February 2014 Archives - The Instrumentalist /category/february-2014-flute-talk/ Thu, 13 Feb 2014 19:58:38 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 What My Flute Means To Me /february-2014-flute-talk/what-my-flute-means-to-me/ Thu, 13 Feb 2014 19:58:38 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/what-my-flute-means-to-me/ My flute means many different things to me. My flute is my time machine. She puts me in touch with the music of the past as well as the present. I can visit people of the past by playing their beautiful flute music. For example, I can journey to Europe in the 18th century when […]

The post What My Flute Means To Me appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

My flute means many different things to me.

My flute is my time machine. She puts me in touch with the music of the past as well as the present. I can visit people of the past by playing their beautiful flute music. For example, I can journey to Europe in the 18th century when I play music of the Baroque era. I can visualize myself playing for people in powdered wigs who are doing the minuet at the Court of Louis XIV. I can watch people dancing the waltz in the 19th century to my flute accompaniment. Since flute in some manner has been used virtually throughout history, I have a wide gamut of choices for my travels.

My flute is my cheap psychiatrist. I can be so thoroughly absorbed in practicing and playing my flute that nothing else matters. I can forget that the world exists when the effort becomes intense. If I have a plane ride (yes, I am a bit phobic about flying), I always read my flute music and picture myself playing as the plane is taking off. My concentration works the same way.

My flute is my obnoxious sister when practicing doesn’t go easily. She’ll say that she’s not going to cooperate. I’ll wheedle and cajole and try every angle to have smooth going. Eventually, she’ll give in. Or not. Sometimes I just have to try to convince her on a different day to allow me to play a passage properly.

Sometimes my flute is my best friend. When she is with me, she enjoys the music as much as I do. We smile at each other and share the same thoughts. Sometimes my flute is my appreciative audience. I’m playing for her and she loves it.

Other times, my flute is my teacher. Often she channels Mr. Quantz or other writers of how to flute manuals. She listens to what they have to say and explains to me their advice. Then I play better.

My flute is also my Santa Claus because she brings me many gifts. She gives me the gift of feeling like a rich lady because I have such a beautiful, shiny instrument that sings to me very sweetly.

She gives me the gift of belonging to a community. She not only shows me that I am part of the chain of all flute players who ever lived but she also makes me feel welcomed in the society of those who play this beautiful instrument today. (She helped me to be part of more than 2,000 flutists who set a Guinness Book of World Records record for a massed flute choir at the National Flute Association Convention in New York City.)

Most important though, my flute is my security blanket. Everything is all right when I have my flute with me.

So – what does my flute mean to me? In one word, my flute means LOVE.

The post What My Flute Means To Me appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Teaching in Dublin /february-2014-flute-talk/teaching-in-dublin/ Thu, 13 Feb 2014 19:55:53 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/teaching-in-dublin/     In 2005 I had the opportunity to move from the United States to teach at the Dublin Institute of Technology (DIT) in the Conservatory of Music and Drama. Besides being a third-level institution that serves full-time students in degree programs (undergraduate and postgraduate), there is also a Junior Conservatory for primary and secondary students. […]

The post Teaching in Dublin appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

    In 2005 I had the opportunity to move from the United States to teach at the Dublin Institute of Technology (DIT) in the Conservatory of Music and Drama. Besides being a third-level institution that serves full-time students in degree programs (undergraduate and postgraduate), there is also a Junior Conservatory for primary and secondary students. The school also accommodates part-time adult students. Originally, this teaching position was to be a short-term post as I was replacing a professor on sabbatical. However, on that person’s return, I was invited to remain on and in September 2012, I was appointed to the position of pro-rata part-time assistant lecturer in flute. I also had begun teaching in other private music schools. At the time, I never could have imagined how teaching in another country would change my life and how much I would gain from this experience.
    Starting life in a new country presented many challenges. Fortunately, everyone speaks English although students learn Irish in schools. I was a bit reluctant to drive on the left side of the road and did not have a car initially so I relied on the buses and learned how to get around easily and efficiently. One aspect of living in Ireland that I have always found fascinating is how compact it is compared to the United States. One can literally drive or take a train to anywhere on the Island and get there within hours.

Teaching
    When I first arrived in Dublin, I also had to get acquainted with a different system of teaching music. Living in Ireland has presented some wonderful challenges and has opened my eyes to many new and different methods of teaching and approaches to learning.
    Having grown up in the States, I was a product of the marching band system. Although there are bands that perform at various functions and at athletic events in Ireland, marching bands are not as commonplace in the Republic of Ireland or in Europe in general, as they are in the United States. The primary level schools that have music focus on teaching singing or Irish music. (The tin whistle is a popular instrument, much like recorder in U.S. elementary schools, although recorders are also used.) At the secondary level there are choirs, orchestras, and traditional Irish music ensembles (and soloists) in the schools that have music programs.
    Students in Ireland often start on the same types of flutes typically used in the States: closed-hole flutes with the off-set G key and C foot (straight or curved headjoint) and progress to the open-hole (either off-set or in-line G key). In Ireland however, the C-footjoint is more often the preferred option over the B-foot joint.
    Many parents enroll their children in privately owned and operated music schools or schools run through government assistance. All of these charge tuition. At schools such as the DIT Conservatory of Music and Drama and the Royal Irish Academy of Music students audition to be admitted. This would not necessarily be the case in the privately run music schools. At the DIT, all Junior Conservatory and third-level students attend weekly instrumental lessons. The Junior Conservatory students attend theory class and perform in one of the numerous junior ensembles (Sinfonietta, Sinfonia, Prelude Winds, and Concert Band). There are also senior ensembles which could combine third level and junior conservatory students (Symphony Orchestra, Camerata, Wind Ensemble, Big Band, Early Music Ensemble and Irish Traditional Music Ensemble). The Conservatory has many vocal ensembles and instrumental chamber groups as well (at all levels).
    As in the United States, the standard of playing and teaching varies significantly. However, the presence of a structured system of exams in Ireland provides students and teachers with valuable guidance and support. The exams offer students a tangible goal and helps them measure progress over time. The comments provided by the examiner also help to reiterate what teachers have said in lessons.
     Ireland uses various systems for examining students in music. These examining bodies include, but are not limited to, the Royal Irish Academy of Music (RIAM, in Dublin), the Trinity Guildhall School of Music (Trinity College London), and the Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music (ABRSM, in London). At the DIT Conservatory of Music and Drama, the Junior Conservatory exams are based on its syllabi and curriculum, and the Conservatory’s graded music examinations are currently being considered by the National Framework of Qualifications for recognition.
    The students who participate in the practical exams work from a curriculum that provides a list of repertoire (solos/chamber, and studies) and a list of technical requirements (i.e. major/minor/chromatic scales, arpeggios, dominant and diminished seventh chords, scales in thirds, all to be played from memory) for each grade, levels one through eight. A sightreading and aural skills exam is also required and in some cases, theory, improvisation and musical knowledge. Students beyond grade eight may enroll in a certificate or diploma program and the testing requirements for these programs are set by each institution.
    The method books and studies I use with students are often chosen based on the curriculum set out by the various examining boards and supplemented with other resources. Much of the repertoire that a student could use if going in for an exam would actually be published by the associated board. These resources are well organized with thoughtful selections for each grade level and may be purchased with or without a CD.
    All students enrolled in secondary level schools are required to sit a Junior Certificate Exam at the end of their 3rd year, and if they continue, they take a Leaving Certificate Exam at the end of their 6th and final year. Both of these exams are overseen by the State Examinations Commission and require subjects such as English and math. Other subjects are optional, including music. In some cases, music may not even be offered in the student’s school, in which case the student may choose to study music as a subject outside of their school. Many institutions such as the DIT offer courses in Junior and Leaving Certificate Music. In both of these exams there are essential activities on which students are examined: performing skills, composing skills, and listening skills. Currently, the Junior Certificate Programme is in the process of being reformed.
    I currently teach three days a week at the DIT and two days a week at Leeson Park School of Music. I also teach privately out of my studio at home on Saturdays. I do some flute ensemble coaching out of my studio as well.

