March 2011 Archives - The Instrumentalist /category/march-2011-flute-talk/ Sun, 27 Feb 2011 19:35:46 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 Remembering Albert Cooper /march-2011-flute-talk/remembering-albert-cooper/ Sun, 27 Feb 2011 19:35:46 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/remembering-albert-cooper/ Albert Cooper        April 12, 1924-January 25, 2011         Albert Cooper’s legacy is that he was the greatest influence on our instrument since Theobald Böhm. He set a standard for mechanical excellence, redesigned our scale allowing us to be more expressive, gave makers new ideas and suggested additional keys to make our performing lives easier, […]

The post Remembering Albert Cooper appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

Albert Cooper
       
April 12, 1924-January 25, 2011
   
    Albert Cooper’s legacy is that he was the greatest influence on our instrument since Theobald Böhm. He set a standard for mechanical excellence, redesigned our scale allowing us to be more expressive, gave makers new ideas and suggested additional keys to make our performing lives easier, and set an example of generosity. Albert was naturally big-hearted and would share anything with anyone. This humble but great man showed that we are merely caretakers of knowledge we acquire in our lives. He set the example that we should pass on our knowledge freely to anyone who wants it.
    Albert Kendall Cooper was born in Hull, England in 1924. He apprenticed at the famous London flute makers, Rudall Carte & Co until the outbreak of WWII, when he was called up to join the army. After the war, he returned to Rudall Carte, married Olive McLewee, and after a time, the couple moved to 9 West Rd., Clapham, where he remained for the rest of his life and where he built his now famous workshop. This workshop was in reality a small shed in the garden where he sat working whilst a visitor only had room to stand at the door to watch him.
    Elmer Cole and William Bennett both contributed to Albert’s search for a true scale on which to build the modern flute and were in fact largely responsible for the calculations that resulted in what became known as the  Cooper Scale. As ‘the Scale’ developed, and players offered their opinions, Cooper updated his figures and gave the latest revision to anyone who asked for it. Over time, he gave different scale figures to different makers.
    Just a few years ago, he said: “Cooper’s Scale? What’s that? There isn’t a scale. There is a constant revision taking place so that, at any one time, there is a set of figures which you can use to design your flute, but these will change in the light of experience. I altered the scale a little as the years went by, mostly according to certain criticisms levelled at it. I now feel that I have more or less reached the end of the road scale-wise.”
    His constant search for excellence and his dogged determination to give flute players a reliable scale resulted in a mounting reputation until his skills became legendary. Albert could often be seen at flute conventions discussing the latest in key design or mechanism with flute makers all over the world. He was always willing to help, advise, or offer figures to anyone who asked for them, often to the astonishment of his flute making rivals.
    A couple of days after Albert’s 80th birthday, he was told, “You are such a famous man. There is hardly a flute player anywhere who hasn’t heard the name of Albert Cooper.” “Well,” he commented, “I dunno why. All I’ve done all my life is tinker about with flutes.”

Trevor Wye

The post Remembering Albert Cooper appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Hearing Protection /march-2011-flute-talk/hearing-protection/ Sun, 27 Feb 2011 19:26:00 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/hearing-protection/     Musicians experience significant exposure to loud sounds on a daily basis, yet our sense of hearing is the faculty we use the most to perceive our craft. It is practically a given that musicians will experience some degree of instrument related hearing loss over the course of a professional career because of the prolonged […]

The post Hearing Protection appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

    Musicians experience significant exposure to loud sounds on a daily basis, yet our sense of hearing is the faculty we use the most to perceive our craft. It is practically a given that musicians will experience some degree of instrument related hearing loss over the course of a professional career because of the prolonged periods of exposure.
    Using hearing protection, such as earplugs specifically created for musicians, can minimize the damage. The best earplugs for our use offer reduced levels of damaging sound as well as the most accurate tonal perception possible. Most people do not need much hearing protection (15 dB) to dramatically reduce the risk of significant hearing impairment over time. (Editor’s Note: Sound pressure is measured in decibels or dBs. The scale ranges from below 0, the sound of rustling leaves, to over 140, the sound of a gunshot or loud clap of thunder. A symphony orchestra comes in around 100dBs.)
    In addition to hearing loss there are other secondary effects that may occur, such as tinnitus or ringing sounds that interfere with sound perception. Loss typically seen in flute and piccolo players occurs in the 3-4 kHz range, which may eventually affect the correct perception of sibilant speech sounds s, sh, and ch, according to audiologist Michelle Wilson. An audiometric test can reveal such problems.
    Damage for flutists can be more severe on the right side because the flute is closest to that ear, although in some cases the left may be more affected due to the proximity of other orchestral instruments. Piccolo players have an increased risk because they play at a pitch level in which the damage occurs the fastest.
    The world’s first high fidelity hearing protector was patented by the late Elmer Carlson, whose design replicated the natural sound of an open ear. In the 1980s custom fitted earplugs were developed by several companies especially for musicians.
    The custom fitted earplugs have two parts: an attenuator button and a deeply-fitted earmold that seals the ear canal. The attenuator buttons can be interchanged: there are filters at different strengths that can be used in different circumstances. I use greater attenuation strength when I practice piccolo. In performance, I want to experience more of the sound interplay between instruments, so I opt for less attenuation or sometimes none at all. However, if I am sitting near amplification during a pops concert, I use the stronger level because the volume of sound is greater. You will need to visit an audiologist’s office to be fitted for the custom earplugs.
    You may want to experiment with earplugs of different attenuation in each ear, or wearing protection in just one ear. However, conventional earplugs (not specific for musicians) can cause problems: According to Patty Niquette, MA, in The Hearing Review, they can include too much high frequency attenuation, too much attenuation overall, or too much occlusion.
    High frequency attenuation tends to block out the high frequency harmonics which are vital to the perception of loudness and overall tonal depth. Players sometimes overcompensate by playing louder than necessary to make up for the blocked harmonics.
    Excessive overall attenuation also leads to overplaying. The occlusion effect is the increase in sound pressure at the eardrum behind the hearing protector itself  that  can lead to an increased risk of sound overexposure. This is more pronounced in wind players because sounds are also transmitted to the ear through bone conduction via the jaw bone, which connects to the bone surrounding the inner portion of the ear canal.
    Potential hearing damage is something that all musicians should be aware of. The most sensible approach to hearing protection is to use earplugs specifically made for musicians, and to realize that hearing damage can develop without any symptoms over the years.
    There are many useful sites online including . It has a terrific article written by Steven A. Wickes about flute/piccolo specific hearing loss concerns. I am very grateful for the knowledge of Michelle Wilson, PhD., who has fitted me for the custom musicians earplugs and provided advice for writing this article. Some additional material may be found at .   

