September 2012 Archives - The Instrumentalist /category/september-2012/ Fri, 26 Oct 2012 18:45:57 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.9.4 Getting Ready for College /september-2012/getting-ready-for-college/ Fri, 26 Oct 2012 18:45:57 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/getting-ready-for-college/     When college and university trumpet teachers were asked to identify the main playing problems of freshman, the answers all led back to fundamental aspects of brass playing. High school trumpet players who are considering a major in music would do well to focus on these basic skills. Build a Library     Students should start […]

The post Getting Ready for College appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>


    When college and university trumpet teachers were asked to identify the main playing problems of freshman, the answers all led back to fundamental aspects of brass playing. High school trumpet players who are considering a major in music would do well to focus on these basic skills.

Build a Library
    Students should start building a library of books and solos while still in high school. The studio teacher will help decide which solos each trumpet major should study, but consulting state lists for suitable solo literature is an excellent way to start. Method books such as Arban’s Complete Conservatory Method, Clarke’s Technical Studies, Schlossberg’s Daily Drills and Technical Studies, and the Concone Lyrical Studies for Trumpet are almost universally required. The ideas presented below will point the students in the right direction, but these great method books offer lengthy and advanced studies for players of all levels.

Warm Up Correctly
    Few students know how to warm up effectively. A good method is to start with the students standing or sitting with good posture and taking in a deep breath while saying the syllable oh. This inhalation should be done in eight beats. They should then release the air over eight beats saying the syllable poo. This should be done four times at a tempo of q = 80. By adding this exercise to each practice session, students will be more likely to incorporate relaxed breathing into their playing. This helps to establish steady air flow, breath support, and good tone quality.
    Next, students should play the exercises below on the mouthpiece at the same tempo, slurred, and using a poo syllable at the beginning. Students struggling with the pitch can play the first note on the trumpet for reference. It is important to keep the tone steady and full, breathing in and out as noted above, and resting four beats between each segment. They should repeat this on the trumpet using the poo syllable at first, then gradually add the tongue and use a too syllable. Arnold Jacobs taught that it is better to think of this syllable as tOO in order to emphasize the vowel and, hence, the tone. This exercise can continue up and down the scale and can be transposed to other keys.

Master Scales and Arpeggios
    There is no such thing as too much proficiency in scales. Students should be familiar with the all-state band audition requirements for their state and use them as a guide. These auditions include scales and arpeggios and give instructions on how to play them. Students should practice the scales in the way prescribed and not avoid difficult keys. A great goal is to be able to play two octave scales and arpeggios in eighth notes up to C6 at a steady tempo, q = 120. It will enhance technique and flexibility if students can play major and chromatic scales both tongued and slurred and in a variety of articulations.

Learn Multiple Tonguing Styles
    Young players often use extremely harsh articulations. They should practice simple drills and melodies using the poo syllable, which does not employ the tongue, and move gradually to a dAH or dOO syllable to start the note. Using softer syllables in legato playing is crucial to learning correct style. In this style, students should avoid a hard Tee articulation, and avoid stopping the sound with the tongue (TuT).
    Beginning college students start with an advantage if they can double and triple tongue well; these articulations are necessary for performing at fast tempos. Teachers should introduce double tonguing by the time students enter the 8th or 9th grade and triple tonguing by the 11th or 12th. Students should start with single pitch drills, played slowly. They can gradually move to other pitches and increase the tempo to at least q = 120. Once students master this, it is a matter of achieving consistency, speed, and endurance through repetition. It is advisable to practice multiple tonguing up and down the scales and not linger on the single pitch exercise once it is mastered. Students should work on multiple tonguing every day.

Build Flexibility
    The ability to move up and down scales in single, double, triple, and mixed tonguing and slurring patterns is an important part of developing agility and flexibility, but lip slurs are an important part of this as well. The lip slur exercises in methods such as the Arban and Schlossberg should be a part of every trumpeter’s daily routine. The example below shows the open notes that should be slurred; the student should continue lower, through all seven valve combinations. Fast lip slurs help with range, but it is best to learn them slowly at first at about q = 80.


Sightread Daily
    An effective approach is to explore the Fourteen Characteristic Studies in the Arban method. Sightreading a line or phrase from these every day is extremely beneficial. Playing duets with other players and reading trumpet parts from pieces in the band library are also good approaches. Players should not just practice the notes, but also learn the meaning of the musical terms and tempo markings on the page.