Performing
    When I first moved to Dublin, I played recitals in the DIT, at Newpark Music Centre in Blackrock (where I taught from 2005 until 2007), the John Field Room at the National Concert Hall and in other venues. I made many contacts in Dublin through a friend of mine and former conductor of the National Symphony Orchestra of Ireland as well as the Mississippi Symphony Orchestra, Colman Pearce. He is actually the reason that I heard of the job in Dublin.
    In the summer of 2012, I formed a professional flute ensemble, Flute Éire. The group consists of piccolo, 4 C-flutes, alto flute, bass flute, and bodhran (traditional Irish drum). The debut performance was in November 2012 at St. Patrick’s College in Drumcondra. We have performed in various venues since then, including at the 2013 National Flute Convention in New Orleans. We have premiered two works by Irish composers John Buckley and Glen Austin. Our focus has mainly been on repertoire by Irish composers.
    When I arrived in Dublin, I was eager to learn about traditional Irish music. I started going to my local pub  and listening to music. I began learning some tunes (slow airs, jigs, reels and some hornpipes). Not being shy, I asked to join in playing with the group and soon began going regularly. I picked up tunes by ear and also found printed music to learn from although it is often not the same as what you hear played because people perform pieces with many variations and different ornamentation. I play Irish music on the silver flute. (There are some traditional Irish flute players who do play on the silver flute and not the wooden flute.)
    I met my now husband through playing traditional music because he plays guitar, banjo, bouzouki, and mandolin. He has a wealth of knowledgeabout traditional Irish music.
    Many of the musicians who perform in the pubs play several times a week. There is typically a group of hired musicians that run the session, and other musicians can join in. Some sessions are very open and friendly, and other people can play along or have a solo. Very often there are regulars who have a signature song or tunes that they perform. I have my own favorites, including Inisheer, Sligo Maid/Star of Munster, and some O’Carolan tunes.
     Ornamentation is extremely important in Irish music. The grace note is very common but is not used in the same way as in the classical style. Grace notes (from above and below – called cutting) are typically used where two notes in a grouping are the same, as between repeated note passages. Other types of ornaments used are rolling, craning, and sliding a note.
    Life is full of surprises that lead us on to the next challenge. Being a teacher has always been my calling, but I never expected to be called to another country. It has been one of the most gratifying experiences for me and one that I would never change.          

For more information on the DIT Conservatory of Music and Drama see the website: .




Marking Scheme by Program
 
Trinity Guildhall:
All practical graded exams are marked out of 100 possible points. If students receive a mark ranging from 87 to 100 they would have the title of Distinction. A mark ranging from 75 to 86 would be a Merit, from 60 to 74 would be a Pass, from 45-59 would be a Below Pass 1, and 0 to 44 would be a Below Pass 2.
First piece (with accompaniment): Maximum 22 points
Second piece (with accompaniment): Maximum 22 points
Third piece (unaccomp. study or solo): Maximum 22 points
Technical Work: Maximum 14 points
Supporting Test 1: Maximum 10 points
Supporting Test 2: Maximum 10 points

*Supporting Tests would be chosen from the following: Aural Skills, Sightreading, Improvisation, and Musical Knowledge

Associate Board of the Royal Schools of Music
All practical graded exams are marked out of a possible 150 points. The required points to Pass would be 100, to receive a Merit would be 120, and to receive a Distinction would be 130.
First Piece (with accompaniment): Maximum 30 points
Second Piece (with accompaniment): Maximum 30 points
Third Piece (unaccomp. study or solo): Maximum 30 points
Technical Work: Maximum 21 points
Sightreading: Maximum 21 points
Aural Tests: Maximum 18 points

The Royal Irish Academy of Music
All practical graded exams are marked out of a possible 100 points. A candidate who receives 90% or over would be awarded a Distinction, 80% to 89% would be awarded an Honours, 70% to 79% would be awarded a Merit, and 60% to 69% would be awarded a Pass.
First Piece (with accompaniment): Maximum 20 points
Second Piece (with accompaniment): Maximum 20 points
Third Piece (unaccomp. study or solo): Maximum 20 points
Technical Work: Maximum 15 points
Sight-reading: Maximum 10 points
Aural Tests (up to grade V): Maximum 10 points
Aural Tests (grades VI-VIII): Maximum 15 points (no theory test required)
Theory Tests: Maximum 5 points

The post Teaching in Dublin appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
A Conversation with the Minnesota Orchestra Flutists /february-2014-flute-talk/a-conversation-with-the-minnesota-orchestra-flutists/ Thu, 13 Feb 2014 19:49:56 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/a-conversation-with-the-minnesota-orchestra-flutists/     In mid-November the Upper Midwest Flute Association, Inc. presented the Flutists of the Minnesota Orchestra in Recital at the half-day point of Patricia George’s Flute Spa. After the recital the flutists shared some thoughts about their performances.  Can you offer some tips for playing those long lyrical lines in Samuel Barber’s Canzone, Op. 38? […]

The post A Conversation with the Minnesota Orchestra Flutists appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

    In mid-November the Upper Midwest Flute Association, Inc. presented the Flutists of the Minnesota Orchestra in Recital at the half-day point of Patricia George’s Flute Spa. After the recital the flutists shared some thoughts about their performances. 

Can you offer some tips for playing those long lyrical lines in Samuel Barber’s Canzone, Op. 38?

Wendy Williams: Yesterday, I video-recorded my rehearsal with our pianist, Gail Olszewski. When I watched the playback, I realized that some movements with my breaths were interrupting the long lyrical lines in the music. Using that knowledge, I tried to be sure that any movements I made with my body enhanced the music and phrasing rather than detracting from it.

The performance of the Bach Sonata in E Major was one of the best I have ever heard because you paid such attention to Baroque performance practice, but accomplishing this while playing on a modern flute. Why did you choose to perform the Bach?

Roma Duncan: When I became a professional piccolo player, I soon realized that my repertoire had shrunk because the piccolo was not used in the orchestra regularly until the Romantic era. So, for recitals I have been trying to re-examine the early repertoire I learned in conservatory because to play Romantic music well you have to remember that it evolved from the music of the Baroque and Classic eras. 

The Karg-Elert 30 Caprices are some of the best music written for the solo flute. Why did you choose to perform this composition and how did you decide which caprices to group together?

Adam Kuenzel:  I wanted to show these little vignettes in a performance. I tried to get them to have some relationship, one to the other through the choice of keys. Five was plenty. I like the variety. They are short, to the point and interesting. Karg-Elert had lots to say in a short period of time. 

A Fragile Circle written by flutist, Timothy Hagen, requires a wide range of emotions and tonal colors. What were you thinking about to create such a range of colors and dynamics?

Greg Milliren:  This is a very demanding and atmospheric piece that has many opportunities to display different kinds of sounds. You have to figure out how to play very softly and also very loudly and still be in tune. To achieve a wide range of tonal colors I work on changing the size and shape of the oral cavity, experiment with tongue placement and use different syllables at the front of the embouchure. While I have a sound in mind that I am going for, the end result is that all these choices greatly affect the angle of the airstream as it hits the blowing edge. It was both a joy and a challenge to perform a very emotional piece based on Hagen’s feelings about loss and acceptance.

Could you share any thoughts about blending or intonation – the aspects that allow you four to play as one, as you did so well in The Marriage of Figaro?

Wendy Williams: When playing second flute, I listen intently to the other second players: the second clarinet, the second bassoon, and the second oboe. I try to match my intonation with them and also consider my vibrato usage. These instruments use less or no vibrato compared to the flute. In my warm-up each day, I find it useful to play with the tuner on the drone setting. While listening to the drone root, I play arpeggios flattening the third if the chord is major, raising the third if the chord is minor. For the perfect fifth, I sharpen it a bit. I always listen to Adam to match volume, note length, tone color and vibrato speed. The only time I play louder than him is when I am below him in octaves or when I have a more important solo line.