The post Hearing Protection appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Starting a Summer Masterclass /march-2011-flute-talk/starting-a-summer-masterclass/ Sat, 26 Feb 2011 22:55:44 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/starting-a-summer-masterclass/     In 1970 I organized and taught my first flute camp. I had been inspired by the work of Dr. Martha McCrory, who had launched an orchestral camp for young players a few years earlier. At that time most community, college, and high school orchestras in the United States had weak string sections. Her goal […]

The post Starting a Summer Masterclass appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

    In 1970 I organized and taught my first flute camp. I had been inspired by the work of Dr. Martha McCrory, who had launched an orchestral camp for young players a few years earlier. At that time most community, college, and high school orchestras in the United States had weak string sections. Her goal was to recruit talented young players and immerse the students in high quality instruction for five weeks each summer at The University of the South, Sewanee, Tennessee.
    The focus of the camp was on improving each student’s skills through private lessons, chamber music, theory classes, and of course, orchestral playing. She hoped for a ripple effect to occur when students returned home and shared what they had learned. Dr. McCrory saw this as a way to improve orchestral programs across the United States. I thought the idea was quite noble and one I wished to duplicate in the flute world. 

    Even though the public school music program was excellent in my city, the emphasis was on ensemble performance rather than on each student’s playing skills. I decided that to develop outstanding flutists, I should gear my program toward three age groups: students who had played for one year, those who had played for two to three years, and flutists in high school. Since I would be the only teacher, I arranged the day into three two-hour blocks. The first group (elementary) was scheduled from 10 a.m. to noon.  The second group (intermediate) was from 1-3 p.m., and the last group (advanced) from 3-5 p.m. 
    Over the years the performance level improved, so I hired additional faculty. This allowed the advanced students to take classes for six to seven hours per day. The classes were held Monday through Friday the first full week after the public school closed in June. On Friday evening they gave a Gala Concert to share what they had learned. 
     The first several years I held the classes in my basement studio. As the classes grew, I moved to a larger space. The Gala Concert went from the high school band room to a local church that had offered free space.
    Over the next 13 years, the masterclass numbers increased from 25 to over 50 flutists. Students who participated in the masterclass program began winning the top positions in the All-State Band and Orchestra festivals. Many students won local concerto competitions and chose to become music majors in college. My ripple effect had started.
    Then I moved to Idaho and had to start over. The first year I advertised the Pocatello Flute Week, I was met with “you are doing what?” Over time,  however, the program grew and flutists from neighboring states joined the local students in the week-long classes. The enrollment increased and I was able to hire artist faculty to provide students with rich experiences. Some years I included theory classes or flute repair in the curriculum.
    What I learned was that offering this type of instruction not only improved the performance level and commitment in my studio, but it enriched the lives of the students in more ways than I will ever know. This article discusses some of the things I learned that may help you start a program for your students. 

The Program

    One of my students returned from a National Flute Association convention and announced that she knew what her career should be. She wanted to travel around the country and present masterclasses. I asked: What is your message? What do you have to offer?  She did have some excellent ideas about flute playing and musicianship, but she had not put it all together into a comprehensive curriculum.  
    Before writing the curriculum for the masterclasses, research what the students have been taught thus far. If you are teaching privately, you may have an idea where each individual student’s playing level is, but to prepare a comprehensive curriculum, observe band classes at several grade levels in different schools to get a more accurate assessment.
    Once you know what each masterclass level is, assemble materials to make a study/performance packet for each student. My masterclass packets are several pages long, stapled together on the left side of the sheet in performance order.
    The first page is a warm-up routine.  It might include exercises on the headjoint, rhythm studies, and note-reading exercises. The next five pages (one for each day of the week, Monday – Friday) focus on the scales, arpeggios, technical exercises, and tone studies in the key of the day. 
    The final pages feature the material that the class will play together in the Gala Concert. These compositions include solos (played in unison) with a piano accompanist a la Suzuki style, canons, and simple duets, trios, or quartets. More advanced classes will play from the standard flute choir repertoire. Packets may also include a page on “How to Choose a Flute;” “Standard Repertoire,” graded by performance level; or “Flute Performance Opportunities.” These might include a list of regional concerto competitions, upcoming masterclasses and concerts as well as dates for Regional and All-State tryouts.