Play with Others
    Much can be learned about faulty pitch and rhythmic problems by playing solos with pianists, organists, and other instrumentalists. Playing with other instruments, especially piano, is also a great way to learn how to listen critically. Unless the student has prepared for solo and ensemble contests before, this could be an overlooked area. Performing solos and in small ensembles will also teach students to count rests independently and not depend on help from the section as in larger ensembles.

Use Technology
    There are also software programs that will help to develop rhythmic accuracy. Even if the software is unavailable, just using a metronome that subdivides the beat will make many problems obvious. It is a good idea to use a tuner to learn pitch tendencies, but don’t depend on it as a crutch. Recording practice sessions and listening to one’s playing are the best ways to correct these problems. Singing parts also develops the ear and can be done without the instrument or tiring the chops.

Play with Expression and Character
     Music should tell a story. Kevin Eisenmith of Indiana University of Pennsylvania assigns his students a simple melody such as a Concone study or one of the songs from the Arban method. He requires students to add dynamics, crescendos, and tempos, to make it interesting and expressive. Students might imagine the scene or idea they are trying to convey and exaggerate dynamics and tempo changes. Such creativity will bring images to life for the listener.

Listen to Great Players
    Students should use the various media to learn the work of great artists. Jon Burgess of Texas Christian University sees a need for young students to check out the trumpet greats: Maurice Andrè, Phil Smith, Adolph Herseth, Tom Hooten, Alison Balsom, Chris Martin, Louis Armstrong, Miles Davis, and Wynton Marsalis. Knowing about these players and their styles is a part of being musically literate.

    Mastery of fundamentals leads to artistry and success. It is the player with superb command of basic skills who wins the audition, not just the one who can play higher, faster, and louder. As students head to college, they might find themselves in a bigger pond of extremely talented people. The student who spends 5-10 minutes each day on fundamentals can discover weaknesses, fix them, and rise above the rest.            

The post Getting Ready for College appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Making Reeds Behave /september-2012/making-reeds-behave/ Fri, 26 Oct 2012 18:33:30 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/making-reeds-behave/     An oboe reed has a relatively short life span and the frequent need to change reeds makes it difficult for oboists to develop a consistent sound. Beginning oboists are at even more of a disadvantage because they rarely have someone to make reliable reeds or adjust purchased reeds. Furthermore, many oboe students buy inferior-quality […]

The post Making Reeds Behave appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

    An oboe reed has a relatively short life span and the frequent need to change reeds makes it difficult for oboists to develop a consistent sound. Beginning oboists are at even more of a disadvantage because they rarely have someone to make reliable reeds or adjust purchased reeds. Furthermore, many oboe students buy inferior-quality reeds because those of high quality are considerably more expensive. If purchasing a reed, a beginner should buy a soft or medium-soft strength reed of the highest quality that is affordable. A good reed can make an inexpensive oboe in good working condition sound excellent, but a poorly made reed can cause a fine oboist playing an excellent quality instrument to sound abysmal. One way to recognize a good reed is to hold it in front of a bright light and identify the following parts as indicated in the diagram below.

    It is rare that a new oboe reed will work satisfactorily the first time it is played. One reason for this is that the same reed works differently for different students depending on tiny variations in embouchure. It is also necessary to adjust a reed to compensate for changes that occur while breaking in a reed.
    All reeds face repeated soaking and drying. This usually has a profound effect on a new oboe reed. Soaking and drying will cause the fibers in the cane to expand and contract. During the break-in period, these fibers rarely contract to the size they were before they were soaked. The reed becomes slightly thicker and its response is diminished with each repetition of soaking and drying. Because of this it must be adjusted so that response is restored. The ability to make simple reed adjustments is essential. However, learning reed adjustment techniques can pose an insurmountable obstacle for those who are not comfortable using oboe reed making equipment.
    The opening of the tip is the first feature to examine. The tip on a new oboe reed tends to be more open than on that of an older reed. After soaking the reed for four minutes, compare the opening to the tip of the reed in the previous diagram. If the tip is too open, an adjustment must be made to close it. To do this, carefully pinch the very tip of the soaked reed with your thumb and index finger. Gently squeeze it closed for a few seconds. If the opening of the reed is not sufficiently smaller, carefully pinch both the heart and the tip closed, and hold for a few seconds. Be sure that the reed has been soaked for long enough before squeezing the tip closed. A reed that has not been soaked properly is likely to crack when it is squeezed. When the tip of the reed is closed to an acceptable diameter, further modifications are often not required. If the reed response is not sufficiently improved, more adjustments are necessary.
    There are only two basic oboe reed adjustments. The first is to clip the tip. If the reed responds too easily, the pitch is wild, and the tone quality is too bright. Reed makers often use a cutting block and a single-edged razor blade to make this adjustment. The razor blade is anchored on one side of the cutting block to provide stability when clipping. Clip only a miniscule slice off of the tip. After the tip is clipped, play the reed. If it still responds too easily, clip another miniscule slice off of the tip. Repeat the clip and test process until the reed responds as desired.