Many of the participants here today are learning to play the piccolo. What advice would you give them?

Roma Duncan: Always play as if you are right. Do everything you can to actually be right and perform accurately with the other players, and then play with confidence. If your approach is timid or hesitant, you will sound wrong.


Meet the Minnesota Orchestra Flute Section

Principal Flute: Adam Kuenzel
Since joining the Minnesota Orchestra in 1990, principal flutist Adam Kuenzel has regularly appeared as soloist at Orchestra Hall. He has premiered two major works for flute and orchestra:  Stanislaw Skrowaczewski’s Fantasies for Flute and Orchestra, Il Piffero della Notte, and Manuel Sosa’s Eloquentia: Espacio para Flauta y Orquesta. A native of Cincinnati, Kuenzel attended the Oberlin Conservatory.

Associate Principal: Greg Milliren
Wisconsin native Greg Milliren, associate principal flute since 2009, studied at the University of Minnesota with Julia Bogorad-Kogan and Immanuel Davis, and at the University of Southern California with Jim Walker. He has had the privilege of performing flute and piccolo in the sections of many major orchestras, including those in Los Angeles, San Francisco, Chicago, Boston, National, Seattle, Detroit, and Colorado, as well as the Russian National Orchestra.

Second Flute: Wendy Williams
Wendy Williams has played second flute with the Minnesota Orchestra since 1992. A graduate of the University of Cincinnati College-Conservatory of Music, Wendy played previously as principal flute with the Houston Ballet, second flute with the Houston Grand Opera and Houston Symphony. She has played two seasons with the Grand Teton Festival Orchestra and has been the honored to join the sections of major orchestras, including those in Chicago, Detroit, Florida, National, Pittsburgh, St. Louis, and St. Paul.

Piccolo: Roma Duncan
Roma Duncan grew up in Newfoundland and earned a bachelor of music in flute performance from McGill University and then a master of music in flute performance at the University of Michigan where she began to seriously study the piccolo. Prior to joining the Minnesota Orchestra in 2003, she was a member of several other orchestras both as a flute and a piccolo player, including the Windsor Symphony Orchestra, Orchestra London Canada, the Fort Wayne Philharmonic, and the Ann Arbor Symphony Orchestra.

The post A Conversation with the Minnesota Orchestra Flutists appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
A Teacher or a Coach /february-2014-flute-talk/a-teacher-or-a-coach/ Tue, 11 Feb 2014 01:59:59 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/a-teacher-or-a-coach/     A very famous destination flute professor was asked, “How do you teach technique? (or substitute articulation, vibrato, phrasing etc.)” The teacher replied, “I don’t know. I never have students with that kind of problem.” What the questioner did not realize is that there are two types of flute professors. One is primarily a teacher […]

The post A Teacher or a Coach appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

    A very famous destination flute professor was asked, “How do you teach technique? (or substitute articulation, vibrato, phrasing etc.)” The teacher replied, “I don’t know. I never have students with that kind of problem.” What the questioner did not realize is that there are two types of flute professors. One is primarily a teacher who assesses a flutist’s playing, makes a plan, and helps the student solve the issues. The other type of flute professor is a coach. A coach works with a flutist, who is already strong in the fundamentals of flute playing, music theory and history, on polishing excerpts, sonatas, concerti, and chamber works.
    I think this division between a teacher and a coach is more obvious in the operatic world. During the course of a career, singers will work with two musicians. First will be a teacher who instructs them in vocal technique and basic repertoire. Then if they are fortunate enough to continue on in an operatic career, the primary work will be with vocal coach who will teach the specific part in the opera that they have been hired to perform. This coach drills vocalists on portraying the roles according to the long-standing traditions of the operatic world. The coach works with singers on proper pronunciation, clear diction, rhythmic accuracy, and phrasing suggestions. Most opera singers continue to work with a vocal coach throughout their careers. However, this coach will not teach the basics of vocal technique.
    February and March are the months for undergraduate and graduate school auditions. In most schools auditions take the form of a mini-lesson lasting from 20 to 60 minutes. In this audition/lesson, flutists perform prepared materials and then the professor works with them on areas where there should be improvement. The professor is auditioning the student’s learning and willingness to learn. During this audition students should also be assessing whether this professor’s style is more of a teacher or a coach.
    In April acceptance letters arrive and students have to decide which school and professor is the best fit. The question should be “Which is a better choice for me – a teacher or a coach?” Ideally it is possible that a flute professor will be equally proficient as a teacher and as a coach, but this is rare as most teachers feel more comfortable with one or the other. For example, one well-known coach told a student, “You need help with projection. Go find someone who can do it and get them to show you how.” A teacher would have shown the student how to do it on the spot. So during the audition students should pay particular attention to the style and content of the lesson and discuss it with their current teachers, so at a later date, they can make an informed choice.
    Making an informed choice means that you have evaluated your playing and know the kind of teaching you need. For example, if you are playing the Jolivet Chant de Linos, which is considered a very difficult work, but are playing the rhythms sloppily, not playing close attention to the articulation marks, playing with the same sound with few or no colors, with no control of the vibrato speed, or using incorrect fingerings, then a teacher who has expertise in developing the fundamentals of flute playing and musicianship will be a better choice for you. The old saying, “Your playing is never better than your fundamentals” is a good one to heed. Once you have the fundamentals under control, then graduate school is the time to consider studying with a professor who is primarily a coach.
    As teachers, we aspire to serve students the best way we can which means we should identify our strengths and shore up our weaknesses. We should strive to be a teacher and a coach, but recognize whether your forte is in more in one area than the other.

How to Develop Teaching Skills
    Outstanding teachers will have solidified or catalogued their thoughts on all the basics of flute playing. Michel Debost’s The Simple Flute is an excellent example of the depth of thought an excellent teacher puts into his playing and teaching. Debost delineates these topics from A to Z and shares his ideas and concepts. He often offers practice suggestions to help players realize the goal.

Getting Started
    On your computer, make a file for each of the basic pedagogical topics. These might include: how to start a beginner, breathing, articulation, dynamics, embouchure, repertoire curriculum (etudes, solos, chamber, concertos, and orchestral excerpts), fingerings, style considerations, set-up of body and flute, playing position, musicianship, intonation, memory, practicing, programming, technique, vibrato etc. As you have a moment to spare here and there over the next few months enter your ideas on teaching each of these topics into the proper file. Then as you teach, think about how you present the topic differently from one student to the next. Can you pinpoint why you taught it one way one day and a different way the next? Enter these ideas into your file.
    If during this process, you have one of those fantastic teaching days when you think of the most brilliant analogy to explain a concept, enter that into the file. Information gleaned from other master teachers also will enrich your files.
    Every few months read over each file and rewrite the entry organizing your thoughts. This step should be repeated at least once a year for many years to come. At a certain point this entry will be good enough that you can print and use it as a handout in your studio teaching and masterclass lectures. (Side note: If you receive too many questions from the students, you know that your handout has not been clearly written.)
The Vibrato Checklist (below) is an example of this type of planning and organizing. Will I reorganize this one checklist day? Of course I will as I have learned that curriculum development is always fluid.