Setting a Date
    Choosing a date is one of the trickiest things about hosting a masterclass.  A date that works in one locale may not work in another. The first full week after school is out in June is an excellent time. However, I have held very successful masterclasses at other times in the summer. Do take into consideration the band marching camps or other school sponsored programs. Work to be an asset and not a detriment to the public school programs. Start media publicity and mailings about six weeks before the beginning of the camp. 

Choose a Location

    My first masterclasses were held in my basement studio. I could easily accommodate 12 to 15 students in each class. However, as the classes grew, I held sessions in high school band rooms, downtown storefronts, churches, and community centers. Before making a final decision, consider the rental cost of the space and if the participants will be covered by the host’s liability insurance. Think about whether the location is suitable for the Gala Concert. If not you will need to rent an additional space for the Friday performance.

What To Charge
    The first years I chose a fee that was affordable by all. As the program grew and became well-known, I was able to charge more. Expenses should be factored into the cost. Basic expenses include guest artist fees, rental fees, insurance (if needed), music, photo copying of instructional packets, publicity, postage, and refreshments. 

Choose a Name
    My first masterclass camp was called Quincy Flute Week. When I moved to Idaho, it became Pocatello Flute Week and eventually Pocatello Flute Spa. One of my students designed a logo that was used on all materials and on T-shirts. Each year, the T-shirt logo was the same, but the shirts were a different color. 

Boarding Students

    The Pocatello Flute Week masterclasses attracted students from many states. I arranged with a local motel to provide group rates. Since I could not be at the motel to supervise the flutists, parents alternated staying with the students during the week. Many of the adult participants had cars and transported the students to the masterclass location. I did not provide food.

Make A Flier

    The ideal flier is one page that can serve as both publicity material and a registration form. The flier should include the name of your program, class dates, registration deadline, class ages, class size, times, fees, what to bring, instructional topics, information about the final concert, and biographical information about the teachers.
    In the early days, I mailed 10 copies to each band director in my region; but later sent the flier by email so each director could print as many as needed. If you are not well known in your area, contact the band director and offer to give a free masterclass to his students for the opportunity to distribute masterclass fliers. If students like your teaching, they will attend the masterclass. In the flier, I always include the following disclaimer:  Neither Pocatello Flute Week or Patricia George assumes any liability for your person, flute, or property. Be responsible. Keep your flute with you at all times. Depending on the size of the program and laws of your state, you may wish to obtain local legal advice about additional waivers and potential liability.

Advertising
    Create a press packet to send to area newspapers and for television public service announcements. Include photos from previous years with bios of all faculty members. It is best to send this information via an email. Attach digital photos of 300 dpi (dots per inch) or higher with your copy. The best publicity, however, comes from one student recommending the class to another.

Before the Masterclass

    Try to be as organized as possible before the masterclasses begin.  Masterclass teaching done well takes enormous energy. The more you have organized beforehand, the more you can relax during your down time. Create and copy the class packets. Purchase pencils for the students to take notes upon their packets.
    Make sure you have a music stand and chair for each student, and create nametags to be placed on the stands. Reorganize the nametags each class so that you can place a student with a weak sound next to one who is stronger. By switching stand partners each time, students also get to know more of their fellow flutists. Many of my students made life-long friends at summer programs.
    Assemble your teaching tools such as plastic bags, cigarette papers, plastic wrap, black board, etc. Type the Gala Concert program in a computer file so that you may easily make additions or deletions to the program during the masterclass week. On the back of the program list each student’s name and home town. Print the concert program as soon as the program is set. Make an average of two programs for each participant. Ask a parent of one of your private students to organize punch and cookies for the reception after the concert. The reception is a great opportunity for pictures, so bring a camera and arrange for a parent with photography skills to document the event. At the reception you can present each participant with a certificate of participation. Some years I presented humorous certificates. Certificates are easy to download and print from the web, or you can make your own.

Teaching
    I invite my music education majors to serve as mentors and assist in the classes with younger students. The mentors adjust headjoint corks, align flutes, and take students out for private instruction if special attention is needed. The mentors also play along with the class so younger students get to sit by a great player.
    To keep things interesting, you may want to intersperse activities such as juggling, movement classes, breathing instruction, music theory, or flute repair into the curriculum. The classes should be appropriate for the age group.
    I have hosted 38 summer flute masterclasses, and they have included some of the most enjoyable teaching of my career. Many of the students who attended as young children continued on to become music majors in college. If you want to have great students, sometimes you have to grow them.  

The post Starting a Summer Masterclass appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Grace Notes /march-2011-flute-talk/grace-notes/ Sat, 26 Feb 2011 22:46:03 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/grace-notes/     “Hello Mr. Debost:         My name is Emily Potter, and I am a flutist from Jefferson, Oregon. After reading your articles in Flute Talk, I wanted to ask you about the proper ornamentation of the Bach Sonata # 1 in B     minor, second movement (Largo e dolce). I have listened to several recordings, including […]

The post Grace Notes appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

   
“Hello Mr. Debost:
        My name is Emily Potter, and I am a flutist from Jefferson, Oregon. After reading your articles in
Flute Talk, I wanted to ask you about the proper ornamentation of the Bach Sonata # 1 in B     minor, second movement (Largo e dolce). I have listened to several recordings, including those by Michael Faust, Jean-Pierre Rampal, and James Galway, and none of their examples exhibit the ornamentation that I have been told is correct.­ For example, in the second and fourth measures of the second movement, both Faust and Rampal play the grace note before the beat. I have been taught that in Baroque music it is proper to play the grace note on the beat. Needless to say, I am very confused.”