    It is highly unorthodox, but entirely possible to use a flat area of a solid wooden desk or metal file cabinet as a substitute for the cutting block.

    The second basic oboe reed adjustment is to scrape. This adjustment usually requires the use of a reed knife, but a small square of 400-grit sandpaper wrapped around the end of a short ruler can be an effective substitute.

    This sandpaper knife is used in the same manner as a reed knife to scrape an oboe reed.

    An oboe plaque will also be needed. The plaque provides stability when inserted approximately a quarter inch between the two blades.

    The plaque provides a smooth surface and separates the blades of the reed so that one blade can be scraped without altering the other. The plaque should not be too thick or the contour of the two blades of the oboe reed can be compromised and the reed ruined. There is no substitute for an oboe plaque as there is for a reed knife and cutting block, but oboe plaques are inexpensive and can be purchased online from a double reed supplier.
    When using sandpaper instead of a standard reed knife, it will be nearly impossible to scrape the fragile tip of the oboe reed without tearing it. Any scraping should be done on other parts of the reed. One should also avoid scraping the rails and spine; adjusting these could compromise pitch stability and high note response. Staying away from some areas and scraping others can be difficult due to the incredibly small surface area of the oboe reed. To indicate precisely the areas that need  adjusting, use a pencil and shade the part of the reed to be scraped. If you make a mistake while drawing on the reed, simply rub the pencil mark off with a finger under a faucet of running water and then redraw. Once the pencil shading is drawn correctly for the desired adjustment, rub the pencil shaded areas with the sandpaper knife. When the sandpaper has removed the pencil shading, the adjustment is complete. Be sure to make all adjustments to both blades of the reed. Test the reed and repeat the process as necessary to achieve the desired tone and response.
    The following are the most common oboe reed adjustments requiring the sand paper reed knife.
    1. The reed is quite hard and difficult to blow. Lightly scrape all areas except the very tip and the bark.
    2. The reed is too hard and the response is stuffy. Scrape the sides of the heart and the blend, avoiding the spine or rails.

    3. The reed is flat, especially on notes in the upper register and/or pitch is unstable. If the response is good, clip the tip. If the pitch is still flat, scrape the back, but be sure to avoid the spine and rails.

    4. The tone is too bright. Clip the tip if the response is good. If the tone quality is still too bright, scrape the sides of the heart
    If nothing is working, check to make sure the reed is symmetrical. As a last resort, on both blades scrape those areas that are thicker than the corresponding area on the other half of the same blade.
    Although the ability to use a reed knife well is the most effective way to adjust an oboe reed, adjustments are possible without it. Sandpaper and single-edged razor blades can be purchased at hardware and home improvement stores, and a ruler can be bought at any store that sells office and school supplies. One of the easiest ways for band directors and oboe students to learn these adjustment techniques is to practice on an old oboe reed. After making a practice adjustment on a retired reed, test the reed. You might have brought it back from the brink.