How to Develop Coaching Skills
   Learning to coach is a life-long process that begins the very first time a musician plays with another. If the outcome is good, then either the musician has listened to a lot of music, has had an excellent teacher, or more than likely, just has a strong amount of natural talent. From that initial experience, the best coaches draw upon an outstanding education, a wealth of personal experiences, and innate talent.
    The first step in learning to coach is understanding how to listen. There are two types of listening: active and passive. Passive listening is employed when you hear background music in a restaurant, elevator, or perhaps even in the car. You are aware that it is playing, but are not thinking about the notes or how the composer has manipulated them in composing the piece. Active listening is when you tune in to the music and are aware of the performance and how the composer has organized the notes to create his composition. An active listener is aware of style, form, harmony, orchestration, use of time (tempo, meter, rhythm), as well as how the performer shapes a phrase, makes color choices etc.
    Aaron Copland, American composer, performer, and teacher, gave a series of lectures at the New School in New York City on “What to Listen for in Music” starting in 1937. In 1939 these essays were published, and this small book became popular among non-musicians as well as professional musicians. Copland addressed the idea of active and passive listening and expanded it into three distinct levels. He thought an astute listener would move back and forth between these three levels. The first level is the sensuous or passive listening that is used when listening to background music. This type takes the least amount of concentration. The next level is the expressive and requires some concentration so that a listener can feel the emotion in the music. The last level is the musical level and is what a good coach will do when listening to you play. In the musical level, the listener is aware of the notes themselves and how the composer manipulates them in the composition. While Copland’s book was published 75 years ago, it is still an excellent resource.
    Improving listening skills is a life-long process that develops with performance experiences. Great coaches are almost always experienced performers. They have played the same composition or program over and over many times. When Yo-Yo Ma was asked a decade ago how many times he had played the Dvo˘rák Cello concerto in concert, he replied, “Something over 700 times.” John von Rhein, Chicago Tribune music critic wrote, “Yo-Yo Ma has, of course, played this most popular concerto in the cello repertory countless times, including several Chicago performances. The wonder is that the music never feels stale under his fingers, because he is always finding fresh ways to make it speak to his listeners, as much through his sovereign instrumental command and searching insights as through the sparks he strikes off his orchestral colleagues.” So the bottom line for teachers is to keep performing whether it is in the solo, chamber, or orchestral realm because what you learn from these experiences will make your coaching skills stronger.
    The next step in becoming a coach is to become an educated musician. An educated musician has excellent music theory and music history skills. Theory skills include not only knowing and understanding the subject, but also having exceptional aural abilities. While aural abilities may be practiced and improved upon, the musicians with the strongest set were probably born with them.
    A strong history background means that you know who the composer was, the style period, what the compositional influences were, and are familiar with the composer’s other works. For example, a coach for a woodwind quintet should have listened to and analyzed the compositions and performances of the 17 Beethoven String Quartets. These works along with the Mozart and Haydn String Quartets are the backbone of modern chamber music performance. Bernard Rogers, American composer and teacher of several Pulitzer prize-winning composers, said, “We all eat at the same table, only Beethoven got the first serving.” What he was saying is that Beethoven figured almost everything out and we are simply creating variations on his ideas. His pieces require most of the basic chamber music playing techniques. Once these are understood and explored, then chamber music performances will be more successful.
    While consummate flute professors have achieved a balance in teaching and coaching, it may be your choice to specialize in one or the other. My suggestion though is to talk with students when they are making the important decision of whom to study with next so that they are aware of the distinction between a flute professor who specializes in teaching and one who specializes in coaching. If you discover that you are more comfortable as a teacher, then work on your coaching skills or vice versa in coming months.    


Vibrato Checklist

By Patricia George

Where 
Vocal folds – where you swallow (Air, food, spine core, spine nerves)
Hand on neck: recite the alphabet, feel the vibration

Method
Whistle silent staccato notes
Hah, hah, hah, rest – throat staccato, then slurred
Sh, sh, sh, rest – blow on hand. Move the air not the abdomen

Headjoint Exercises
Use headjoint only (remember muscles learn in chunks)
Plastic bag on headjoint
Post-it strip on vapor trail
Right hand in front of embouchure moving down/up or forward/back

Speed 
High range – faster
Low range – slower
Solo or tutti playing
Too fast on stage sounds like a straight line in audience (PhD dissertation – Moscow)
Artistic musicians match other’s vibrato speed
Tape yourself to evaluate speed
When you start, imagine the vibrato already in motion much like stepping on to a moving train

Control
Spasms: 2:1, 3:1, 4:1 – MM=60 to 80 (Moyse: Vibrating pizzicato)
Patterns: 02320, 0234320, 023454320

Scale Practice with Vibrato
Forward Flow. Kincaid 2341 with 5 vibrato on all the 1s
Practice 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 vibrato per note on scales

Other Suggestions
Practice counted vibrato using hymnals and beginning books
Practice vibrato on harmonics. A harmonic note has some built in resistance so once the resistance is removed, the vibrato will flow more freely.

Color Vibrato
Generally a bit faster. 
Light in the tunnel exercise

Where to Vibrate
1st note of a slur
On any note with an accidental
Note before a skip of a fourth or more
Highest/lowest note of a phrase
All the time

Copyright 2008 by Patricia George
georgeflute@hotmail.com

The post A Teacher or a Coach appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Achieving Balance: A Conversation with Elizabeth Buck /february-2014-flute-talk/achieving-balance-a-conversation-with-elizabeth-buck/ Sun, 09 Feb 2014 23:32:59 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/achieving-balance-a-conversation-with-elizabeth-buck/       I have always been interested in the Eastern and Western philosophies of the meaning of life. How do we balance between work and play? Between day and night? Between good and bad? The yin and yang of life is the duality of opposing forces. As a flutist, I have wondered how to achieve […]

The post Achieving Balance: A Conversation with Elizabeth Buck appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
 


    I have always been interested in the Eastern and Western philosophies of the meaning of life. How do we balance between work and play? Between day and night? Between good and bad? The yin and yang of life is the duality of opposing forces. As a flutist, I have wondered how to achieve balance between the musical and technical, between practicing and performing, between working and having fun. Since graduate school, my mantra has been work hard and play hard.
    At first I took it literally – work hard and play the flute hard. So I practiced every Friday and Saturday evening as if I were already a member of an orchestra. I wanted a symphony job and realized that as long as I was not yet playing in a symphony, I should be practicing as if I were. There is a sense of becoming the person you want to be by acting on it step by step. So I took out the Beethoven Symphonies (or Brahms, or whatever standard repertoire I wanted) and sat down like a principal flutist and read through the parts. I played along with recordings with the volume pumped up and just played and played. Much later, I realized that playing hard is for fun – and I changed my mantra to playing hard means really taking time to relax and have fun.
    I have always been a driven person and my motivation for music and flute came from early fears that I would never be good enough. My elementary school band director was one of the first people to sit me down and say there are always going to be too many flutes, so why not take up another instrument like the oboe. In fact, there was no precedent for an incoming sixth grader to make it into advanced band, which was why they were enticing me with the oboe. Free lessons for six weeks – we’ll give you reeds – here’s an oboe. I took it home and honked on it and thought that I would rather not play an instrument than have to play oboe.
    Flute has always been my love. Before I knew what the flute was, I heard its sound and was mesmerized. Without knowing a thing about the instrument I was able to produce a sound immediately. Years of piano lessons made reading music easy, and I immersed myself in everything I could read. I never practiced for lessons. I was able to do whatever was asked immediately, so I did not understand why people needed to practice. It was not until college that I learned how to practice and why it was so important.

How did your musical journey take you to  Juilliard?
    My older brother went into music first and had a copy of the Juilliard brochure among the many pamphlets and catalogs that colleges send out to prospective students. Picking up the brochure, my hands were trembling. It took me a bit of time to realize that one applies to Juilliard just like any other college or university. My mother insisted that I use music as a backup choice, as I had already enrolled at UC-Berkeley during my senior year of high school and was enrolled as a pre-freshman. She was thrilled that I was applying to Northwestern and Stanford – solid schools that would give me a great academic environment while maintaining my love for music.
    I decided to apply for Juilliard and will never forget the frigid blast of March air that greeted me upon landing at Newark International Airport. As a Californian, I had never seen snow. It was daunting to walk into the audition room. Julius Baker, Samuel Baron, and Paula Robison were on the faculty then. I played Ibert Concerto and remember feeling dazzled by being no less than six feet away from the best flutists in the world. My twin sister also applied for Juilliard, and she got a letter almost immediately regretting that she had been denied acceptance. It broke our hearts, and I wondered if my letter had gotten lost in the mail. Weeks went by and I had a feeling that maybe, just maybe, I might get in.
    About six weeks later, a thin envelope arrived from the Juilliard School and back in those days, a slim letter meant denial. Slowly, dejectedly, I opened the letter and read: Congratulations, you have been accepted for entrance to The Juilliard School. What a moment. Stunned, I thought, they must have made a mistake. How could I have been good enough?
    All lives have a path, and this was an unmistakable road sign that I should pursue music. I moved to NYC and then was absolutely miserable the first two years. My sister ended up at Oberlin, where she lived in a dorm and had a cafeteria. By contrast this was the era before dorms at Juilliard, and I took a room at the local YMCA, with no refrigerator, no microwave and only a hotplate. Money was so tight that I documented down to the last penny everything I spent and earned. Phone calls were so expensive that I wrote my mother a postcard every day. How I longed to be in a regular university environment.