    Emily, you are not the only one! Let us back up a little. Ornamentation in general, and grace notes or appoggiaturas in particular, were not consistently indicated before 1800, because it was assumed that a good musician would implicitly know what to do. In Blavet Sonatas and the Telemann Fantaisies, for example, a trill or ornament was sometimes indicated with a simple + (or not at all). In J.S. Bach’s music, the appoggiatura (leaning) before a cadential trill was written out or implied (or not at all), etc.
    It must also be remembered that playing styles differed considerably, because of geographical distance, different generations, instrumental innovations, and so forth. Even the style of J.S. Bach’s sons differed from the towering authority of their father. There was the London Bach, Johann-Christian; the Potsdam Bach, Carl-Philip Emmanuel; and the Halle Bach, Wilhelm Friedemann. What was true for Papa was something else for the kids.
    In spite of distance and stylistic idiosyncrasies, there were a few things that “went without saying” but which to us go even better if said. Inevitably, these self-evident truths had exceptions, just like any modern law. If there were no exceptions to laws, our poor lawyers would starve.
    The general rule, which in my youth was not really common knowledge, was that a trill always started with the upper note. Take a look at old editions of Baroque music by the old masters. I will accuse no one, cite no names, but there are some very fallacious (and famous) editions that are still sold in flute shops. These editions included ornamentation where none existed in the original (called urtext); dynamic markings and metronomic indications (the metro­nome dates from ca. 1800); articulations where the original had none or very few; and a general heavy and pompous, let’s say Romantic, approach to music of the 17th and 18th centuries.
    However, what was a constant of the Baroque was that the appoggiatura was an expressive tool. It was leaned upon, generating harmonic tension. For that reason, the actual or implicit grace note had more intensity than the actual trill, instead of what we tend to do nowadays, when the shake or trill obliterates everything else.
I spoke about rules (I don’t like the peremptory weight of this word) and now enter the exceptions:
    The rule: Grace notes were always long and on the beat, leaned upon as it were (appoggiatura=leaning), except when they were short and before the beat. I am not kidding. Now the four main exceptions:
    I.    The grace note is long when it is an appoggiatura. An appoggiatura is a non-chord tone that is approached by leap and resolved by step. In the following example, the C natural is an appoggiatura to the B. It receives one-half the value of the B. The B is the third in a G-major chord, progressing to an A in an A M/m7th chord. However, I like to perform the C natural short because all Baroque treatises, the Quantz in particular, set out rules and then qualify them with the admonitions to exercise good taste in whatever you choose to do. That is certainly the case here, whether you select to play the C heavy (long, on the beat) or light (short, before the beat).

    II. In bar 2 the grace notes are short, because a grace note placed just before the fastest value of the piece (here 32nds) keeps the flowing value of the shortest notes.


    III. The grace note is also short when it is the first note of a larger interval (more than a third). The grace note in bar 10 of the same movement is short, comparable to a kick on a diving board. Here is another example of this springboard idea.


Here the D# grace note is short, a spring to the octave, whereas the A# is a 4-3 suspension, which is played long.
    IV. The grace note is short when it is placed on repeated notes.


This tradition is carried over to our Mozart concertos.


    There is also a curiosity in Baroque keyboard music called the acciaccatura, meaning crush or squeeze in Italian. Not only was the grace-note short or very short; the two concerned notes were crushed together to create acute dissonance. Such an effect is beyond the possibilities of the flute, but it shows that not all grace-notes were long.
    For a long time (1850-1950 approximately), Baroque grace notes were considered a purely decorative, if somewhat dry, embellishment. Then, as the Baroque revival started taking place, ornaments in general and grace-notes in particular became the issue, to the extent that they sometimes appeared to be the tree hiding the forest.        

The post Grace Notes appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Expressive Speech and Music /march-2011-flute-talk/expressive-speech-and-music/ Fri, 25 Feb 2011 21:47:13 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/expressive-speech-and-music/     “O Frabjous Day! Callooh!  Callay!” The exuberant exclamation from Lewis Carroll’s famous poem Jabberwocky illustrates perfectly the mysterious interface between sense and nonsense – the elusive realm of expressive communication. After basic facility with notes and rhythms, the most important skill young flutists learn is expressivity. Not the frosting on the cake, but the […]

The post Expressive Speech and Music appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

    “O Frabjous Day! Callooh!  Callay!” The exuberant exclamation from Lewis Carroll’s famous poem Jabberwocky illustrates perfectly the mysterious interface between sense and nonsense – the elusive realm of expressive communication. After basic facility with notes and rhythms, the most important skill young flutists learn is expressivity. Not the frosting on the cake, but the cake itself. Expression is the reason we play; without expression, playing music is pointless. 
    How often have you reminded students not to wait until the final stages of preparation to incorporate expression markings into their performance, but rather to consider their expressive intent from the very first reading of a new piece? The challenge of helping young students discover the magic of expressive playing is one of the greatest pleasures of teaching.
    My flute students are bright, capable, charming, and as different from each other as colorful jungle birds. Sometimes they express their individuality in puzzling ways. One student, for example, might barely come through the studio door before she launches into an animated account of soccer practice, math class, or prom dress, complete with larger-than-life gestures, hilarious asides, and a whole cast of characters. Her storytelling is so entertaining that it is tempting to serve cookies and just sit down for a good talk. When I manage to steer her attention to playing the flute, however, her performance is bland and timid. She has clearly practiced for the lesson, but her music reflects none of her gregarious personality.
    Another type of student murmurs a polite greeting, assembles her flute and arranges her music on the stand. Her performance, unlike her spoken communication, is imaginative and daring, colorful and impassioned. When she finishes playing, she responds to my comments and suggestions with nearly inaudible one-word replies.
    These extremes illustrate the curious dissonance between many students’ personalities as expressed by their spoken communication and the personalities they reveal as they play. The tantalizing question for teachers is how to  help students expand the range of their expression by observing their spoken and musical communication and showing them how to use strengths they already have while respecting their individual personality?
    To address this question, I designed a series of activities to increase students’ awareness of the parallels between speech and music. The goal was to help them recognize some of the physical gestures that enhance speech and show them how these gestures translate into music. In addition, I hoped to diminish students’ self-consciousness about their own expressive communication, whether spoken or musical, and to have a good time together as we experimented with my ideas.