The post Making Reeds Behave appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
The Road Forward Circles Around Lessons Learned in High School Can Shape a Career /september-2012/the-road-forward-circles-around-lessons-learned-in-high-school-can-shape-a-career/ Thu, 06 Sep 2012 20:01:13 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/the-road-forward-circles-around-lessons-learned-in-high-school-can-shape-a-career/    Part of my job as a college music professor is to recruit graduating seniors to major in music or play in the band at our school. This means driving hundreds of miles to speak with students during high school band rehearsals. I see all types of music programs, but one visit recently made me […]

The post The Road Forward Circles Around Lessons Learned in High School Can Shape a Career appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>


   Part of my job as a college music professor is to recruit graduating seniors to major in music or play in the band at our school. This means driving hundreds of miles to speak with students during high school band rehearsals. I see all types of music programs, but one visit recently made me proud of the teaching profession and made me reflect on what one man gave to me over the four years I was in high school.
   Jeff Doughten, who has taught band for almost half a century in high schools and colleges in Oklahoma and Texas, graciously allowed me to spend a few minutes on the day of a football game speaking to his students at Palo Duro High School in West Texas. After I finished my sales pitch Doughten took care of some business items.Then, asking for a show of hands, he asked the band who would attend the study session on Saturday morning. Most hands in the room went up, and he reminded them that he would provide breakfast, but that it would be “a study session, not a doughnut session.”
   I immediately understood the need for a study session: rules about academic eligibility are strictly enforced in Texas, and students who don’t keep up in their other classes cannot perform with the band or play on sports teams. If Doughten wanted to have a full complement on the field later in the season, he needed to get help to students early in the year. After rehearsal I talked with Doughten and his staff and realized that the study session was not just to keep students on the field. Doughten viewed his job as not just helping students make music, but as preparing them for life. He was molding young people into the type of student that I would be fortunate to have in one of my college classes.
   If you ask music teachers why they chose the profession, the chances are good that they will name an influential teacher from adolescence. This person was probably the second or third most important person in their lives, after parents, and had such a profound influence on them that they eventually chose to follow the same career path. For at least some of the students at Palo Duro High School, that person will be Jeff Doughten. For me, it was John Blevins.
   I first met John Blevins in spring of 1987, when I had played trombone for less than a year. J.B., as we called him later, and as I will always think of him, had been the band director at Upper Arlington High School in Columbus, Ohio for a few years at that point. I was in the fifth grade band at Windermere Elementary School, which was one of UA’s feeder schools. I was the oldest child in my family, so I had only a vague understanding that one day I would attend UA.
   For the annual All-City Band Festival, we went to the high school for performances by the bands at UA and the schools that fed into it; all the fifth-graders were put into an enormous massed band that rehearsed once as a group on the night of the concert. It is easy to imagine the sound of this group of at least a hundred beginning wind and percussion players, but our parents were proud. I remember that former Ohio State football coach Woody Hayes had died that week, and some of my friends didn’t attend the concert because they were taken to a memorial service for him instead. After the rehearsal, we were herded into the high school choir room and, amazingly, left unsupervised. Our directors all had other ensembles on the concert, and we students did what any group of fifth-graders holding instruments would do and began to play as loud as possible. This went on for a few minutes before the high school band director stormed into the room, yelled at us very loudly to stop the racket and stormed back out. I don’t remember exactly what he said, but we were quiet after that. I remember hoping that he would retire before I reached high school.
   Luckily for me, John Blevins was still teaching by the time I reached my first summer band rehearsal in June 1990. He had been my counselor for Music merit badge in Boy Scouts, and from time to time would visit the middle school band, until, in the end of my eighth-grade year, we were invited to join high school band. I did not really know what to expect because I did not have an older sibling or friends in the band. I knew that I wanted to keep playing trombone, however, and that the music we played in middle school had long ago stopped being difficult.
   A complete description of my high school musical experiences would take volumes. As a freshman, it was a huge benefit to be around upperclassmen (and girls) in a less structured setting than other classes. I sometimes half-jokingly tell people that I teach music now because I fell in love with a girl in band – another trombone player a year older than me. The real reason is that band (and later jazz band and orchestra) helped me feel that I belonged in that cavernous high school. I have no doubt that I would have succeeded without music because my grades were always good and I was a curious, focused student, but I cannot imagine what it might have been like.
