October November 2020 Archives - The Instrumentalist /category/october-november-2020/ Tue, 20 Oct 2020 21:09:39 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 2020 Directory of Music Schools /october-november-2020/2020-directory-of-music-schools/ Tue, 20 Oct 2020 21:09:39 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/2020-directory-of-music-schools/ Click here for The 2020 Directory of Music Schools Home page photo courtesy of Lawrence University, photo above courtesy of Gordon College.  

The post 2020 Directory of Music Schools appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

Home page photo courtesy of Lawrence University, photo above courtesy of Gordon College.

 

The post 2020 Directory of Music Schools appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Fuzzy Math /october-november-2020/fuzzy-math/ Tue, 20 Oct 2020 04:23:36 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/fuzzy-math/  His low, gravelly voice rumbled across the room like an earthquake. “Trey Reely. Do you have your homework?” “Yes, Mr. Powell,” I would reply meekly. Mr. Powell didn’t just teach algebra, he preached it. He held his tattered algebra text like it was Holy Scripture and spoke religiously about algebraic expressions and functions in a […]

The post Fuzzy Math appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
 His low, gravelly voice rumbled across the room like an earthquake. “Trey Reely. Do you have your homework?” “Yes, Mr. Powell,” I would reply meekly. Mr. Powell didn’t just teach algebra, he preached it. He held his tattered algebra text like it was Holy Scripture and spoke religiously about algebraic expressions and functions in a way usually reserved for a fire and brimstone sermon. I think he would be proud to know that I’m applying the little math knowledge I have retained to my musical pursuits. See if you can solve these brain teasers.


A concert band has seven trumpet players. The band is performing a three-movement work that calls for straight mutes in each movement. Two players accidentally drop their mutes during the first movement, and three more accidentally drop theirs during the second movement. How many trumpet players are left to drop their mutes in the third movement?

    None. The other two forgot to bring their mutes.

The director of a 100-member marching band excitedly mic drops from a 30-foot band tower following the setting of the final set. How many band members cheer as it hits the ground?

    99 – All but the majorette who didn’t get a solo.

How do you calculate the number of flag-line members in a band without seeing the band perform?

    Count the holes in the band room ceiling tiles and divide by two.

A beginning clarinet player chips his reed. How many more chips before he gets a new one?

    No single answer. This is directly proportional to when the band director notices.

What is the common denominator: 82% beginning band registration rate; 80% fundraiser participation rate; 100% dress rehearsal attendance?

    Pizza.

An eight-member trombone section has 20 measures of extended rests between rehearsal letters C and D. Then 12 more between letters D and E. Then 8 more from E to F. How many players will miss the entrance at letter F?

    None, because they all entered at letter E, and the director gave them a dirty look before cueing them at letter F.

The district band budget is $5,000. The district football budget is $25,000. How many candy bars must the band sell to equal the athletic budget?

    Based on dollar bars sold at 50% profit, the total would be 40,000. However, the band’s budget just dropped while doing the math for this problem, raising the total to 42,000 candy bars.

A percussion section is given six different parts for a concert selection. How many parts will still be available for the second rehearsal?

    Given that all six parts will be left on the music stand, an average of one part will disappear each class period until the next rehearsal. In a seven-period day, that means no music will be available.

A metronome and a typical band performing a march begin at quarter note = 120. Which finishes first?

    The metronome because the band drags the trio.

You are at a band’s halftime show. A clarinet section has 20 members. Clarinet player X is out-of-phase by measure three, with neither foot hitting on the beat. The tempo increases at measure 24, slows and changes to ¾ time at measure 48, then slows again for a majestic ending. How many clarinet players are in step?

    Clarinet player X if the tempo is ju-u-u-u-u-st right.

A band director buys a new set of wind chimes in August. How many bars will be missing from it by May?

    This will depend on the number of performances. Wind chimes are typically dropped every time they are moved, regardless of the age of the ensemble. The only thing that changes is the distance from which the winds chimes crash to the floor. So for four performances, one is looking at probably four drops and one lost bar for every other drop. Therefore, the answer most likely is two. However, the odds increase exponentially if the wind chimes are used during marching band.

A percussionist goes to the percussion cabinet for a triangle beater. What time of year will she have the most options in beater choices?

    The last week of school. There will be more options each month as more and more wind chime bars become available.

There are ten trumpet players in the section. How many of them have a pencil for rehearsal?

    None. They “never” make mistakes.

You are the director of a 114-member band. Your football team is the 12th seed playing the 1st-seed team whose school is located 372 miles away from your school. Your team throws 30 incomplete passes yet scores 50 points, and the opposing team throws 20 incomplete passes yet scores 80 points. The games ends at 11:20 pm. What is the only certainty in this scenario?

    The single place to stop on the way home for a break only has one bathroom.

A band director says “one more time.” How many more times will the band play it?

    As many as he/she feels like it.

What is 1/8 + 2.5/4 + 1.5/4 + 2/4 + 2/4 + 3/8 + ¼?

    Measures 2-8 of “Lord Melbourne” from Grainger’s Lincolnshire Posy.

There are four oboists in a band. The tuning is terrible. According to them, what percentage of the section is at fault?

    Zero. All of the blame should be placed on the reeds.

A jet is taking off near the band room at 140 decibels, an ambulance is driving by with a siren at 120 decibels, a jackhammer is drilling concrete at 110 decibels right outside the band room door, and firecrackers are going off at 160 decibels in the middle of the band room. How many alto saxophone players will have to stop playing for you to hear this?

    Assuming you have eight saxophones, probably seven of them if the remaining one has a bad reed.

It is May. Henry is a beginning trombone player. How many slide positions are available to Henry?

    Five if his right arm is strong enough.

Bonus: A 24-year-old band director making a salary of $30,000 per year that increases $550 annually is offered a job at a company for $60,000 per year with a 5% increase each year, yet declines the offer. Write this in the form of an equation.

    ($60,000y + i) < ($30,000y + z)*L
    y = years taught
    i = 5% salary increase compounded annually over course of your career
    z = $550 per year added each year over the course of your career
    L = love of watching your students grow to love the art of music

    Special thanks to Terry Hogard, Director of Bands at Brookland High School (Arkansas), for his assistance with this article.

 
 
 
 

The post Fuzzy Math appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Tambourine Technique /october-november-2020/tambourine-technique/ Tue, 20 Oct 2020 04:01:20 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/tambourine-technique/     The tambourine is one of the most common accessory percussion instruments and is used in many familiar musical styles, including rock, pop, and classical genres. Derived from jingle-bearing frame drums from around the world, such as the Brazilian pandeiro and the Egyptian riq, there are many approaches to playing the instrument. Even within […]

The post Tambourine Technique appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

    The tambourine is one of the most common accessory percussion instruments and is used in many familiar musical styles, including rock, pop, and classical genres. Derived from jingle-bearing frame drums from around the world, such as the Brazilian pandeiro and the Egyptian riq, there are many approaches to playing the instrument. Even within the concert percussion world, performers use numerous playing techniques. However, many non-percussionist directors and young players may be unaware of the fundamentals of tambourine tone production, resulting in performances with incorrect technique and poor sound quality.