Musical Interpretation

    From the simplest folk tune to the most complex contemporary composition, interpretation depends on a performer’s personal reservoir of ideas. These interpretive inspirations derive from many sources, one of which is the idea that a text, whether actual or imagined, underlies much of the music we play. Singers have the advantage of knowing the words a composer had in mind for a particular song. Not having a printed text for flute music should not keep us from imagining a possible story, as well as characters who might  sing those words. One of my favorite examples of this kind of inventiveness is the line sung by my friend, flutist, and teacher James Grine, to the jaunty melody from the first movement of Mozart’s G major concerto: “Yes, I will be home for din-ner!”

Undoubtedly you and your students will think of other equally inspiring or amusing texts for the flute music you are currently studying.

Sounds in Nature

    Some musical ideas, though not rhythmically matched with a text, are nevertheless evocative of natural sounds or moods. Some examples are the numerous birdcalls in flute repertoire and the musical imitation of wind or bells. I mention these because they show the power of a word (birdcall, breeze, ringing) to evoke a spectrum of associations in the imagination of performers and the audience, all of which can contribute to interpretive ideas. The best way for each of us to add to our store of evocative words and images is to live a full and attentive life outside the practice room. The more experiences we have, the richer our store of imagination-triggers.

Gestures
    Another source of interpretive inspiration is physical gesture. It is a rare student who doesn’t move her hands, eyebrows, or head as she speaks. Surely expressive gestures (clapping, pointing, hugging) predated speech as a means of communication. In dancelike music we speak of the musical gesture to refer to the contour of a phrase that reflects a physical impulse. Students who have experience in theatre or dance will recognize the parallels between musical gestures and the physical movements that are appropriate for those phrases.
    Less obvious, but equally fascinating to explore, are the more subtle movements or gestures that substitute for a verbal explanation. In fact, a single gesture such as a raised eyebrow or a finger to the lips may take the place of many words. Consider the familiar gesture of a handshake. Practice various styles of handshake with your students so they can experience the tactile difference between a warm, hearty handshake, which is the equivalent of a confident opening phrase that shows the performer’s pleasure to be there, and a handshake that communicates the opposite message.
    An underlying premise of this project is that music and speech are communicative functions, requiring a listener, so I had students experiment with reading aloud. A child is the ideal audience for this purpose because when we read or speak to a child, we tend to exaggerate our expressive gestures in order to convey the story clearly. A single child is better than a class or roomful of children because we relate more personally to a single listener than we do to a crowd. Small children, especially, give immediate and honest feedback, so we know whether our communication has succeeded. Many of my students babysit or have younger siblings who are eager participants in this part of our exploration.
    Using the discussion of physical gesture and vocal nuance as a background, I asked students to read expressively from a children’s story and to observe how naturally they used the elements of the story to structure their expression. Features like quotations, italicized words, questions, changes of character, or words like and, but, or so invited imaginative inflection or changes of vocal quality that could be transferred to musical expression.
    Just as the words and, but, or so have musical analogs, certain musical elements imply verbal equivalents. Pickup notes, for example, indicate and then this happened, repeated notes can say and I really mean it!, and a V-I cadence signals the end.
    Sometimes the music suggests two people having a dialogue or an argument, or one person asking a question that is answered by a second person. Character changes can be indicated by a new dynamic, a faster vibrato, or a darker tone color. We work on these skills, not because they are ends in themselves, but because they are the tools with which we achieve more sophisticated communication. Clearly, the responsibility and pleasure of finding an effective way to communicate whatever we perceive as the composer’s intent lies with the performer.