   At age 36, one can look at paths not taken and wonder what might have been. After my first year of teaching public school, having seriously considered going to law school, I gave teaching another chance. I kept coming back to music because it inspired me. Every morning and every summer for four years in high school, I came to rehearsal expecting to leave feeling good about myself because J.B. cared enough to make it happen. He wasn’t just there for the paycheck or to pursue his own musical dreams. His overriding passion was to help his students become thinking, feeling musicians and thus be thinking, feeling humans.
   John Blevins was still human and lost his temper at least once every marching season. He occasionally preached in class when an expert in music education might say he should have just let us play our instruments. He tended to get bogged down over details in rehearsal so that we sometimes did not have the big picture in place for performances. When I came to observe his rehearsal as a college senior, he seemed worn down, teaching a piece again that we had played when I was in high school but not as enthusiastically I as remembered.
   After that year, he retired from high school band, taking over first-year band instruction in the district. A few years later, I taught private lessons to one of his fifth-grade trombone students and realized that changing job assignments was the best thing he could have done for himself and his students. He reflected on his life and made needed changes. I know that in even in the darkest times he never stopped caring about students or the music. His passion inspired many of us to be just as passionate about whatever our own work ended up being. He never stopped showing us how to be good people who did the right thing instead of the easy thing, or the profitable thing, or the popular thing.
   I left high school thinking my band experiences would become mere memories. I had played in All-State Orchestra and been accepted into a top music school. I was convinced that I was heading toward more important things. I did well and learned a great deal from some very good teachers, but none of them really changed who I was.
   My dream leaving high school was to compose, but I majored in music education for what some would say is the wrong reason – because it offered a better chance at a steady paycheck, and made my parents feel more comfortable about supporting me in school. I had a terrible first year teaching band, general music and physical education in an inner-city school in the south. I probably studied too much music and not enough life in college: I could write 16th-century counterpoint, but could not relate to my students. I worked as hard as I could, haunted by my expectations and those of my mentors. I remember having dreams that year where J.B. would ask me how things were going and I would try to put a positive spin on things. He indulged my pride, and then sometimes offered suggestions.
   When the year mercifully ended, I moved to another position back in Ohio, where I could relate better to the students and teach high school band. Within a couple of years, I had decided to return to graduate school, at Ohio State, to pursue composition with the idea of eventually teaching in college. Years before, Blevins taught us not just how to play music, but how to put it together. When I took his Computer Graphics and Sound class in my sophomore year, I learned to use a computer to notate music, which I hated at the time, but could not live without now. Even though I hit the wrong button one day and ruined my final project, he still decided that I had learned enough to give me a grade. If he had given me a grade based on completing the project, I might have never become a composer.
   Because of J.B.’s catholic approach to music, nothing ever surprised me, not even twelve-tone music, or the strange folk-song settings of Grainger, or the most avant-garde jazz. Because he taught me to like good music (music that is beautiful, well-crafted, meaningful, permanent, expressive, sincere, and not pandering), I was able to seek out good music and experience it and now I write good music (I think). I try to share my tastes and teach my students how to find good music on their own.
   During my last year of graduate school, 2007, J.B. and I sat down for coffee a couple of times. We hadn’t kept in touch since I graduated. J.B. and my parents are about the same age, and all three were approaching retirement, my parents from the jobs they had held for decades, J.B. from his second career teaching first-year band. As he spoke, I was astonished to hear so many things that are the core of my approach to life. I realized that this man had been the most influential person on my character other than my parents. I had always thought that I left UA and J.B. behind when I graduated, and that I was making my own way in the world. Sitting across the table was my teacher, telling me things that I believed because he believed them and taught them to me. That is the power that we have as teachers.
   Every adolescent needs a John Blevins or a Jeff Doughten. For some, it may be a classroom teacher who goes the extra mile, or an athletic coach, or a religious or Scout leader. When that person is good and true and passionate, the young person will be to an extent inured against some of the terrible things that may lay in store in adulthood, and will be ready to help someone else in turn. This is what I learned from John Blevins. I carry his lessons with me always.