Instrument Parts and Selection
    The most common concert tambourines have a diameter of ten inches, two rows of jingles, and either a calfskin or synthetic head. While calfskin heads remain a traditional choice of some professionals, synthetic heads are significantly more durable, require less maintenance, and are not affected by weather and humidity, making them ideal for school groups. A headless tambourine with a plastic shell is typically a handheld pop/rock instrument or mounted on a stand; it should not be used for concert playing.  
    Most tambourine shells are made of solid wood, although composite ply shells are available on less expensive models. In addition to jingle slots, each shell features a holding area without jingles so the player can grasp the shell. There is a hole in this area for mounting the tambourine on a cymbal stand – it is not intended for use while holding the instrument in the player’s hand.
    The jingles are made of three primary metals: silver (high pitch), copper (medium pitch), and bronze (low pitch). In addition to the metal used to construct them, the physical texture of the jingles has a significant effect on the instrument’s tone. Smooth, nickel-plated discs like German silver jingles provide the brightest jingle sound and greatest dynamic projection. Cor­rugated or fluted discs are heavier and duller sounding due to crimping, over hammering, and sometimes even excessive heating. These jingles are best used for delicate, quiet, and articulate playing. Most manufacturers offer tambourines with mixed jingle combinations, and picking the appropriate jingle sounds for your musical situation is an important consideration. If your program only has one tambourine, it is best to consider an instrument with a combination of bright and dark jingles that will complement most performance settings.

Instrument Grip and Playing Positions
    To execute all tambourine techniques with ease it is crucial to hold the instrument properly. With the tambourine head facing up, locate the holding area of the shell. Place the bottom of the shell in your non-dominant hand where the fingers meet the palm.

    Wrap fingers around the bottom of the shell,


and place the thumb above the shell on the drumhead. Do not put any fingers through the mounting hole on the side of the shell.


    In addition to holding the instrument, proper tambourine playing requires a designated playing position, rest position, and a method to transition from one position to another.

Playing Position
    Using the grip described above, lift the instrument so the forearm is parallel to the ground and then rotate the tambourine with your wrist so that it rests at a 45-degree angle.

    The angle of the tambourine affects how much excess jingling there is. Tilting the tambourine 45 degrees allows the jingles to quickly come to a rest after the drum has been activated, which eliminates any unwanted sounds from extraneous vibrations. Holding the tambourine perpendicular to the floor will produce the most extraneous sound. An instrument that is parallel to the floor allows a constricted vibration of the jingles, but there will still be some excess sound.

Rest Position
    Because the tambourine’s jingles are designed to move freely, the tambourine is one of the most challenging instruments to keep quiet when not in use. A resting position that allows the tambourine to be picked up as quietly as possible is essential. As with all accessory percussion instruments, the performer needs a trap table, music stand with a towel, or a padded surface on which to rest the tambourine. Placing the tambourine on a trap table with the holding area facing the player and the drumhead facing up will allow the player to smoothly and quietly pick up the instrument.

Transitioning Between Positions
    The player must also consider how to move silently from rest position to playing position. Using the non-dominant hand, grip the tambourine as described above and lift the instrument while keeping it parallel to the ground. This will help to keep the jingles flat and silent when preparing to play. To avoid extraneous jingling noise, do not switch the instrument from hand to hand.

    When the tambourine is near chest level, the instrument can be shifted to the 45-degree playing position. When returning the instrument to the table, ensure that the tambourine is flat so that there are no extraneous sounds from the shell striking the table multiple times.

Playing Zones and Techniques
    With the instrument in playing position, use the dominant hand to strike the tambourine. Do not move the drum to strike a hand or another surface. The ideal playing zone varies from the center of the tambourine head to directly over a set of jingles, depending on the desired timbre. The area toward the center is best for mezzo forte and louder passages because of the significant volume produced by a combination of head and jingle sounds. Striking on or near the rim provides more precise jingle sounds that are best for delicate, articulate passages at lower volumes.  

General Playing
    For moderately-soft to moderately-loud passages, cluster the thumb and fingers of the dominant hand together and strike the drumhead between the center and edge, directly across from the non-dominant hand holding the instrument in playing position.

Loud Passages
    To adjust for louder volumes and accented notes, form the hand into a loose fist and strike the drum in the center of the head with the flat of the knuckles as if knocking on a door.

Soft Passages
    Use the thumb and fingers to strike the instrument at the edge over a set of jingles. For the softest, most delicate effects, strike on the rim with only one finger.

To increase the dynamic level, strike the instrument with more fingers. To add head sound to the overall timbre, strike the drumhead closer to the center.

Techniques for Rapid
Rhythmic Passages
    Many composers write rhythmically-dense tambourine passages that are difficult, if not impossible, to execute with only one hand striking the tambourine. The following methods allow the player to execute quick rhythmic passages at varying dynamic levels.

Loud Rapid Passages (Knee-Fist Method)
    This advanced method uses the player’s dominant hand and knee to execute quick rhythms. Place one foot on a chair, snare drum case, or lower tripod of a drum stand. Turn the tambourine upside down (or have a second tambourine already resting upside down) and hold it so that the center of the head is a few inches above the propped-up knee. Make a loose fist as if initiating a powerful single stroke with the dominant hand above the center of the head.

     Strike the inside of the drum head with the fist, and then use the non-dominant hand to move the entire instrument and strike the outside of the batter head against the knee. For a consistent sound, ensure that the hand and knee strike the head in the same location. The fist is usually stronger, which can be used for emphasis in accented patterns.

Soft Rapid Passages
    Similar to the technique for loud rapid passages, place one foot on a chair, snare drum case, or lower tripod of a drum stand. Lay the tambourine on the propped-up thigh with the head facing up. Rest forearms or palms on the drumhead to control the sound by varying the pressure and how much of the head is covered or muted. Using the fingertips, strike the rim over top of a set of jingles closest to the knee . Make sure that hands are positioned symmetrically for an even sound.

    As with soft single strokes, adjust dynamic levels by adding or subtracting the number of fingers used by each hand. If searching for an alternative to resting the instrument on a leg, lay the tambourine on a trap table cushioned with a towel or padding. Play near the rim with the fingertips of both hands over the top of a set of jingles. Control the sound of the instrument by varying the pressure and muffling of the head with wrists and forearms as described above.