Historical Styles

    There are aspects of historically correct performance practice that must be considered at some point in a young flutist’s study. My concern is simply to show students the many expressive possibilities that are available and to leave the refinement of these expressive choices for another time. Until students have developed a repertoire of expressive gestures, the confidence to experiment with them, and an attitude of curiosity and delight towards musical communication, I believe that they should not have to worry about whether the choices are historically correct.
    Breath, in all its poetic and physical manifestations, is the source of energy for speakers and wind musicians. In addition to its physiological function, breathing has expressive possibilities of its own. Breaths generally correspond to commas, semicolons, or periods, with varying lengths of pause that correspond to the relative weight of a punctuation mark within a sentence. 
    To put this to use in musical performance, first listen to a simple melody, observing phrases, cadences, and sections of the melody. Then decide whether the phrase endings should be punctuated with a period, a semicolon, a comma, or perhaps a question mark or exclamation point.
    When students learn to recognize the sound of a V-I cadence, they understand that the aural sense of resolution demands a breath-pause indicating finality, whereas an unresolved progression calls for a shorter pause, so that the listener’s attention may continue without a break.
    To help students discover how important breath-pauses are to the audience’s comfort and understanding, they can read a prose passage, breathing only when they run out of breath. The result is a disconcerting rush of confusing words, with the audience as well as the reader feeling breathless by the end of the passage. Students can also learn how expressive breathing affects a listener by observing the various styles of breathing used by professional announcers or actors.
    In unaccompanied music, a cadenza, or music notated “freely” or “in an improvised style,” we can make especially good use of meaningful breaths and breath-pauses. This style of music offers performers considerable rhythmic freedom and frequently intimidates students. It requires performers to make decisions usually handled by the composer. Students learn that they can trust their own ability to make good expressive choices and that there are many good options. The test of a good choice is whether it communicates effectively. 
    It is a challenge to find a textual equivalent for a mood in abstract music. Sometimes, music is most effective when left in its purest, least textualized form, unencumbered by visual associations. One of the strongest arguments for not over-interpreting music is that its emotional impact can transcend the realm of verbal expression; it is precisely this inexpressible aspect of music that is so compelling to performers and listeners alike. On the other hand, any ideas that help a student understand a previously inaccessible piece are worth considering. Even abstract music can be approached from more than one direction.
    As students become familiar with the idea of using their speech skills to enhance their expressive playing, I use questions about the music we are studying to help them recognize these parallels. Here are some of the questions that I have found to be particularly helpful.

Questions to Ask:

•What mood do you hear? 
•Does it change?
•Can you think of adjectives to describe the moods?
•How many characters are involved and what are they like?
•Are they arguing, discussing, questioning?
•Are there places in the music that remind you of a gesture or a sound, such as a sob or a sigh?
•How would you move if you danced to this music?
•Where are the best breathing places to show where characters change or ideas end?
•Are some of the breaths dramatic, meditative, aggressive?
•If you were speaking the message of this music dramatically, where would your voice be most intense? Where would it be hushed?
•How will you transfer those qualities to the flute tone?
•What is the mood at the very end of the piece? The audience will experience this mood. What can you do visually as you finish playing to help them switch from the music’s mood back into their role as audience members?

    The following is a list of activities related to the concept of using the correspondence between speech, music, and gesture to trigger interpretive ideas. The activities are open-ended and can be expanded or adapted as needed. Many of these work well in a group setting where students can brainstorm ideas, play their experiments for each other, and enjoy trying new interpretive possibilities together.
    These ideas will not necessarily turn shy students into extroverted performers, but they may open up worthwhile communication channels. Students who experience performance anxiety may also be helped by these exercises as they learn to focus on the story they are telling, rather than on the audience’s judgment of their performance.

Activities and Suggested Music

     1. Read a passage from a children’s story aloud or some other text that includes dialogue, various characters, and emotional expression. I used the opening of Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland. Observe the way vocal inflection is used for quotations, parenthetical or italicized phrases, and the lengths of breath-pauses.

     2. Become aware of gestures used by friends and family, with or without accompanying speech. Consider how these gestures affect the speaker’s meaning, or whether a gesture substitutes for words.

     3. Use a folk melody or other tune with familiar words (Rockabye Baby works well) to discover why we breathe in the places we do.


 The first two breaths occur at the ends of ideas. The third breath illustrates breathing before a pickup, and the fourth breath reinforces the text by leaving a silence at the moment of the surprising tumble.

     4. Use a copy of an unfamiliar but expressive piece that has been purged of all expression markings. Listen carefully to phrase contours and implications of tension and resolution. Find good breathing places and notate them with punctuation markings.

     5. Using music with the composer’s own markings, play with careful attention to those markings not as abstract instructions but as a way of telling a story. Possibilities for this music include the slow movements from the Baksa Soliloquy (because of their rich emotional content and their relative lack of technical difficulty), the middle movement of Muczynski’s Three Preludes, and the opening of Honegger’s Danse de la Chevre. Britten’s Six Metamorphoses after Ovid for oboe solo works well for flute and offers a story to use as a starting point.
     For younger students, the Vaughan Williams Six Studies in English Folksong are beautiful. I use the version for violin, which needs just a little modification to be suitable for flute.

     6. As a final collaborative activity bringing us full circle back to Lewis Carroll, read together his Jabberwocky, demonstrating that even nonsensical words can be meaningful. Although the notes in flute music have no inherent meaning, we can play them meaningfully by using our imaginations, just as we can turn the whimsical gibberish of Jabberwocky into a story understood by any audience.      

The post Expressive Speech and Music appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Memorable Masterclasses /march-2011-flute-talk/memorable-masterclasses/ Fri, 25 Feb 2011 21:26:56 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/memorable-masterclasses/         The summer after the fourth grade I traded my collection of 108 silver dollars for a Conn student model flute. A few days later my mother took me to Texas Tech to enroll in the six-week band camp. The person in charge didn’t want to enroll me because I was three years younger […]

The post Memorable Masterclasses appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>


   
    The summer after the fourth grade I traded my collection of 108 silver dollars for a Conn student model flute. A few days later my mother took me to Texas Tech to enroll in the six-week band camp. The person in charge didn’t want to enroll me because I was three years younger than the minimum age requirement, and I had never blown a note on the flute.
    My mother explained she needed a place for me to be while she was in graduate school classes all morning. Fortunately Eugene Doche, the camp flute professor and San Antonio Symphony Principal Flutist, took pity on my beautiful mother and said, “I will teach your daughter.” Classes started the next day. At 9 a.m. I accompanied Mr. Doche to the beginning class, at 10 to the intermediate class, and at 11 the advanced class. At noon he gave me a 15-minute private lesson to answer my questions. During the afternoon I practiced and practiced. In six weeks I completed the entire Ernest Wagner book and was well on my way to a life-long love affair with music-making and the flute.
    My story is not unusual among those who have attended a summer masterclass program; many of us have found that these exceptional experiences have changed our lives. For this roundtable discussion I invited five colleagues to share their stories of memorable summer masterclass programs.