The post The Road Forward Circles Around Lessons Learned in High School Can Shape a Career appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
What Band Directors Like /september-2012/what-band-directors-like/ Thu, 06 Sep 2012 19:36:26 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/what-band-directors-like/    I recognize that not all band directors are the same, but there is no doubt that they have a lot in common. Please indulge me as I speak for all. Loud metronomes.    Band directors love loud metro-nomes – and the louder the better. Not content to torture only those under their care, some […]

The post What Band Directors Like appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

   I recognize that not all band directors are the same, but there is no doubt that they have a lot in common. Please indulge me as I speak for all.

Loud metronomes.
   Band directors love loud metro-nomes – and the louder the better. Not content to torture only those under their care, some band directors hook metronomes up to amps, put them on wheels and take them outside so that everyone in the whole county could march to the beat if they so wanted. There is nothing like the rush band directors feel when they have the power to annoy so many people at one time.

A football team with a running game.

   It’s not that band directors are football purists who love the physicality of the proverbial “three yards and a cloud of dust.” They just love to see the clock running. The modern passing game has added many hours to the director’s workweek. Passing forty to fifty times a game is the norm now, and defenses still seem to have no idea how to stop the massive yardage and points that are accumulated by modern offenses. I have a colleague who took his band to an away game that ended with a score of 87-52, and this was without an overtime period. The game did not end until after 11:00 p.m. and the band arrived back at school at two in the morning. Out of respect for the defensive coordinators I will not mention the names of the schools.

Plaques and trophies.
   Of course any director will tell you it’s not about the trophy, it’s simply what it represents. Don’t let them fool you. What else will be left behind in the band room after a career move or retirement? Maybe something rude written on the bathroom wall, but the school will eventually paint over that.

Freebies.
   Conventions are a bonanza for the frugal band director. Free CDs, candy, pizza, pencils, and pens are just a few of the treats directors can collect. On the home front, if a director is lucky, band parents might provide free food at football games – but don’t count on it; those band boosters can be pretty tight. Often the best one can hope for is to get some popcorn right before it is thrown out.

Large tuners.
   Everything electronic seems to be getting smaller. Unfortunately, the smaller a metronome shrinks, the harder it is to find. I love my retro-biggie-sized Korg Auto Chromatic AT-12 Tuner. May it live long and prosper.

Patriotic songs and marches.
   Band directors are one of the last bastions of these endangered musical works. They feel great satisfaction when their students enjoy performing them and understandable pride when members of the audience begin tapping their feet.

A quiet bandroom.

   A bandroom is typically a very noisy place, but there is nothing like being there in the summer. Tasks that have been neglected for months can finally be completed: cleaning out the desk, finishing the inventory, straightening up file drawers, emptying the trash on the computer, painting over the graffiti on music stands, and even getting around to a little instrument practicing.

Public radio.
   One of the best technological innovations of the last few years is the podcast. This enables band directors to listen to NPR programs previously only heard in snippets when driving to and from work. The risk here, of course, is the director becoming an insufferable bore who has a little something to say about everything but can only remember that he heard it on “some NPR podcast.”

Fancy batons and baton cases.

   Most band directors have a trusty baton that has experienced many forms of abuse. It is often left abandoned all over the bandroom, sometimes thrust into a tile ceiling, and frequently banged mercilessly against a music stand, its fiberglass chipping. Then the final insult comes when the director pulls out a special baton for the performance. I have a baton given to me by the seniors several years back. I call it the “baton not touched by human hands.” It’s stored and protected in a hermetically-sealed tube that resides in a small case for extra protection.

Corny jokes.
   Students often wonder if there was a college class where band directors learned their jokes. No, but we all wish there had been. It would have been an easy A.

Music scores and parts with the measures numbered.
   Why more publishers don’t do this I don’t know. With the computer programs available today it is certainly easy enough.

Golf.
   I have only played golf with other band directors one time; it was a best-ball tournament in Memphis, Tennessee. My foursome started out slow, but improved as the day went on, finishing with what we thought was a respectable two above par. Our ignorance gave us short-lived bliss. Out of nineteen teams we placed 18th and were at least 15 strokes behind the winner. I couldn’t help but jealously wonder if there was any correlation between golf and the quality of one’s band directing. Were the winners poor band directors? How did they have time to teach school and become great at golf?

When their own parents still come to concerts.
   The main reason I took a new position four years ago was to be closer to my parents. They had been coming to my concerts for years even though they lived some distance away. I thought that it was mainly to see the grandkids perform, but the kids have flown the coop, and my parents still come. They even converted much of their personal wardrobe to our school colors.