Stand-Mount Method
    This method is primarily used when the composer specifically requests the use of sticks or mallets. Using the mounting hole in the tambourine, attach the tambourine to a cymbal stand. Use extra cymbal felts if necessary and tighten down the cymbal wing nut to prevent the tambourine from moving or rotating excessively.

    Extra care must be taken when using mallets or sticks to avoid breaking the head. Consider using a mountable plastic pop/rock tambourine to spare the high-quality concert tambourine from being struck with sticks.

Tambourine Rolls
    Tambourine rolls are one of the most frequently misunderstood tambourine techniques. Confusion occurs when determining how to execute the roll itself, attempting to create a sustained sound (as opposed to a rapid succession of rhythmic attacks), and accurately starting and stopping the roll. The first decision facing a performer is choosing between the shake and friction (thumb/finger) rolls.

Shake Rolls
    Shake rolls are best for louder dynamic levels and longer rolls. When initiating a shake roll, hold the tambourine in the standard playing position described above. Begin the roll by striking the instrument with your dominant hand – much like a wind player articulating the beginning of a sustained note with their tongue. The player can envision ‘pushing’ the tambourine into the shake roll with this initial attack. Using the wrist and forearm, rotate the tambourine from left to right as if turning a doorknob back-and-forth.


    To become comfortable and produce a smooth, sustained sound, practice this motion slowly and then speed up to ensure proper execution. Just as the roll began with a clean attack, it must conclude with an attack to define the roll duration. When striking the drum to release the roll, immediately return the tambourine to the standard 45-degree playing position to ensure the jingles stop moving.

Friction Rolls
    Friction (thumb and finger) rolls are best used for softer dynamics and shorter rolls. To achieve this technique, the player will skip the thumb or middle finger around the perimeter of the head. The player should hold the tambourine in playing position, with the finger or thumb of the dominant hand on the edge of the tambourine close to the holding area.



    Friction rolls performed by middle finger (above) and thumb (below).




    The fleshy part of the thumb or finger exerts a light rubbing motion around the rim of the head, causing the jingles to vibrate. Proper execution requires the head to be tacky. Many players apply beeswax or bass bow rosin to the head, while others wear a rubber thumb or finger cover.
    For a soft release, drop your pointer finger  into the head as you lift your friction thumb/finger away from the instrument.
    For an accented release, you can drop the heel of your hand onto the drumhead instead of your finger.


 

Visual Dynamics
    Playing the tambourine is inherently theatrical due to the visual elements produced by the techniques described above – especially when con­sidering dynamic levels. In addition to striking the drum with more force to produce louder sounds, holding the instrument near the player’s waist and raising it higher in the air as the volume increases can emphasize a crescendo. This allows the conductor and audience to view the instrument as the passage becomes louder. The same concept can apply to a decrescendo, only the player will start with the tambourine higher in the air and then lower it as the passage becomes softer. The tambourine can be held near the player’s eye level when executing louder passages and closer to the stomach level for quieter passages to enhance dynamic levels visually.

Additional Considerations
    High-quality concert tambourines require proper care and maintenance. It is essential to take precautions to make sure that the instrument is always in good working order. The tambourine should be stored in a protective case or bag and should not have heavy items stacked on it. Periodically inspect the head and shell to ensure there are no cracks, pulls, or head tears. 

The post Tambourine Technique appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Five Rules to Develop Musicianship /october-november-2020/five-rules-to-develop-musicianship-2/ Tue, 20 Oct 2020 03:22:44 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/five-rules-to-develop-musicianship-2/       Many middle school music teachers focus on getting the notes and rhythms first and plan to make it musical later. Understandably, beginning students are overwhelmed by the many basic elements they have to learn and apply. Unfortunately, there never seems to be enough time to add in the musicianship and over time, […]

The post Five Rules to Develop Musicianship appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
 
    Many middle school music teachers focus on getting the notes and rhythms first and plan to make it musical later. Understandably, beginning students are overwhelmed by the many basic elements they have to learn and apply. Unfortunately, there never seems to be enough time to add in the musicianship and over time, students become complacent as they feel they have mastered playing the notes and rhythms and never get to the stage of asking what else should they should be doing.

    To avoid this problem, teachers should develop a basic musicianship curriculum for beginning and intermediate flutists that will teach them how to play musically and expressively. They learn musicianship skills in a simplified format and can then apply them to their pieces. The following is one such method.

One Note
    The first exercise is to teach students to play a single note with even air. With the tuner have students play a single A on the headjoint only. At this stage tell them to not worry whether the note is sharp or flat. The goal is just to keep the needle still while playing the note. With experimentation they will quickly figure out how to portion the air when playing a long note with even air. They will also learn how to make an attack in tune rather than going sharper at the beginning of the note.

Two Notes
    Next, introduce students to the idea that two slurred notes are played as strong/weak or loud/soft. As a visual reference you can explain that in violin bow strokes, the sound is stronger near the frog where the hand holds the bow and can apply pressure more easily and gets weaker as the player pulls the bow out to the tip. This means that a two-note down bow slur on a violin naturally will start strong and become weaker.

    Two slurred notes are nearly always played with this dynamic design. This idea also works well for any two articulated notes. The note duration of the two notes does not matter. It might be a whole note slurred to a quarter, a half note to an eighth, etc.
    When applying the loud/soft idea to a phrase, the entire phrase is played at the printed dynamic, but within the passage some notes will be played softer and others with more stress. This deviation of dynamic is called inflection. You can illustrate the idea for students by having them speak with no inflection in a monotone voice and then making it more engaging with inflection.  
    Students can practice scales with this two-note idea. To accomplish this, the aperture or opening of the lips is made smaller by squeezing the lips together and the speed of the air may be reduced depending on the range or tessitura. This should be worked on at the slowest of tempos. Place four vibrato cycles on the first note and three vibrato cycles on the second note. The finger(s) should move just as one cycle ends, and the next begins. This also will help students end phrases with a taper.

Repeated Notes
    Many of the most elementary pieces have repeated notes. These too should have dynamic design. Start by demonstrating how playing repeated notes at the same dynamics is boring for the listener. Then introduce the strength of the beat principle. (If a piece is in common meter, the first beat is the strongest, followed by the third, second and fourth beats.) In playing repeated notes, they should consider the strength of the beats first. If repeated notes begin on a weak beat and end on a strong one, they can increase the dynamic with each note to create forward motion.

Articulatory Silence
    J.J. Quantz wrote in his book, On Playing the Flute about articulatory silence. He noted “The notes must not appear to be glued together.” It was as good advice then as it is now. Articulatory silence is the nano second of silence good musicians place between syncopated notes. It is also the silence that replaces a dot in articulated rhythms. There is also an articulatory silence between groups of slurred notes.