   
Jerrold Pritchard

  
  Jerrold Pritchard completed his bachelor’s and master’s degrees at California State University, Sacramento and a D.M.A. at the University of Washington. His principle teachers were Merrill Jordan, Edna Comerchero, Sid Zeitlin, and Felix Skowronek. He also participated in master classes by Julius Baker and Marcel Moyse. He taught for 12 years at the University of Northern Iowa and just recently retired as Professor of Music at C.S.U., San Bernardino, where he was also Associate Provost/ Vice President for Academic Programs for 25 years.


    Having attended dozens of masterclasses taught by many well-known flutists and teachers, I believe that I have benefited from every one of them – even those that were badly organized or taught or that included students who were unprepared or not very advanced. In masterclasses students and performers can learn what not to do as well as what to do.
    Some of the least valuable experiences were when the performer was so polished and perfect that there was little for the teacher to say. I distinctly remember two occasions when Geoffrey Gilbert and Louis Moyse simply said, “Well done. What else you have to play?” Though you obviously don’t want to embarrass yourself in a public setting, I have found that much is learned when the class performer is open to advice and can make the changes. It is best when they have learned the piece well but have not perfected it yet or solidified their interpretation.
    One of my most rewarding masterclass experiences was when Moyse worked with a woman in her 60s who was almost a complete beginner. Someone had told her that, if she wanted to learn quickly at her age, she should go to the top players and teachers. She started lessons with Julius Baker. She then came to the legendary Moyse flute seminars in Brattleboro, Vermont after only six months of study! Moyse was so kind, understanding, and helpful to her. His instructions were precise and exactly matched to the needs of this beginning student. He guided her musically and technically and sent her on her way with good concepts and technical information about how to make the flute sing.
    I learned another valuable lesson from one of the first people to play at the Moyse class. He was a very advanced and talented player who had actually not enrolled in the class; he just came for the day to show off for the great man. Not understanding Moyse’ emphasis on expression, accuracy, control, and faithful realization of the composer’s written instructions, this fellow played a very fast and technically impossible piece with blazing fingers, a great deal of rubato, and questionable intonation. About halfway through the piece, he must have begun to understand who he was playing for and realized how inappropriate his choice of music and style was. He began to falter, and then tremble, and finally stopped. Moyse looked up at him with a smile and simply said, “Now we begin.”
    The wide variety of skill levels and backgrounds at the class made it very enjoyable and allowed Moyse to show the breadth and depth of his approach and perspective. The 25 or so members of the class became a supportive community that assisted and learned from each other rather than being a competitive group.
    I had fortunately brought along a big box of ensemble music, and we spent evenings at the comfortable old lodge playing flute duets, trios, and quartets together, laughing and sharing our backgrounds and experiences with the flute. By the end of the masterclasses, we had become friends and dawdled chatting over meals, went swimming, hiking and exploring the area. I still keep in contact with many of them years later.
    I only played twice for the class and was pleased to have done my best and been able to benefit from Moyse’ skillful and perceptive coaching. I have found that I benefit most from these types of group lessons from just listening attentively to others playing for the teacher and taking careful notes. I recently came across a long, detailed set of comments and quotations from Moyse that I made at that long ago class; I could still hear his voice, inflection, and wise advice in my mind. What memories!


Conor Nelson

    Conor Nelson gave his New York recital debut at Carnegie Hall’s Weill Recital Hall and has appeared as soloist with the Minnesota Orchestra and the Toronto Symphony Orchestra among numerous others. He is currently the Assistant Professor of Flute at Oklahoma State University.


    While still in high school I attended the Julius Baker Summer Masterclasses in Danbury, Connecticut. At that time, Baker gave a three-hour class every day, and the sounds that came out of his flute were purely magical to me. I quickly realized, however, that I was behind some of my peers, and from that moment on, I knew that I would need to work very hard in order to make it as a musician. A wide variety of guest artists also gave classes there, and I gained exposure to musical and technical ideas that were revolutionary for me. They inspired me to practice even harder.
    After one of my first performances in the class, Baker asked me where I was from. When I told him Toronto, he immediately lit up like a Christmas tree and said, “If you’re from Toronto, you simply must study with Susan Hoeppner.” I was familiar with her recordings and flattered that he thought I was ready. I remember leaving a message on Susan’s answering machine when I returned home that said, “Mr. Baker (her former teacher) recommended I study with you.” I am so thankful for that connection and the opportunity to study with her, as she will undoubtedly be a lifelong inspiration.
    At the Baker classes I also had the opportunity to observe a class taught by Linda Chesis, who would later become my principal teacher at Manhattan School. One of her Manhattan students at the Baker class helped me set up my first lesson with her in New York. When the time for the lesson arrived, I took an overnight bus from Toronto to New York and had the lesson the next morning. It was a lesson that changed my life forever. Her innovative ideas about tone production, breathing, and style simply blew me away. When she picked up her flute and played, I knew I had to go to M.S.M. She helped me through some difficult transitions in undergraduate school and was always there for me every week. It’s possible that I never would have met her if it had not been for the Baker classes
    Meeting serious flutists my age at the Baker classes also provided a new-found motivation. I met friends such as Mercedes Smith and David Buck, who now hold principal positions in the Pacific Symphony and the L.A. Phi n. I knew that flutists like Mercedes and David would be my competition for entrance to conservatories, so I worked harder upon my return to Toronto.
Mercedes and I ended up in the same freshman class together at the Manhattan School of Music and have been friends ever since. The opportunity to attend classes, festivals, and camps every summer for 12 years was a formative element of my musicianship. I also had a lot of fun!