Tuxedos.
   Male directors like tuxedos, particularly if the tux has tails. Directors like the inevitable compliments from their spouse and students on their snazziness. It gives them the feeling that for at least one moment they are a Revelli, a Toscanini, a Reiner, or a Bernstein. As the director conducts his young charges in Pigeon Cove Overture, it will feel like the best performance ever if he is wearing a tux.   

The post What Band Directors Like appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Improvising During Rehearsal /september-2012/improvising-during-rehearsal/ Thu, 06 Sep 2012 19:17:40 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/improvising-during-rehearsal/    It is important to learn to improvise in many different styles. Composers in all areas improvise in the style in which they intend to compose their music; Mozart and Bach were both high-level improvisers. Directors work on this skill with jazz band but not with all the students in the band and orchestra programs. […]

The post Improvising During Rehearsal appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

   It is important to learn to improvise in many different styles. Composers in all areas improvise in the style in which they intend to compose their music; Mozart and Bach were both high-level improvisers. Directors work on this skill with jazz band but not with all the students in the band and orchestra programs. The following guidelines will get students improvising while still using rehearsal time effectively. I use these as part of my warmup. I start with such standard warmup exercises as scales and then add this onto it. It rarely takes up more time than what I typically spend on a warmup any other day and the improvisation exercises function as a transition to get students ready for that day’s rehearsal music.

Simple Melodies
   I begin by teaching what I call ear tunes, simple melodies taught by rote, to my students. My students are also required to learn to play five ear tunes of their choice on their instrument. To reap the most benefit for my band or orchestra program, I choose to teach melodies by ear from the music we are studying, but these can be also be folk songs or anything else easy and familiar.
   I start by playing or singing the melody for the students three to four times and asking them to listen for different aspects of the song each time you perform the song. Examples of things to listen for include tempo, different rhythms, and the shape of the line. After doing this, break the melody down into phrases and echo them with the students until they are able to sing the various parts of the song. Combine the phrases gradually until students can sing the entire song without your assistance.
   After this students should begin working through the phrases on their instruments. Begin by explaining the difference between the starting pitch and the tonic for the key of the song. Then have them find both pitches on their instrument. If students know enough solfege, they should have an easy time understanding the difference between the tonic and starting note. In band, it may be necessary to cover the transpositions and their relationship to concert pitch.
   Have students play the scale of that key and then work on each phrase to get used to playing by ear. Use the same process for learning to play the melody as you did to have them learn to sing in step one. Some students will struggle with this, particularly if it has not been part of their training. Repeat this with different tunes until the students have learned 10-12 songs. This will give enough of a base to begin learning improvisation.

Learning Patterns
   The next step is learning functional patterns, short rhythms or groups of notes that can be used as part of a harmonic progression. These patterns should be presented both rhythmically and tonally, isolating rhythm from notes at first. The aim is to reduce difficulties as much as possible; students may have an aptitude for rhythm that is different from their aptitude for pitch.
   What I learned my first year of teaching is that students would just improvise by following the blues scale up and down. Playing a blues scale up and down while changing rhythms is not improvising. What I tried to get students to do is hear the changes in harmony, so they improvise. They more pieces you add, the more complicated it gets, so by limiting it, students have a chance to grasp it without it being overwhelming.
   I prefer to begin with rhythm. Students usually have an easier time being creative with rhythm. Take a series of rhythm patterns from rehearsal music, or make up your own, and change the articulation to legato, staccato, or marcato, depending on the pieces you are working on. The end goal is improving the music by students choosing the right articulation when performing the pieces rather than the director having to remind students every day. It is best to develop rhythm patterns from the repertoire being studied, and to include both duple- and triple-meter patterns.

   Begin by teaching these patterns by ear with the same type of call-and-response method used earlier for the melodies. When students are secure in the patterns you have chosen, chant a rhythm and then have them respond with one of their own. However, they should only use the rhythmic devices found in your example. For instance, if you chant a pattern of quarter, two eighths, quarter, two eighths, students should respond only using quarter and eighth notes.
   The first several times I have the entire band respond simultaneously, with each student choosing a pattern. This almost always produces what sounds like steady eighth notes and will help students be comfortable improvising rhythm because everyone is doing it at the same time. After this, begin calling on individuals to perform a pattern after you demonstrate one.
   This is also an excellent way to drill complex rhythms, such as those from the third movement of Holst’s Second Suite. They are typically difficult for many groups to negotiate and teaching them by ear first would be a benefit in and of itself. Asking students to improvise using these as a starting point can later be used to identify correct and incorrect music reading when performing the third movement of Holst’s Second Suite in F.