What were your studies like at Juilliard.
    This period of my life produced lots of questioning and inquiry about going into music. Was I doing the right thing? Was I on track for success? What is success? Did I want to stay at Juilliard? I put on the notorious freshman fifteen because there was no one to stop me from eating a pint of Haagen-Dazs ice cream for dinner. I walked everywhere, blocks and blocks at a time, because the subway was dangerous and too expensive. All the other flute students were incredible – Renee Krimsier, Susan Hoeppner, Marina Piccinini, Les Roettges, Amy Porter, to name just a few. Thomas Robertello, one other flutist and I were the lowly freshmen class.
    I chose to study with Sam Baron because he was an artist and such an amazing musician. Every lesson was an explanation on how to do something – how to pick out the chordal and harmonic structure of a work, how to teach, how to explain things. I remember being impatient for wanting to play and perform, not discuss scales and theoretical analysis and pedagogical information. He always wanted us to bring a music manuscript notebook to our lessons, as he often wrote out examples and exercises. To this day I still have every page and every notebook. There is so much information that Baron gave me, even though I sometimes did not process it at the time. It is something that happens generally for all young adults: the information is there, but until we are ready, we will not understand and learn. When we are ready to learn, we are our own teachers. So much of my present teaching is based on the fundamentals of what Baron taught. He taught that “full sound is produced when the embouchure hugs the airstream.” Tone colors are not the same as dynamics, and projection is not about loudness.
 
How do you apply the teachings of Baron?
    In my own teaching, air and breathing are the two fundamentals that I stress for full sound. Baron used to say that it is the air behind the air that makes a good tone. In other words, you use air to breathe, and then the support of the intercostal muscles with the diaphragm, shapes the air, creating an airstream that is blown, or breathed, across the back wall of the embouchure plate. It sounds daunting and yet easy. And then when we breathe and blow into the flute, there are variables like how fast or slow the airstream, what is the correct angle and depth, how is the embouchure shaped, what is the shape of the oral cavity, how open is the throat. Baron used to remark “it’s only a metal tube. The work of finding a full sound is individual in nature as only you know your own shape, space and set-up.” Teachers should be able to direct and focus the information so that students can find their own ideal sound.
    Now that I have been teaching for over ten years at ASU, I give my students this simple definition of a cracked/chipped/marred note: the note will crack because the air in use does not match the set-up. Another easy definition, right? So many flutists decrease the air in use because usually it is the increase in air that results in a note that breaks or cracks. Instead, they should think about changing the set-up. Use the increase in air flow (whether volume or speed) and instead adjust the embouchure or set-up. This is why flutists should learn control and flexibility and why balance is so important. Greater air demands greater space. I try to teach the balanced nuances between air, breathing and control. The ABCs as it were. Air is controlled by breathing; breathing controls the use of air; control of set-up creates the correct embouchure to hug the air in use. When these three elements balance, the result is a resonant, rich, and centered sound.

What were your experiences studying with Carol Wincenc?
    After working with Baron, I switched to Carol Wincenc for my master’s degree. I met her at the Sarasota Music Festival 25 years ago. She had just joined the faculty at Juilliard, and I decided that I wanted to finish my graduate studies with her. Studying with a woman flutist was so foreign to me, and I thought that the perspective of a female performer would be invaluable towards my development. Baron, Wincenc, and I met for lunch to discuss this change. Baron was incredibly gracious about allowing me to switch to Wincenc, and I became her first student at Juilliard.
     Wincenc opened the world to me. My first assignment was the Moyse 24 Little Melodies. We studied these one by one, in great depth, and this completely changed the way I play the flute. She later started teaching at Rice University in Houston and eventually lured me there to earn a DMA. Even though I had been invited to the first Boston Symphony principal flute audition, been a finalist for the New Jersey Symphony and the San Antonio Symphony, going back to school gave me more time to practice and hone my audition skills.
    Houston was a world of its own as was Rice University. During my first semester there I developed mono. Then I asked for a six-week leave to tour with the Manhattan Wind Quintet. The Dean looked at me incredulously and asked why I was pursuing a DMA if I had professional engagements to keep. The concept of balance became important even at that stage of my career. I had to figure out how to balance going back to school, taking care of my health, going on tour and making up classes and lessons.

How did you come to the Phoenix Symphony?
    I auditioned for the Phoenix Symphony after taking a string of auditions back-to-back. All I remember was thinking about canceling the Phoenix audition because I was out of money, stressed with school and travel, and disappointed that I was not winning any jobs. I got on the flight, and it was
an incredibly beautiful landing in Phoenix.
    There were mountains surrounding the city and it looked a lot like California. I loved Phoenix and felt at home immediately. The first round was rather short, and I remember thinking, it could go either way. I had played well, but the decision was out of my hands.
    I was surprised when I advanced to the next round. Every round got better and better until there were five of us waiting for the final results. When the personnel manager asked to speak with me outside in the hall, Brian Gordon, the Phoenix Symphony piccolo player who was also taking the audition announced, “There goes our new principal!” I didn’t know what he was talking about until music director James Sedaris and the entire committee surrounded me and congratulated me on winning the audition.
    I felt like I had won the lottery, and then I asked when the job started. The answer was next week. I still wanted to finish my DMA coursework as I was enrolled in my last semester. Jim Sedaris said something then that I will never forget, “You can start whenever you want. We will hold the position of principal flute for you. You just let us know when you’re available.”
     In short, I was able to finish my DMA coursework and then start with the Phoenix Symphony at the end of the semester. Working in a symphony orchestra as principal flute was literally my dream come true. I had no intention of finishing the DMA, except that Leone Buyse eventually replaced Carol Wincenc at Rice. Buyse had been my San Francisco Symphony Youth Orchestra flute coach when I was a teenager. We discussed my status as a not quite ABD (all but dissertation), and she encouraged me to finish the degree. I would be the rare orchestral flutist with a DMA. Perhaps it is not so rare today, as many flutists with a DMA are playing in orchestras. She was instrumental in helping me pass my qualifying exams, the foreign language exam, and the final writing of my dissertation. I finished the dissertation just weeks before applying for the ASU job and almost twelve years after starting the degree.

Why did you make the career switch from playing in the Phoenix Symphony to teaching at Arizona State University?
    Getting the ASU job was another road sign for staying active with the flute. I had grown a little disillusioned after winning my dream job at 28, which was old in undergraduate time, but quite young on the spectrum of life. I was not sure I wanted to sit in a symphony orchestra for the rest of my life. I tell students, the orchestral repertory has not changed significantly in the last 250 years. Beethoven’s nine symphonies are still in the same keys as they were when they were composed. Did I have it in me to maintain the day-in and day-out of playing in a symphony orchestra? I’m prone to ask questions, lots of questions. My students sometimes feel intimidated and perplexed – am I asking because I want them to answer? Are my questions rhetorical? I know that one of the most effective ways of learning is to ask questions. If you don’t know the answer, then that’s how you find out how to learn.
    After much soul-searching, I decided that I liked the idea of helping people, but playing symphonic concerts in large halls was not the most direct way to know whether I was being effective at meeting people and helping them. Just as I came up with a five-year plan for eventually switching my career to nursing, the ASU job opened up.