Wendy Rolfe

    Professor at Berklee College of Music, Rolfe performs with the Handel and Haydn Society, Boston Baroque, New York’s Concert Royal, Toronto’s Tafelmusik, and in Latin America. She earned a bachelor of music degree from Oberlin Conservatory with Robert Willoughby and has masters and doctorate degrees from the Manhattan School of Music with Harvey Sollberger.


­    Playing Ravel’s Pavane, Bartok’s Rumanian Dances, and folk dancing amidst New Jersey cornfields are some of my most intense memories of the three summers I spent from ages 12 to 14 at the Appel Farm Arts and Music Center. My flute teacher and now dear friend, Jan Smith, was also the Center’s orchestra director (and swimming teacher). One summer, she challenged me to learn the first movement of the Mozart G-Major Concerto in two days, and I little realized that this was the beginning of a lifelong process.
    Red Fox Music Camp in the Berkshire Hills followed with thrilling rehearsals of Brahms’ Second Symphony. I think that was when the Boston Symphony Music Director Erich Leinsdorf came to conduct us.
    The next summer, before my senior year of high school, I inhaled, ingested, and became immersed in the French flute school at Jean-Pierre Rampal’s masterclasses in Nice, France. I lived with our family friends, the Cochereaus (Pierre Cochereau was then the Director of the Conservatoire in Nice and organist at Notre Dame) in their villa on the Mediterranean and rode my Mobilette (motorbike) to classes every day.
    Only later did I understand how much I had learned by absorbing the French style in such intensive sessions. I remember working on the “Cantilena” from the Poulenc Sonata with Monsieur Rampal and having the opportunity to be coached on the Mozart Flute and Harp Concerto by Lily Laskine, the legendary harpist.
    Then there was the summer as a Fellow at the Tanglewood Music Center. What a privilege to perform Wagner’s Tristan und Isolde with Leonard Bernstein, Stravinsky’s Rite of Spring with Seiji Ozawa, Bruckner with Klaus Tennstedt, and contemporary music with Gunther Schuller, while being coached by Doriot Anthony Dwyer. These summer music programs all profoundly changed my life, because I experienced making great music with great flutists and other musicians who took profound joy in sharing their art.”

Susan Antonetti
     University of Arkansas at Little Rock, Professor of Music (Wind Ensemble Conductor and Flute) Susan Antonetti holds degrees from Arkansas Tech University and the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville. She has conducted bands at the middle school, junior high and high school levels. Her bands at Bryant High School earned state-wide, regional, and national acclaim. She plays Principal Piccolo with the Little Rock Wind Symphony.


    After 18 years as a band director I retired and found myself returning to the instrument I fell in love with – the flute which had led me to band directing in the first place. The question was how to get back what I had as an undergraduate? The first thing I did was seek private lessons. That got me started, but it was workshops that rekindled the flame. 
    The first workshop I attended was a Flute Spa by Patricia George, and it changed everything I thought I knew about the flute. The next workshop I attended, however, sent the terrible message, “after a certain age, you might as well give up.” Fortunately the workshops that followed that one were amazing.
    Seek out workshops that feature an artist who is also a great teacher. There are amazing flutists out there who have little or no interest in teaching and then there are the gifts to the flute world – teachers such as Patricia George, Keith Underwood, Christina Smith, Rhonda Larson, Helen Speilman, and Lea Pearson – to name just a few. I have learned more about the flute in the past two years of attending workshops led by these amazing artists/teachers than any other teaching I’ve encountered. While workshops require a financial commitment, think about not only what you get from them, but what you will be able to give to yourself and your students. I’m hooked on masterclasses and workshops.

Elizabeth Buck

    Elizabeth Buck is Associate Professor of Music (Flute) at Arizona State University. She holds degrees from Rice University and The Juilliard School. She has served as Principal Flute with the Phoenix Symphony, been a Visiting Associate Professor at Indiana University’s Jacobs School of Music, and taught at the Brevard Music Center.

    Summer programs and masterclasses are great opportunities to travel, see the world, and experience new teachers, concepts, ideas, and friends. In high school, I participated in the Boston University Tanglewood Institute orchestral program. It was an unbelievable experience to meet serious classical musicians from all across the United States. 
    At Tanglewood, I listened to the Boston Symphony, took weekly lessons with Lois Schaefer, and played and practiced all summer long in the orchestral program with renowned guest conductors. This solidified many skills I still use and teach to this day. In fact, I’m still playing and performing with some of the same friends I made that summer – over 25 years later. When I got the job with both the Phoenix Symphony and later, Arizona State University, I had the wonderful circumstance to reconnect with Lois Schaefer. Schaefer moved to Arizona upon retirement from the Boston Symphony, and then donated her entire personal music library to A.S.U. Studying with her during the summer at Tanglewood essentially paved the way to my professional career and life-long connections in music. You can’t really get any more life-changing that that.

The post Memorable Masterclasses appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>