Syncopation


Dotted Rhythms

Dotted or Tied Notes Under a Slur
    A good rule to remember is decay or diminuendo to the dot or tie. I use the anacronym DDT for decay to the dot or tie. Remember this rule only applies to notes under a slur. This will help flutists add nuance to their playing. Two concerns to remember: If the phrase ends after the dot, then all notes after the dot are played more softly. If the phrase continues after the dot, the first notes are played softer and then it should crescendo into the next strong beat.

In this example the notes after the dot are softer.

Here the phrase continues, so the eighth notes start softly and then crescendo into the next strong beat.

Start Softer after a Breath
    This is an issue for flutists of all levels. They come to the end of a phrase, take a big breath and then have so much air that the next notes played are too loud. Remind students to consciously play softer after a breath to control the shape of their phrases and make them conversational.

Practice with a Phrase
   
    This melodic fragment illustrates these five basic rules of inflection. Work with students so that they can execute these rules in a convincing manner. Then experiment with other phrases.

 Clues from a Title
    Tell students the title of this fragment is Butterfly, and then have them think about how that might change their performance choices. Perhaps everything will be lighter and more dance-like as a butterfly goes from one flower to the next. To imitate a butterfly, they might play at a slightly faster tempo and make the notes a little less full bodied.
    Then say that it is called Appassionato. Would the notes be fuller bodied and the vibrato more pronounced? Ask students to come up with titles of their own and experiment with different ideas. Changing the title of a piece or exercise is a beneficial practice tool to expand creativity.
    These simple five rules can greatly  improve musicianship, and they do not take much time. Start by working on one for a few minutes each week. Students who learn these ideas early will find easy to incorporate them into their music as they advance. They will likely enjoy exploring the vast world of musical expression as they learn the tools to make their performances exciting for listeners and themselves.

 

The post Five Rules to Develop Musicianship appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
When Bud Came to Play: Courage, Solutions, and Influence /october-november-2020/when-bud-came-to-play-courage-solutions-and-influence/ Tue, 20 Oct 2020 02:55:24 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/when-bud-came-to-play-courage-solutions-and-influence/       It happened right on stage in front of an audience of 500 parents and probably every serious trumpet teacher and student in the region. There he stood; a man considered to be the greatest orchestral trumpet player in the world – Adolph Herseth. Poised, confident, engaging the entire audience with his gaze, […]

The post When Bud Came to Play: Courage, Solutions, and Influence appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
 
    It happened right on stage in front of an audience of 500 parents and probably every serious trumpet teacher and student in the region. There he stood; a man considered to be the greatest orchestral trumpet player in the world – Adolph Herseth. Poised, confident, engaging the entire audience with his gaze, ready for his entrance. The Haydn Trumpet Concerto in E-flat Major had by then become his signature piece. In he came, and all were swept away on the musical journey to unfold.
    One morning I was struggling to come up with a special year-end experience for my high school band students while saying to the choral director and assistant band director how great but unlikely it would be to have someone like Herseth perform. The choral director sat patiently listening to me carry on, but my assistant band director casually chimed in suggesting that I call him; he had his number in his musician’s union phone directory. There was no reason to back down. It would just take gathering up the courage to place the call.
    My reverence for Adolph Herseth was long standing, and I was not alone. In 1948 at the age of 26 he was appointed principal trumpet of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra and would remain in that position for an amazing 56 years of unparalleled devotion to his art. In no small measure he and his CSO colleagues set an unmatched standard of orchestral brass playing.
    So, telephone in hand, my heart was pounding, panicking over what I would actually say if Herseth answered. One ring, two rings…and then there he was.
    “Hello.”
    “Hi, Mr. Herseth?”
    “Yes.”
    After clumsily introducing myself I managed, “I’m calling to ask if you might consider coming out to play with our high school band and choir on our spring concert?”
    Without hesitation, “When is it?”
    “M-May twenty-third,” I stammered.
    “Hold on, let me check my book.” Clunk went the phone receiver, as I waited with bated breath.
    Then, “Sure. I can do that.”
    And there it was. Adolph Herseth, not only took my call, but had agreed.
    Our concerts were collective department efforts, so the top Symphonic Band and Acapella Choir presented them jointly. It was decided to program not only the Haydn concerto, but also Norman Dello Joio’s Song of the Open Road for mixed chorus and solo trumpet, plus Awake the Trumpet’s Lofty Sound from George Frederick Handel’s oratorio Samson involving everyone – not only the choir and band, but two solo trumpets as well. Amazingly Herseth agreed to it all. An added bonus was to have our first chair trumpet play alongside our guest soloist on the Handel. What made that exceptional was that she was not only an excellent player, but had conquered the challenge of playing beautifully with a full mouth of braces.

    Plans were made. Herseth would rehearse with us on the day of the concert. That morning, I was a bundle of nerves anticipating his arrival, praying that our intense rehearsing over many weeks was enough preparation to be worthy of providing the musical accompaniments. He arrived well before the rehearsal and immediately put me at ease with his warm yet business-like manner. The band filed onto the stage, and we warmed up and tuned. You could feel the excitement as well as tension as I introduced Mr. Herseth. The students applauded, he smiled, bowed and said that he was pleased to be with us. He was holding an unlacquered rather shabby-looking rotary valve trumpet on which to play the concerto. He raised it above his head so that everyone could see his horn and cracked, “See? This is what happens when you don’t take care of your instrument.” We all laughed realizing that this was an instrument appropriately chosen to be used for this piece. The rehearsal went well; balance was good and tempos were adjusted. He asked how I thought the concert would be attended and I told him that we were sold out; tickets were gone. With that, we were all set for the concert.
    That evening Herseth entered to thunderous applause, bowed, nodded to me that he was ready, and off we went into the introduction. He made his initial entrance and that’s where the mini drama began – all completely unknown to me or the audience. The concerto ended, we shook hands, and I strode off into the wings following him. He turned to me and said, “That was good!” I was about to faint at the praise when he quickly added, “Now, being a good band director, I’m sure you’ll have a needle and thread in your desk drawer, right?”
    “Why yes, as a matter of fact I do. Follow me.”
    My office was only a few steps from the stage. As we sat down and I searched for the sewing kit, compliments of my dear wife Jane who was known as the uniform lady for the band, Herseth explained what had happened during the performance.
    As the introduction neared the end, he raised his instrument and made his entrance. During the next solo break, he realized that his tux coat had come unbuttoned. He said he reached down to redo it, and the button, which had been hanging by a thread, came off in his hand. Ever so discreetly he slipped it in his side pocket, and no one seemed to notice. We had videoed the concert, and later, we saw it happen. All captured on tape. No drama. Just a display of being calm and cool no matter the circumstance.
    Herseth calmly sewed his tux button back into place as we chatted during the choir performance. What an opportunity! The conversation moved from my love of the CSO to his recent visit to the eye doctor. It seemed that he needed to have a change in his eyeglass prescription. His doctor encouraged him to consider getting trifocals. All the better to see his music and the conductor he explained. With a twinkle in his eye, Herseth said, “Not interested. I don’t look at them anyway!” We chuckled, and with that it was time to return to the stage. Button problem solved.
    The remainder of the concert went wonderfully. Afterwards, Herseth stayed to sign autographs and visit with students and parents. Back in the music office, there were warm goodbyes as Mr. and Mrs. Herseth departed for home. We directors were left with the most fantastic afterglow. Some exceptional music was made that night, and everyone talked about the concert for weeks afterward.
    The lessons I learned were many and long-lasting.