How many students do you teach?
    I have anywhere from 13-18 students at ASU, depending on the year and enrollment. ASU offers degrees in music therapy, music education and music performance, from bachelor’s degrees up to doctorates. In any one year, I strive to keep the ratio of undergrads to grads at 3:2. My philosophy of teaching is that we all learn from one another, whether one is a freshman, doctoral student, or even non-major. The flute studio at ASU is supportive, encouraging and inasmuch as possible, non-competitive. We all have things to learn and improve upon, so I teach from the standpoint that we are all in this together: no one person is above anyone else.

What kinds of ensembles do your students play in?
    All students at ASU have equal opportunity to play in orchestra, wind orchestra, band and wind ensemble. Placement auditions occur once a year in August and are open to anybody on campus. Because there can be fewer ensemble opportunities for flutists, I started a flute choir called the ASU Community Flute Ensemble. When I first started teaching, I vowed never to have a flute choir. After teaching for several years and traveling to South Korea where flute choirs are incredibly popular, I realized that music-making is a community endeavor and there are so many flutists who want to play with others, so I asked one of my TAs to design a flute ensemble program. We are still a fledgling ensemble on campus, but it is open to all.

What do you look for when a student auditions for you?
    When students audition for ASU and play for me, I am looking for qualities that make both the musician and the person. At the undergrad level, I look for poise and potential – people who respond with openness and curiosity. The qualities that make a musician are subjective of course, but some signs of great musicianship and personality emerge right away. These qualities include focus in regard to performance and sound; control in regard to technique and breathing and authenticity in presentation. For graduate students, I look for maturity to see the bigger picture. Do they know why they are interested in ASU or why they want to pursue a master’s degree. They should have specific goals of what they want to accomplish in the next two years. The two year MM is such a short time of study that I like to work with students who are motivated and goal-oriented from the start. At the DMA level, I will only take students who I believe to have the potential to finish the degree and be hired at the college level. As such, I only take one or two doctoral students at a time because the job market is saturated with those who carry advanced degrees.

What is your basic core curriculum with regards to etudes?
    Etudes are the bridge between technical exercises and musical pieces, although I would argue that etudes are music. From Andersen etudes to Hughes, Boehm, Karg-Elert, Damase, Jeanjean, Bozza and beyond, I firmly believe in using etudes for initial sight-reading and weekly development for musical training. Learning notes and rhythms are the basics for musical understanding, but playing the notes and rhythms musically are entry-level to the professional field. Every note one plays ought to be musical and lyrical. Yet students play scales like they are some sort of rote punishment for repeating patterns. They address etudes like history books filled with facts – pages and pages of notes that are boring and uninteresting. I continually remind students that I expect them to bring in one etude per week. At one point, a record was set – 13 etudes were played in one lesson. Then students began arguing whether 5 Jeanjean etudes were the equivalent of 13 Andersen etudes, but which opus of Andersen, since op. 15 is decidedly more challenging than op. 33 and then what about op. 60? To this day no one has surpassed 13 etudes.
    I hope students realize that there is nothing at all boring about etudes. They are musical snapshots. You do not get a panorama or landscape with etudes. It is just a snapshot for working out technical details in a musical way. Etudes help to cover style and musical expression, often well in advance of seeing such styles and expression in the standard repertoire. Additionally, etudes are like labs of learning – places to test musical and technical ideas.
    Getting the right notes and playing in time can be so difficult to begin with that this is sometimes all students think about. I try to inspire students to play musically from one note to another, connecting notes with their air so that even scales are music. If everything we play is musical to begin with, there is not a separate process for artistry and musicality.

Do you have any hobbies that relate to your playing and teaching?
    I love cooking and hiking. Cooking is such a creative outlet that I find it easy to make analogies between it and music. Music on the page is like a recipe. The ingredients are listed, the necessary items are named, the process  is detailed, and then the recipe is hopefully brought to life. Music on the page is exactly a recipe. The notes are listed, the necessary markings are named, and then the process of making is up to the musician to bring forth to life. To follow a recipe literally and by the book can be correct and taste good, but sometimes a cook can add a splash of something or inadvertently make up substitutions and then the results are unforgettable – either for good or bad! This is what making music is all about: to be creative and to make something unforgettable. Literally following the notes and rhythm on the page may produce competency, but it is the added splashes that bring forth interest and artistry.
    Music brings people together just as food brings people together. I learn a lot about my students when we have potluck suppers, and each student brings a special dish. Some students do not know how to cook, so on occasion, I have taught students how to make dishes like fried rice. I explain the importance of eating well and taking good care of one’s body. I stress the importance of drinking water and getting plenty of rest and relaxation balanced with exercise and time outdoors. Playing the flute is but one aspect of our lives. In teaching, I want my students to be the best flutists and musicians that they can be. I want them to know why they play the flute, how to play the flute and when to play the flute. Who inspires them? What do they want to accomplish? Where can they get the education and experience and training necessary to realize their goals?
    I know I do not have all the answers, but I try to find the right questions to ask. This is what I hope my students will remember: how to ask the relevant questions that help them to become the best that they can be, no matter what they do. I want my students to have an openness and curiosity towards learning for the rest of their lives.      

Elizabeth Buck is associate professor at Arizona State University. From 1994-2003, she was principal flute with the Phoenix Symphony Orchestra. Previous orchestral and teaching engagements include principal flute with the Brevard Music Center, Arizona MusicFest, Arizona Opera, and Nova Philharmonia Portuguesa, visiting associate professor at Indiana University, and flutist with the Manhattan Wind Quintet and the Grand Teton Music Festival As a soloist she has performed throughout North America, Europe and South Korea. She is also on the faculty of the InterHarmony International Music Festival in Italy.   


6 Rules for Appropriate Breaths

    •    At the beginning of the piece, always!

    •    During rests

    •    Between a long note and short note: (this includes ties and dotted notes, for example)

    •    In-between wide intervals: (unless it’s expressive to sing and connect the lower note to a higher interval)

    •    Where the contour changes (from interval leaps to step-wise patterns, for example)

    •    Where phrases begin (when with an upbeat, the breath should correspond with the beginning before the upbeat)

The post Achieving Balance: A Conversation with Elizabeth Buck appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Breathing New Life into an Old Flute /february-2014-flute-talk/breathing-new-life-into-an-old-flute/ Sat, 08 Feb 2014 03:47:02 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/breathing-new-life-into-an-old-flute/     Flutists are tied, however indirectly, to a wide variety of flutes in cultures all across the world. Although folk instruments seem fundamentally different from silver flutes,  wooden flutes played by traditional musicians are in fact the same as classical flutes from the time of Beethoven and Schubert. The wooden flute, often referred to as […]

The post Breathing New Life into an Old Flute appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>



    Flutists are tied, however indirectly, to a wide variety of flutes in cultures all across the world. Although folk instruments seem fundamentally different from silver flutes,  wooden flutes played by traditional musicians are in fact the same as classical flutes from the time of Beethoven and Schubert. The wooden flute, often referred to as an Irish flute, is adapted from the 19th-century predecessor of the Boehm flute. When these flutes were abandoned by classical flutists in favor of the Boehm system, they were gradually adopted by traditional music community. Today the wooden simple system flute is used by players of traditional music in Ireland, Scotland, Brittany (France), Quebec, and even Sweden. Some musicians prefer to play antique instruments, while others play contemporary flutes adapted from the patterns of historic workshops such as Rudall, Rose, and Carte.

Selecting an Instrument
    When you begin the hunt for a good wooden flute, it helps to keep two things in mind. The first is that there is nothing simple about the simple system flute. Because these instruments have conical bores (as compared to the cylindrical bore of the Boehm system flute), they vary widely from maker to maker. It is worth meeting other flutists to try as many different flutes as possible. They may provide guidance on deciding how many keys to have on your flute (instruments can be keyless or have up to eight keys) as well as their views on the advantages of different types of wood. Contemporary makers include many outstanding workshops run by individuals who are passionate about their craft. They are often happy to share this dedication and expertise directly with interested customers. The second is to remember that these wooden flutes are every bit as complex as today’s silver flutes, and to budget accordingly. Buy the best possible instrument and you will be happier in the long run. As with any instrument, something that seems inexpensive at first can become costly later in terms of frustration. 

