and come out as a resilient flutist on the other side.

The post Memorizing Concerti Through Positive Visualizations appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Mixing It Up /april-may-2021-flute-talk/mixing-it-up/ Tue, 27 Apr 2021 18:30:00 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/mixing-it-up/ Harmonics    Beginning practice with harmonics is an excellent idea as it reminds the flutist how the flute overblows to the upper partials. Harmonics also help set the embouchure for the golden notes – those in the upper middle octave. Georges Barrère suggested using the setting of the third harmonic partial for the all-purpose embouchure. […]

The post Mixing It Up appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>


Harmonics

   Beginning practice with harmonics is an excellent idea as it reminds the flutist how the flute overblows to the upper partials. Harmonics also help set the embouchure for the golden notes – those in the upper middle octave. Georges Barrère suggested using the setting of the third harmonic partial for the all-purpose embouchure. The English flutist Geoffrey Gilbert recommended something quite similar in using one of the middle octave left-hand notes (G, A, or B) to set the embouchure. Usually, flutists practice harmonics low to high, but what if for this month, you switched to practicing them high to low? This is more difficult because your ear has to remember what the top pitch sounds like and what the position of the lips has to be in to be successful.

 
From The Flute Scale Book by Patricia George & Phyllis Avidan Louke, Published by Presser, Chapter 3.





De la Sonorite

   The first exercise in this book by Marcel Moyse is a go to for most flutists. Rather than playing it as written, what about playing it as a third harmonic partial? To do this, finger a low E to a D# overblowing for the B and A#. Michel Debost said that Moyse always intended this exercise to be played with vibrato. Playing vibrato cycles on a harmonic note offers resistance; however, when followed with the notes with the regular fingerings, the vibrato is free and spinning. Play the first pair of notes at the harmonic and on the repeat with the regular fingering. On the descending part of this exercise, the F# (overblown from the low B) is the last of this exercise you can play at the harmonic. Remember to repeat this idea when playing the ascending part of this exercise.

 
Marcel Moyse: De la Sonorite

 


Five-note patterns
   Rather than starting the five-note patterns on the low D as it is written in 17 Big Daily Exercises by Taffanel & Gaubert, start at the top of the flute on a G ascending to the top D and back down. Then repeat starting on each chromatic note until reaching low C. Doing this with the HAH or breath attack certainly gets the air moving on a lazy day.

 
From The Flute Scale Book by Patricia George & Phyllis Avidan Louke, Published by Presser, Chapter 5.

 
Scales
   There are so many ways to play scales yet we always start on middle C on the piano. This is a good idea if we were pianists because C major has no sharps or flats. For the flutist starting on low C means that the right-hand pinkie is out of the position of function and having the finger in this position adds tension to the right hand, arm, shoulder etc. Why not start the scale cycle on F major or on G major where the flute is better balanced in the hand and then progressing around the Circle of Fifths practicing C major last in the cycle? I usually start in F major and progress major/minor around the circle of fifths ending with C major and a minor.

 
Top Octave
   We all avoid practicing in the top octave if possible. The fingerings are awkward, and they take a lot of air and a smaller aperture. To overcome avoidance of the issue, I remind myself that today’s high notes will be tomorrow’s low notes. Daily practice of a one octave chromatic scale from D6 to D7 up and down reaps many benefits. Start slowly with the metronome and try to increase the speed a little each week. Becoming more familiar with the fingering combinations means that those top octave passages in repertoire become easier and controllable.

 
Vibrato and Articulation
   Using a hymnal, play the soprano line of a few hymns each day with measured or counted vibrato. To prepare for accurate vibrato cycles, tongue each quarter four times, a dotted quarter six times etc. using first T, then K, then HAH and finally with vibrato cycles. This exercise keeps the vibrato and articulation even and under control. This exercise also improves the technique of moving fingers up and down exactly in time because of the counting of the subdivisions with the metronome.




Etudes

   The etudes of Ernesto Kohler are some of the best written for the flute; but most of us are only familiar with the first set in his Op. 33. Check out
for other opuses such as Op. 75, 30, 82, 89, 66, and 60. Download and play away. You will soon figure out that Kohler has one zinging part (chromatic major seconds at a fast tempo) in each etude that will need a little bit of extra attention. Figuring out the best grouping and chunking solutions to play these few measures is quite beneficial to your entire approach to music.

 
Coda
   One last thing that I have done for years at the end of the university term is to take one of methods (Altes, Popp, Soussmann, Taffanel et Gaubert, Gariboldi, Moyse) and play it cover to cover pretending I am a novice player in the beginning pages and progressing through the advanced pages. (For the series of etudes that are not in one book such as the Moyse works, I begin with the De la Sonorite and 24 and 25 melodies progressing through the etudes and studies finishing with the 48 difficult exercises. I read every direction and consider what the author was proposing in his pedagogical treatise. I always get new ideas to apply to my own playing and teaching.  

The post Mixing It Up appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>