    Dream big. Sum­mon the courage to identify and seek the best possible models for you and your students to emulate. I picked up that telephone months earlier placing the call to invite Mr. Herseth, quaking as I did
so but have thanked my lucky stars ever since.
    Analyze the experiences you have and identify the things that you can learn from them; never be reluc­tant to change plans to best suit specific circumstances. I thought the Haydn concerto would be played on that rather scruffy looking horn, but it wasn’t. Mr. Herseth determined, perhaps based on the acoustics of the packed hall and other reasons, that his regular Bach trumpet would be the better choice. Also, standing right next to him as he played, I never really heard sound coming directly from his horn. Rather, it came from him. As odd as that seems, all I can say is that there was an absence of tongue/attack. His sounds were immediate. From that time forward I tried as much as I could to emphasize the elimination of hearing fixed percussive attacks in my student’s playing.
    Have resources handy to address situations that may not be anticipated before they occur. Who would imagine needing a sewing kit at the ready for use by a guest artist in the middle of a performance? You just never know.
    Provide your students with the best possible music and experiences; the results can have long lasting influence. To this day, many of my former students are patrons of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, play and sing in community and church groups all over the country, and best of all, have lingering fond memories of an evening when Bud came to play.  

The post When Bud Came to Play: Courage, Solutions, and Influence appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Set Yourself Up for Success In College and Beyond /october-november-2020/set-yourself-up-for-success-in-college-and-beyond/ Tue, 20 Oct 2020 02:43:59 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/set-yourself-up-for-success-in-college-and-beyond/ photo courtesy of Lawrence University     College is an exciting time for students to learn, discover, and have new experiences, yet it can also be a period that is quite overwhelming for many. This feeling can often prevent students from having a clear vision of their overall college career. Frequently, they are focused on […]

The post Set Yourself Up for Success In College and Beyond appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>


photo courtesy of Lawrence University

    College is an exciting time for students to learn, discover, and have new experiences, yet it can also be a period that is quite overwhelming for many. This feeling can often prevent students from having a clear vision of their overall college career. Frequently, they are focused on assignments due for the next day or week and find it challenging to look past the semester let alone what they will be doing after graduation. As a teacher, one of my goals is to help students see the broader picture of their academic journey and to offer advice and insight to direct them on their path. Having been a student myself for many years, I can look back on my experiences with perspective and share what I have learned with my students. My intention is to provide steps they can take while in college that will allow them to transition smoothly into their profession.

Setting Goals
    One of the most important first steps to success is to set a goal. Know what you are working towards and ask yourself what it is you see yourself doing three to five years after graduation. The best way to commit to a plan or goal is to write it down. Having the goal on paper allows you to firmly establish and commit to your aspirations. Be specific and try to detail every aspect of your ideal job including who, what, when, where, why, and how. Once you have a clear idea of your long-term target, assess your timeframe and set short attainable goals that align with your vision. Establish daily, weekly, monthly, semester, yearly, and five year goals. Make sure your objectives are both challenging and achievable. If you find yourself setting goals, but falling short of them, reevaluate and adjust to make the target more manageable.

Organizing Your Time
    Structure your micro and macro goals in a way that works best for you. Utilize calendars, journals, and practice logs to help you stay on track. Write down goals for the day or week and mark off what you accomplished. Be aware and take notes of the annual opportunities within your school, area, and state. This includes competitions, masterclasses, camps, and festivals. Keep these on your radar and write down deadlines in your calendar with enough advance notice that you can plan for them in the coming semester or year.
    Take advantage of the academic breaks and use the time that you have during the winter, spring, and summer to reset goals and plan new projects. You can use this time to research festivals, masterclasses, band camps, or specialized studies that appeal to you. I recommend choosing one or two experiences that interest you the most and work towards making that a reality.  Allow yourself six months to a year to plan for these events so that you have enough time to prepare applications, recordings, letters, save money, and find opportunities for financial support to help cover expenses.

Building Experiences
    Whatever your goal is, find ways to build experiences into your college education that will help you achieve your vision. Look for opportunities to work in your chosen field while in school. This can include work study, working in the library or at a music store, teaching private lessons at local high schools and middle schools, or leading high school marching band sectionals during the summer or fall. These experiences not only allow you to make money while going to school but are great opportunities to build connections and relationships. You can often maintain these jobs even after graduation.
    Be open to as many diverse experiences as possible. This will give you more depth as a person and musician. Get involved and volunteer at your university and in the region by helping out with music camps, festivals, music fraternities and sororities, or regional competitions. This can lead to creating a great mentorship with directors and teachers, a student teaching opportunity, or possible employment.

Networking and Cultivating Relationships

    Get out in the schools and start working with young students while you are still in college.  Inquire about opportunities to teach lessons or provide a free clinic on basic fundamentals such as hand position, fingerings, or embouchure formation. Most directors will appreciate your initiative and be eager to have you come out to work with their beginning students. Not only does this build relationships with area directors, but it is a great teaching opportunity that allows you to develop your teaching skills in a friendly environment. Teaching takes practice, so the more you do it, the better you become.
    Fostering and sustaining good relationships is a big part of creating a thriving career in music. Your professors are one of the most important resources that are available to you. Find mentors and teachers who you admire and look up to and who you want to shape your teaching after. Cultivate a good rapport with your professors for they will be your biggest advocates as you transition to the next step in your career.
    Support your friends.  Go to their performances, exchange ideas, and learn from each other. Find people who you enjoy playing with, who have the same aspirations as you, and who are eager to collaborate. The friends you make in college will become life-long colleagues later in life. They will be your greatest support system not only during college, but throughout your career.