Extending Technique
    Playing in a traditional style offers a golden opportunity to extend your technique. The wooden flute has some possibilities that are distinct to the instrument. For example, because the fingers are in direct contact with the holes (with no keys to intercede), both subtle changes and dramatic ornaments are possible. Irish playing has its own ornamentation system that can be adapted to a silver flute but which comes much more readily on a wooden one. Grey Larsen’s book The Essential Guide to Irish Flute and Tin Whistle provides an excellent overview of this ornamentation on both wooden and silver flutes. He notes that this ornamentation is better understood as a system of articulation as individual pitches are not heard. The ornament is used to provide a rhythmic interruption to a note, thus helping to shape a phrase in a way analogous to the way classical players utilize tonguing and slurs.
    For classical flute players who love the silver flute’s ability to change tone color, a wooden flute offers tremendous possibilities for shifting timbres. This can happen not only through the embouchure and air but also through alternate fingerings. Historical fingering charts from the mid to late 1800s show that multiple fingerings are available for each note. These might be selected for pitch (making a difference between Ab and G#, for example), or they might be used to shade notes. Some players today will even vary fingerings on a repeated note, playing with the changes that come between a strong and weak sound as part of their phrasing.
    Sometimes extending one’s technique means not adding but rather taking away. Irish playing has a strict moratorium on vibrato and tonguing. A straight, strong sound is preferred, with finger vibrato sometimes used in the playing of slow airs. Even if the sheet music indicates no slurs, notes are never individually tongued. Phrases may be shaped through the use of glottal stops or accenting certain notes or beats. This accenting is called the swing and is essential to an authentic sound. Interestingly, classical flutists can adapt the mechanism of their vibrato technique to create this rhythmic pulse. This is a wonderful example of how classical training can pave the way to quick learning, as long as flutists exercise options as choices and do not merely play by habit.
    Hand position also varies. The fingers of the right hand are kept flat, both to facilitate ornaments and to cover the larger holes more readily. Playing with curved fingers and using the fingertips, as in classical playing, is sure to get in the way. The left hand’s role in holding the flute changes as well. Some traditional players use what is called a piper’s grip, in which the left hand thumb comes around to the front of the flute to push on the space usually occupied by a classical player’s pointer finger knuckle. This feels dramatically different, and yet is worth trying out. Once mastered, this position allows considerable freedom in the use of the first finger for ornamentation techniques. Those who retain the classical left hand position will find that the thumb is not free to move and is actually holding up the flute. Rather than indicating a personal failing of the flutist’s posture, this happens because the wooden flute has a different center of balance than the silver flute. This is a good example of how what seems familiar might actually be foreign. It is a good idea to take it slowly at first so that the body has time to internalize these new mechanics without becoming injured.

Learning by Ear
    Traditional music is passed down from musician to musician, and is almost always learned by ear. While there are volumes of tunes that have been written down, it is important to understand the nature of these collections. The way a tune is written represents the way one person played that tune on a particular occasion. In a tradition where variations are part of the practice, that music would look different if the transcriber chose the second or third time through. Additionally, notation systems do not exist for transcribing most ornaments and accents. A number of ideas have been proposed, and knowing how to read them might mean understanding what is intended rather than what classically trained eyes will see. For example, what is written as an eighth-note triplet might be intended to be played as two sixteenths and an eighth. Finally, there is no Urtext version of a tune. It is not at all uncommon to find tunes in which one region of a country tends to play an F# while another plays an E – and they are both considered right. When all is said and done, finding sheet music might feel like a shortcut, but it can sometimes be the long way around.
    For these reasons, finding a good teacher is essential; as with classical music, learning will happen faster when it happens directly with an experienced musician who can serve as a guide. Traditional musicians teach tunes directly, will be able to put them in their context, and can suggest variations and demonstrate ornaments that are well placed and represent a solid style. In both group classes and private lessons, teachers usually play a few notes and ask students to repeat them back. These notes are not randomly selected bits, but rather correspond with the internal phrasing of the tune. Traditional phrasing does not emphasize long, arching phrases, but rather shorter snippets that receive their own emphasis as they are strung together.
    For those who are not used to it, learning by ear can feel maddeningly slow at first. Thankfully, many musicians find the learning curve happens quickly after initial breakthroughs are made. It is not only permissible but generally expected to bring a recording device to lessons to take home a version for practice. Computer apps like Capo and The Amazing Slow Downer offer the ability to slow down an mp3 while keeping the pitch constant. It is possible to put a difficult section on loop, making it easier to find pitches. This is good for musicians who feel self-conscious in the first stages of learning to play by ear. It can be hard to realize that one might be able to play an exceptionally difficult concerto but cannot match the first three notes of a seemingly simple jig. In this, flutists should enjoy the luxury of not having to know all the answers and celebrate the joy of entering a beginner’s mindset, all the while watching the development of new abilities.

Listen Widely
    To support both learning by ear and developing one’s own robust style, it is essential to listen to as many traditional musicians as possible – whether through CDs, YouTube videos, concerts, or meeting them in person at festivals and sessions. Finding multiple recordings of the same tune will help to give a wider view of the variety of styles and settings that are possible. Just as there is no Urtext version of a written tune, there is no authoritative version of a performed tune. Multiple styles are considered equally correct, originally developing in geographically defined pockets when travel was uncommon and recordings were scarce. Today there is a dynamic cross-fertilization of styles that happens through experiences shared across county and country lines.

Connect with the Community
    One of the joys of stepping into a new musical style is the opportunity to connect with a different group of musicians. The traditional music community is especially rich this way, with a worldwide community that is spread across the globe.
    A first step to connecting with the local community is to search for a session or informal get-together in which musicians play with each other. While these often happen in a public setting such as a pub, the musicians are playing for each other rather than for an audience. Although it may appear on the surface as though the music is happening organically, there are unspoken customs that underlie a session. Learning about session etiquette before attending your first one is an essential key to receiving a warm welcome.
    Those who live far away from community centers are able to access resources online, from discussion boards to online lessons. These flutists can connect directly with local communities while travelling (finding a local session is often a great way to relax after attending a conference), and especially by taking part in one of the many summer festivals that bring together musicians from diverse places.
    When flutists connect with others, they enjoy two advantages: first, as tunes are passed down directly from musician to musician, the tradition itself is tightly tied to the community. Meeting individuals who can help guide your learning is just as essential in the traditional music world as it is in classical music; after all, who could imagine learning to play Syrinx well simply by watching videos on YouTube? Likewise, think of the many good friendships that are developed by playing chamber music together. A second advantage of connecting with the traditional community is that these new friendships might include musicians whose playing inspires your own.

Respect the Tradition
    It is unfortunate that traditional music often has a reputation of being simple; as you learns about the intricacies of tunes and styles, the more we see how truly complex it is. As with any new skill, stepping out of your comfort zone and suspending judgments is key to making quick progress. For example, Swedish music regularly makes use of a pitch between Fn and F#. Upon hearing this unusual pitch, one response might be to correct the intonation. This unfortunately implies that beginners who come from a classical background have the authority to improve the tradition – an impression most would be horrified to give off, and which will certainly damage their ability to connect with other musicians. A better choice would be to listen with open ears, notice the pitch seems unusual, and then accept the challenge of learning to place the note accurately: right between Fn and F#.

Finding Your Own Sound
    In biology, scientists tell us that there is exceptional diversity in the places where two ecosystems converge. This edge theory is true in music as well. When we stand at the edge between classical and traditional music, creativity can flourish. Diving into a traditional world, we can strive to extend technique and learn new sounds and ways of playing. That might in turn cross-fertilize performance of other styles of music. For example, many musicians talk about the uncanny similarities between the modal chords of traditional music and that of early and Baroque music. Aiming for a strong sound, flutists might develop a dark, husky tone that opens up new colors on a silver headjoint. Or, as happened to me, the cards might all fall into place: my favorite classical composers, like Dvo˘rák and Vaughan Williams, were known for incorporating folk melodies into their music. When I discovered the richness of the traditional music world, I felt as though I had found a musical home. In short, learning a new style can help musicians find their own voices and expand their concept of musicianship. It all starts with a few steps into the unknown.        