Developing Your Portfolio
    Your musical portfolio is a variety of materials that represents who you are as a teacher and musician. It can include your bio, cover letter, resume, headshots, teaching philosophy, and musical recordings. Work to build a diverse and comprehensive portfolio that includes your education, teaching experience, leadership activities, performances, service, and accolades. As you begin to organize your resume, take note of which sections are sparse and begin to create opportunities and experiences for you to add to these areas.
    Recordings are another important aspect of your musical portfolio. This can contain any performances you have given throughout the year. Strive to record and save your recitals and departmental and studio class performances. Have a variety of both audio and visual recordings. In addition to live performances, take some time throughout the semester to record a solo piece on your own. Ask a friend to record for you and use a space that enhances your playing.  This process allows you to listen back, observe, fix mistakes, and grow as a musician.
    Building your portfolio will take time so do not be overwhelmed with the process.  If possible, begin developing your portfolio during your first year of college and update it each semester. Having these materials ready to go will benefit you if you should ever apply for festivals, competitions, graduate school, or a job.

Establishing Good Habits
    It’s important to establish a strong foundation of good habits at any stage in your life. The habits you establish while in school will ultimately benefit you and help shape your success for the future. Begin developing good communication skills while in high school and college.  This means responding to emails and phone calls from your professors and colleagues in a professional, appropriate, and timely manner. Quick and courteous responses will help you to secure gigs and future jobs and establish yourself as a considerate, responsible and dependable individual. If someone contacts you with an opportunity and you allow too much time to pass, there is always a chance the prospect will go to someone else.
    Be early and prepared for classes and rehearsals. As everyone knows, the golden rule in music is “to be early is to be on time and to be on time is to be late.” Make sure that you are prepared with your materials and music, in your seat, and with your instrument ready to go at least 15 minutes before a rehearsal. This will allow you time to look over difficult sections and get in the right head space for the rehearsal.
    Be careful about how you present yourself. Be courteous, respectful, professional, and kind. These are just a few character traits that will set you apart from others and will draw others to you. A significant part of any job search is for others to recognize that you can work well with other individuals, are a good fit for the position, and can successfully contribute in that position.

Health and Wellness
    Following a career in music can be challenging and demanding so it is vital to listen to your body and give yourself down time. Strive to create balance by allowing yourself to rest, get plenty of sleep, eat well, and exercise. Music often begins as a source of enjoyment when you are young. That hobby can take on a different role as you get further into your musical studies and career, so it is even more important to create balance and find enjoyable interests outside of music.
    You will experience many challenges in your life but know that growth occurs during these difficult times. Just because something is arduous does not mean you are on the wrong path. Do not stop because you are challenged. Instead, dig deeper into the experience. 

The post Set Yourself Up for Success In College and Beyond appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Not Finished Yet /october-november-2020/not-finished-yet/ Tue, 20 Oct 2020 02:29:52 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/not-finished-yet/     I would like to take this opportunity to thank the tens of thousands of music educators who are facing the toughest year of their careers. Like all of you, I spent last spring learning to navigate the waters of our new normal.  However, my perspective was a bit different from most. I was […]

The post Not Finished Yet appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

    I would like to take this opportunity to thank the tens of thousands of music educators who are facing the toughest year of their careers. Like all of you, I spent last spring learning to navigate the waters of our new normal.  However, my perspective was a bit different from most. I was completing my 40th and final year as a band director – my retirement planned before anyone had even heard of Covid-19. Since then I have enjoyed sleeping in, spending time with family and friends, planning a winter getaway, and learning that there is life outside of the band room. However, I have greatly missed my students and co-workers, and as time goes on, I will miss concerts, parades, football games, festivals, conferences, and so much more.

    I had no idea that my final semester as a band director would involve a global pandemic. I was so unsure as to what the future would bring. My days were filled with awaiting student emails, assignment submissions, and Zoom meetings. I spent a great deal of time reconnecting with music that I had not taken the time to listen to in decades. In teaching band for 40 years, I had lost some of my own connectivity to the joys of great band literature. Through all of those dark days, I became even more sure of how much of a difference band makes in the lives of our students. We must not give up on helping them to learn the joy of making and sharing music.
    As a child, I was the only redhead in my elementary school and stuck out like the proverbial sore thumb. I was shy, introverted, unsure of myself, and really just wanted to blend in. That all changed in 6th grade when I started in band. Over the years, being in band gave me confidence. I had a place to belong. I was safe in band. I was successful in band. That shy, gawky redhead learned to have a voice, become a leader, and share a passion for music and music education. One day, she even had the confidence to introduce herself to a stranger at the Midwest Clinic, a band director named John Warren from a far-away place called North Dakota. The rest, as they say, is history. Band not only made a difference in my life – it gave me my life – and what a life it has been!
    I began my career in rural Alabama.  Having grown up there, I thought I knew my state. I was wrong. When I started teaching in 1980, I had many students whose parents were coal miners. One day I took a student home and realized her family did not have indoor plumbing. I had seen outhouses but did not realize that people still used them. A few weeks later her grandfather came to me and said he wanted to buy his granddaughter a new trumpet. Knowing there might be a lack of money, I suggested that the one she had was just fine. “No, we want to get her a good one because band just might be what helps her go to college someday.” He was right. That Bach trumpet helped her go to college. I have seen that type of thing repeated countless times in my 40 years.
    I hope all band directors continue to realize what an impact they have on their band families. This was brought home to me as I stood in front of my band at State Contest, a day after our trombone section leader was buried. I looked at the band just before starting On a Hymnsong of Philip Bliss and thought, “I can’t do this. You have to.” With Justin’s family sitting in the audience, those kids gave a truly superior performance. Our band grieved as any family would at such a tragic time, but we leaned on each other for support.
    I must give thanks to the greatest band people in my life including my high school director Bill Brunner and my college director Edd Jones. The passion my fellow teachers have for band students and music education has always inspired me to be a better teacher. This group of people includes “The Cullman County Connection,” the “Chick Band Directors,” and the band staffs at Ft. Payne High School and Mandan Middle School. These wonderful teachers certainly make a difference in their students’ lives.
    Early in my career, a college teacher encouraged me to get involved in the professional organizations of music education. They have made such a difference in my teaching. I have had the wonderful opportunity to work with music educators through membership in and service to the Alabama Bandmasters Association, the Alabama & North Dakota Music Educators Association, and Phi Beta Mu. Seeing professionals come together to teach each other, learn from each other, and share with each other makes all of us better teachers. I truly look forward to continuing professional affiliations as well as my personal music education even in retirement.
    So, as you all continue your band journey please remember this on the toughest of days – you will get through this time. You will come out stronger, more resourceful, more empathetic, and even a better music educator than when this madness began. What you do matters. What we do matters. I can’t be finished just yet. I have so much more that I want to share, so much more I want to learn.
    In May I realized that the end of my 40th year would not be what I expected. There was no huge crescendo and rallentando with a grand chord on my final fermata. Instead, it was a slight ritardando, at pianissimo, and with a very gentle release on the final note. I have always loved slow and pretty much more than grandioso. I am fine with my ending because it really isn’t an ending. I am sure there is at least one more D.S. al Coda in my future.

– Rebecca Rodgers Warren, Wife, Dog Mom, and still a Band Director

 
 
 
 
 

The post Not Finished Yet appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Including Everyone An Interview with Rachel Maxwell /october-november-2020/including-everyone-an-interview-with-rachel-maxwell/ Tue, 20 Oct 2020 02:12:39 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/including-everyone-an-interview-with-rachel-maxwell/     Now in her 26th year at Traughber Junior High School in Oswego, Illinois, Rachel Maxwell believes that it is possible for any student to perform at the highest standards. “If they do keep playing after high school, that’s great, but it is more important to me that they come out of our program […]

The post Including Everyone An Interview with Rachel Maxwell appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

   
Now in her 26th year at Traughber Junior High School in Oswego, Illinois, Rachel Maxwell believes that it is possible for any student to perform at the highest standards. “If they do keep playing after high school, that’s great, but it is more important to me that they come out of our program having an appreciation for excellence, digging in and tearing apart the composition, step-by-step methodical work, and understanding the value of that while being better consumers of fine arts. I want students to be stronger, better, more caring, and more understanding about the world around them. If they come out with this skill set, they are going to be good at everything. They can go into any career, understand how to go from point A to point B, and know how success looks and feels. No one can take the confidence from a student who knows how to do that.”


Last December, you presented to a packed house at the Midwest Clinic. What was your topic?
    At Midwest, I presented a clinic titled Excellence and the Inclusive Ensemble. It received some criticism online prior to the convention from people saying, “I’m going to Midwest to hear the best of the best. I don’t want to hear this bleeding heart stuff.” To me this was a bit funny, because, while we joke and have fun in class, I am the last person to be a bleeding heart; we work until we get things down.
This is the secret to a great band: You teach all the students in front of you until they get things exactly right. We have all heard directors reminisce about the band from 2002 that was the best they ever had, but you don’t have that group anymore. Don’t let that affect your approach to this year’s students. Kids are kids. If you break concepts down, teach them, repeat, and model, every student in that room can learn and improve.

As you watched your students move to the high school program, what did you notice, and how did it change your perspective?
    One thing I see frequently is middle-of-the-road students in junior high becoming strong players or leaders in high school. I think there is a danger in giving too little attention to the students who aren’t at the top, especially in junior high. Seventh and eighth graders aren’t finished – they are just starting. Some are already rock stars, and some will never be more than average performers, but some are late bloomers who become the foundation of the high school program.
    This realization pushed me to pay more attention to the students who weren’t the best, to make sure they are not treated differently – and don’t feel like they are treated differently – than the top players. Teachers rarely know everything about their students’ lives. We don’t know what extent the family makes practicing – or schooling in general – a priority.
    It is impossible to tell in beginning band what a student is going to be. Children change a lot between sixth and twelfth grade, often going through numerous personalities and interests. Teach to where you want them to be. They might not be the best players in junior high, but then the high school concert or jazz band sparks them, and they ask, “What do I need to do to be part of that?”
    The other side of that is the students who breeze through junior high through sheer talent and only realize in high school that they have to pair that with hard work. Some of these students realize they like band better as a hobby, and they learn to be accept getting passed by the students who are working hard to excel.
    If we truly believe that music education is good for every kid, then it is going to be especially good for lower-achieving students. Those are the children who need it for the long haul. Research about ability-based groupings in other content areas shows that when you ability track, there is not as much growth in the high-end kids, and there is almost no growth in the low-end kids, but when you mix those two populations the high-end kids still continue to develop but those middle- and low- kids improve along with them, so our focus has shifted over the last ten years.

How do you work with students who might have learning disabilities?
    If you believe that special education students are going to hold you back and that ability-based bands are the only way to have an excellent ensemble, that is well and good for the programs that want to be ability based. I think every student, especially in the first years of band, deserves an outstanding experience. I don’t want anyone to feel like they never got a chance to shine or was never pushed because they were in an ability-based band.
    A student who just graduated from high school had regular seizures and, diagnostically, a low IQ,  but she mastered some first clarinet parts in my band. It wasn’t a sympathy chair; she earned it (plus, we rotate all our chairs anyway). We booked a concert at Chicago’s Orchestra Hall with a high school and a college, and there was no way I was going to exclude her.
    I talked to her about how she was going to approach it, and she had a private teacher who helped quite a bit in preparation. In IEP meetings, her core teachers only talked about her limitations, but we saw her blow past every limitation based on her work ethic and her desire to be part of what everybody else is doing. Music might be the only time a student like her is on a team with honors and AP students. I think she accomplished so much because we told her she could and acted like it was normal. We gave her a part, told her to work on fingerings, tone, and good playing technique, and it never entered her mind that she couldn’t do it.

Where and how did you learn the importance of high expectations?
    I was lucky to be in the honors program and take horn lessons as my honors track. This meant extra recitals and projects in the horn studio, which pushed me into what I felt would prepare me to take auditions. It wasn’t until my student teaching that I started liking band more than performing. I was a high-anxiety performer and didn’t have the tools to handle that at the time. I elected not to go to grad school and took a teaching job in West Aurora, Illinois instead.
    Lily Fagan, my mentor there, showed me that students can do more than most people think and do it better than expected as well. Her approach was that there was a right way and a wrong way to do things, and we are going to do things the right way. This reminded me of the standards in drum corps and my college horn studio, and I knew that was the kind of band director I wanted to be.

Why do you set such high standards with young players?
    Your standards determine your results. I think that what many directors need is confidence. People say things like, “I have a great band, but we don’t play—” and I ask them to stop. Stop aiming your goals toward the bottom end. Start supporting the bottom end and aim your goals past the top students. Everybody will come along. Not every student will get there at the same time or in the same way, but believe in your students. Some students will link arms and skip toward success, and other have to be dragged there. Invariably, the ones who have to be dragged realize success is more fun than they thought it was when they get there.
    My approach is to expect the worst player in the section and the worst behaved student in the section to play and behave at a certain level that’s pretty close to the same level as anybody else. There is no room for poor playing or bad behavior. It is not what we do. This goes back to pedagogical expectations from day one – that you teach students how to sit, have a good embouchure, and hold their instrument correctly. We frequently joke, “We do things one way: the right way.” There is no reason to not do things the right way; no matter who you are, you can hold a trombone correctly and count to four.
    The Chicago Symphony players are not sitting with their legs hooked on their chairs, bodies scrunched over, or elbows next to their body, nor do they play out the sides of their mouths. Good technique is the same at every level, and whether a young band has it comes down to a director’s grit and conviction that it can be mastered and that it will be revisited until it is done right. I tell them, “I’ve done this for like 30 years, so I know I can go longer than you on wanting it right,” but at the same time, it isn’t a war. Athletic coaches point out flaws in technique often, and it isn’t meant to be punitive. Students don’t get in trouble for sloppy technique; fixing it is just part of the job. However, it has to be packaged in a way that is personable and appealing to the students. Model often, make jokes, find a way to make a game of it. Never stop monitoring, and you will find you can fix a student’s posture with just a look. You will also find that students get to the point at which they want to do it correctly and are proud when they do.
    People like to be successful and affirmed. They like to be part of something that’s positive. Make sure your students know you have their backs, and build on that. One thing I find myself saying often is “We do not baby you because I don’t think you’re babies. If you have adults that baby you, think about what that means. It is not a compliment. They treat you that way because that’s all they think you can handle. Show people you can handle more. We are tough on you and have expectations of you because we see greatness in you. We know you can do this even if you don’t believe it.” The highest regard I can have for children is holding them to this incredible standard.
    It is dangerous to tell students the right thing once and then move on. It is not enough to say, “You need to fix that note. You need to look that note up. The intonation on that note is not good.” Not only do you have to identify the error, but you have to diagnose why it is happening and how to fix it. Then you have to put the physicality of it into words the child understands, and until you get a student to play it correctly, there is no teaching going on. Too many people stop at the diagnosis.