The post Breathing New Life into an Old Flute appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Humor in Music /february-2014-flute-talk/humor-in-music/ Sat, 08 Feb 2014 03:32:04 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/humor-in-music/     I was an avid Spike Jones fan during my teenage years. I relished his no-holds-barred slapstick spoofing of the classics; especially the William Tell Overture (starring “Feedlebaum”), Poet and Peasant Overture, and Sabre Dance (check them out on YouTube). Fortunately I never outgrew my penchant for musical humor, and to this day I can […]

The post Humor in Music appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

    I was an avid Spike Jones fan during my teenage years. I relished his no-holds-barred slapstick spoofing of the classics; especially the William Tell Overture (starring “Feedlebaum”), Poet and Peasant Overture, and Sabre Dance (check them out on YouTube). Fortunately I never outgrew my penchant for musical humor, and to this day I can still appreciate well-chosen comedic touches in music, whether by the composer or the performer.
    Inspired by the long-running success in London of The Complete Works of Shakespeare (abridged) – 37 plays in 97 minutes! – I decided in 2004 to contribute to the musical humor genre by designing a potpourri of 33 flute audition excerpts titled The Compleat Audition tAngler (a piscatorial salute to Izaak Walton’s 1653 classic, The Compleat Angler) which I premiered on my 80th birthday “senior” recital at Northwestern in 2005. Charlie Geyer gave me a proper sendoff by playing the two trumpet calls from Beethoven’s Leonore No. 3 Overture, and then with Martin Amlin’s sensitive collaboration at the piano, we took off on the following 33 excerpts in 10 minutes: Leonore No. 3, Mozart D Major Concerto, Rossini William Tell Overture, Mozart G Major Concerto, Rimsky-Korsakov Russian Easter Overture, Stravinsky Petrouchka, Nielsen Concerto, Saint-Saëns Carnival of the Animals, Strauss Till Eulenspiegel and Don Quixote, Dvorák 8, Mendelssohn Scherzo, Hindemith Symphonic Metamorphosis, Strauss Ein Heldenleben, Dvorák 9, Bizet Carmen Intermezzo and L’Arlesienne Minuet, Ravel Daphnis & Chloe, Prokofiev Peter and the Wolf, J. Strauss Perpetuum Mobile, Beethoven 4, 7, and 3, Prokofiev Classical Symphony, Bach Polonaise and Badinerie from the B Minor Suite, Tchaikovsky 4, Shostakovich 5, Debussy Afternoon of a Faun, Schumann 1, and finally, the Ibert Concerto.
    Truthfully, in order to shoehorn these 33 excerpts into a 10-minute medley I had to pare them down to an average of 18 seconds per excerpt, and then find the appropriate linking elements to make logical (but amusing) segues. For example, the 8-bar sustained pianissimo high D at the end of the Leonore No. 3 excerpt becomes the 4-bar high D that begins in the second bar of the solo entrance to the Mozart D Major Concerto. The half-note E-F# trill at the first big cadence of the Mozart (bar 46) resolves to the quarter-note D that becomes the lead-in to the staccato 32nds in the Andante section of William Tell. Four bars later the descending chromatic 32nds of William Tell lead into the low G that begins the second phrase of the Mozart G Major Concerto. And so on.
    I performed the Compleat Audition tAngler again (this time with the added subtitle, 33 and 1/3 Expediently Excised Excerpts) at the 2008 NFA convention in Kansas City, expertly partnered by Robert Pherigo. (I also did it at the British Flute Society convention in Manchester a few weeks later with Richard Shaw.) On the Kansas City program I also introduced one of my more recent favorites for piccolo and piano, Jacques Castérède’s La Belle Époque. (There is a short section in the middle where the performer switches to flute.) The subtle humor in the Castérède is certainly a far cry from the antics of Spike Jones, but one can still appreciate the careful thought that the composer gave to introducing and developing the cameo appearances of Mozart’s Magic Flute (Papagena’s 5-note panpipes scale) and Rondo alla Turca, plus a snippet from the fourth movement of Beethoven 5. However, the first theme of the Haydn G Major Piano Trio (quoted in full) becomes the foundation of a series of variations based on the quadrille dance form. The signature opening turn figure of both the Haydn Trio and the Mozart Rondo alla Turca become the dominating intrusive elements heard throughout the piece. Although the technical challenges of La Belle Epoque are formidable for both piccolo and piano, they are well worth working out.
    More recently, on June 7, I performed the Castérède with the ever-reliable Tim Carey at Nicole Esposito’s Iowa Piccolo Intensive and also on October 31 at the Rochester Flute Association’s Flute Fair with Minji Nam.
    Some other compositions for piccolo that parody famous themes include the Lowell Liebermann Concerto (Mozart G Minor Symphony, Beethoven Eroica Symphony, and Sousa Stars and Stripes Forever). The Sousa march becomes the chief victim of Ken Laufer’s Scars and Scrapes Forever! (“A march into musical mayhem”) and also the last movement of the PDQ Bach Sonata Piccola, (S. 8va) (Edited to no small extent by Professor Peter Schickele).
    With the availability of the fantastic resources of YouTube one can spend many delightful hours immersing oneself into the comedic world of music. Here are some of my favorites: Victor Borge, Spike Jones, Gerard Hoffnung (The Hoffnung Symphony), Rainer Hersch, Igudesman and Joo, PDQ Bach, Danny Kaye (Danny Kaye and the New York Philharmonic), Reggie Watts, Anna Russell, Florence Foster Jenkins, Jack Benny and Giselle MacKenzie, “What’s Opera, Doc?” (Bugs Bunny cartoon), and “A Night at the Opera” (the classic Marx Brothers film).
    That last item reminds me of a book that I highly recommend, Sir Denis Forman’s A Night at the Opera: An Irreverent Guide to the Plots, the Singers, the Composers, the Recordings (Random House). Irreverent and funny it certainly is, but also full of reliable information and fascinating opera lore. I learned more about opera from this book than from any other. After reading about La Boheme, I laughed all the way to the Left Bank.
    Victor Borge, topping the YouTube list above, also wrote a humorous book of biographies of famous composers, My Favorite Intermissions: Lives of the Musical Greats and Other Facts You Never Knew You Were Missing (Doubleday). He also wrote My Favorite Comedies in Music (Dorset Press). Victor Borge’s Comedy in Music, the longest running one-man show in the history of theater, opened on Broadway in 1953 and ran for 849 performances! He appeared with the Chicago Symphony several times as pianist and conductor, and I had the honor of playing principal flute in the last concert he conducted with the CSO in 1999 (he died in 2000). The concert included the Mendelssohn A Midsummer Night’s Dream Scherzo, conducted at the slowest tempo I have ever heard or played. It was breathtaking in the extreme.
    Speaking of conductors, playing jokes on them can be a perilous business. Fortunately this was not the case with the affable James Levine who was famously duped in 1991 at a rehearsal of the Mahler 2nd Symphony at Ravinia, the summer home of the CSO. The first movement begins with the violins and violas executing a loud G tremolo that quickly diminishes. The cellos and basses then enter in the second bar with a fiercely dramatic triple forte explosion of sixteenth notes culminating four bars later into a dotted rhythm pattern.

Mahler Symphony No. 2, 1st Movement


    Before the rehearsal, the CSO cellos and basses secretly conspired to piggyback onto that dotted rhythm theme as a perfect springboard into the Mexican Hat Dance. At bar 6, when they suddenly went “Mexican,” Levine and the rest of the orchestra, were taken by surprise and momentarily stunned before they burst into uproarious laughter and applause.
    Luckily, WFMT was doing a sound check at the rehearsal and happened to record the celli-bassi escapade. That recording was broadcast with great jubilation at several subsequent CSO-WFMT Radiothons. Too bad that YouTube wasn’t around in those days to archive it. It would surely have gone viral!

The post Humor in Music appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>