Are there ways teachers can err with the standards they set?
    I see people shoot themselves and their program in the foot by making the expectations too high. I’ve thought about this for years. Logically, the next step for improving our quality would be to add sectionals. That is the biggest difference between what we do and all the Texas bands I observe that perform at Midwest. We do not have a sectional schedule now. The workaround is that we team-teach and also have a student teacher, so one of us can pull a section out of rehearsal as needed.
    It is important to weigh who that next level of performance is for. It can be easy to fall into the trap of doing things for ourselves under the guise of doing them for our students. Will the seventh and eighth graders really benefit more from a Midwest performance than they are with the experiences they already have? The reality is that a Midwest performance would just be a feather in my cap. My students don’t know what Midwest is and are unlikely to see it differently than the other prestigious things we do.
    If I added sectionals, I know what it would cost: I would lose the students who are in sports. Even just 90 minutes a week can make or break someone’s dedication to an activity. If I need to get things done that cannot be accomplished during the school day, then I need to pick different music or use our team teaching better. This is a wiser alternative than implementing something that would be a deal-breaker for some families.

Is time or money a bigger obstacle for band students?
    It isn’t finances that make the playing field uneven, it is the parents’ attitude toward school that can make or break a child. There are likely students in every district who wanted to join band, and the parents’ response is, “Yeah, whatever.” They don’t enforce practice time or sign the child up for lessons. In other cases, the priority might be something other than music, but whatever the reason is, I don’t want to penalize anyone for not putting band first. It isn’t a priority for every family.
    The cost has to be something that every family can reasonably afford. There are expectations for instruments and equipment, but we also have ways to support students through boosters and many school instruments that I’ve bought over the years. We are able to make sure that every student can reasonably participate in everything we do.
    There were some old-school programs in which students were expected to make a serious commitment. These bands did amazing things, but every student had to take private lessons and invest in a certain instrument. That isn’t the reality for most children and families anymore, and the question facing teachers is whether they want to be the one to set up restraints so students don’t pick band or the one to open things up so students can be in band along with any other activities they might like.
    I gently encourage private lessons but do not push hard because that is a financial and time commitment that not every family can make. If I force lessons, I am making decisions about how families spend their money and time, which is not my place.

What are reasonable expectations for parents of music students?
    Well, it goes two ways. One is an overall family commitment to the program. My expectation for the time and money a family invests in the program has to be reasonable, as does the daily progress and workload. No one in my classroom is likely to love band as much as I do. Most parents are supportive, but some are indifferent, with the mindset that band is fine but not something they will be deeply into.

    From there, the next question to ask is, “How do I make this an excellent experience for every kid who walks in the door, regardless of mental or physical ability, motivation, what they bring to the program?” An unsupported child deserves an excellent experience as much as one who is highly supported and has been prepared for this experience by their family. With that is my expectation of and persistence in mastering each step along the way. None of the pedagogical aspects of playing have anything to do with how much money you have.
    Also, I don’t want middle school students to have to choose between band and anything else. One way to help students keep their options open is to keep the calendar unchanged once it is set. I do not make changes because that disrupts a family’s life. This includes out-of-school rehearsals, which I feel strongly about limiting. A changing schedule quickly becomes a hassle, and at that point, parents decide that the activity isn’t worth it. No one has the time to put up with a disorganized teacher. I have been on the receiving end of that, too.
    A few years ago, we were selected to perform at Midwest, the Illinois Music Educators Association Conference, and SuperState in the same year, in addition to our usual Prairie State performance. Because those first three were unexpected, I got some pushback from parents that it was too much. I tried to explain that it was like winning the lottery; you apply to all of these things and might make one of them every few years. What happened was abnormal, and  I expressed thanks for accommodating, but the pushback made me think about over-scheduling performances. If there is too much, it can erode families’ trust in our decision making. If the expectations seem too heavy, we come across as unreasonable. The kids are usually up for anything, especially if a fast food stop is involved, but every event scheduled for outside the school day requires a sacrifice on the parents’ part.

How has remote teaching affected what you do?
    It takes a lot of work to commit to helping every child have a degree of success. Remote teaching makes this exhausting. I was determined that every student was going to improve in some way. I don’t get paid to hang out with only the ten students who will practice no matter what. I am still trying to find that happy medium between working toward progress and being aware of how disappointed students must feel to be at home instead of with their friends at school.
    It comes back to what I believe is best. I want as many students as possible in band, not just the ones who live and breathe band. The more students I can reach, the more value I have to the district, the more value our program has to the district. An inclusive program makes for a bigger platform to share ideas about growth and excellence.


* * *


    Rachel Maxwell is the Director of Bands at Traughber Junior High School and the has been the Junior High Band Coordinator for District 308 in Oswego, Illinois. She has taught music education courses at VanderCook College (Chicago) and North Central College (Naperville, Illinois) and has been invited to be a guest conductor, clinician, and adjudicator at numerous music camps and festivals. Maxwell attended Illinois State University and graduated in 1993 (Summa Cum Laude) with a Bachelor’s Degree in Music Education. She received a Master of Music Education degree from the University of Illinois in 1997, and in 2003 she completed a Master of Educational Leadership degree from Aurora University. Maxwell has also completed additional coursework in team-building, leadership, and working with diverse students. She has taught band in the West Aurora School District (1993-95) and in the Oswego School District (1995-present). Under her direction the bands at Traughber have received national acclaim and have performed at The Midwest Clinic (two clinic presentations and rehearsal lab group), the Illinois Music Educators Association All State Conference, the University of Illinois SuperState Festival, and at the ASBDA National Convention.

 
 
 
 

The post Including Everyone An Interview with Rachel Maxwell appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>