   Once the students become more comfortable with the rhythmic aspect of improvisation, introduce tonal improvisation. This should be done beginning with tonic and dominant harmonies. Many students struggle to hear the difference between tonic and dominant, so this is an important skill to develop. Using two- and three-note patterns in tonic and dominant chord functions, and having the students both sing and play them will help to develop a sense of harmonic flow. Without this ability they will not be able to improvise effectively and have difficulty in reproducing composed music. Once tonic and dominant functions are learned, add sub-dominant chord patterns to the mix. From there, the possibilities are infinite.
   I recommend starting tonal patterns with the circle of fourths. This is an easy introduction to the tonal aspects of improvisation. When I first started doing this type of activity with my students, I began with the tonal patterns and found that students struggled a great deal. By adding the circle of fourths, students become less uncertain of which note to play and are better able to grasp the tonal patterns once presented. Few students have experience using their ears without their eyes; the circle of fourths allows students to begin with something visual and is easy to commit to memory so the focus can shift quickly toward listening. If we do not move students away from the visual world, their comfort with improvisation becomes limited by what the eyes can take in and interpret. To begin teaching using the circle of fourths post the notes on the board. I have found the following format to be most beneficial for my students:

C – F – Bb – Eb – Ab – Db/C# – Gb/F# – Cb/B – E – A – D – G – C

   Have students play each note the circle of fourths choosing the note in the easiest octave. Each note should be a whole note so students have time to think about the next pitch. Students should play their relative pitch corresponding with the concert pitch and play the notes in the circle of fourths in order. It is preferable that this be unconducted so students practice keeping track of the beat.
   The next step is for students echo you singing tonic and dominant three-note patterns; I usually sing the in solfege. Give students the key and the starting pitch and have them learn the patterns for these simple chords. I recommend that the starting pitch be same as the tonic to reduce confusion. Tonal patterns also work well for warming up the embouchure; they are triadic in nature and use a limited range that is expandable.

   The following patterns incorporate an expanded range for practice:

   After the students are comfortable with the patterns and can perform them with relative ease, they should start improvising patterns. The easiest way to do this is to provide a pattern and have students respond using the same chord. When students are comfortable with this, have them respond with a different function. For example if you provide a dominant pattern, they would respond with a tonic pattern.
   After these beginning steps, students should be able to try echoing back entire harmonic progressions. For example, I will play a measure of tonic and one of dominant, and students will then improvise their own patterns. This can easily be expanded to include subdominant chords, and eventually lead to ii6-V7-I progressions. Each new chord should be introduced first on neutral syllables, then solfege, both singing and playing, before adding them into improvisation exercises. This activity can be done in any key or mode and can be used for all types of music.
   Before moving on from this, I recommend revisiting the circle of fourths to combine tonal and rhythmic functions in an easier setting. At this point have students play the circle of fourths in whole notes, then add varying rhythms and styles.

Improvisation Using Melodies
   Students now have a basis for improvisation using one of the melodies from the music being studied. Improvisation should use the harmonic progression of the song, various rhythms found within the piece and the style of the piece; these parameters help direct students’ creativity. When students stumble, help them recover by reminding them of these three things and, if necessary, review the activities that have led to this point.
   Some advanced activities might include having the band play the progression using harmonic progressions already learned and rotating several individuals who improvise while the band accompanies them. This can be stretched into players interacting with each other improvising together in a call-and-response format. It is also possible to alternate the melody and accompaniment through different sections, while soloists improvise, setting up a Concerto Grosso style. This opens up possibilities of teaching various forms, including how to be creative within each form through improvisation.
   Many composers impose restrictions upon themselves before beginning a composition to help limit the possibilities. This allows them to focus their efforts in a specific direction and promotes creativity. By placing limitations on improvising students, we are giving students a starting point for creativity, and once students are set on a path to creativity, their performance level will improve.    

The post Improvising During Rehearsal appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
The Easy Move from Alto Sax /september-2012/the-easy-move-from-alto-sax/ Thu, 06 Sep 2012 18:56:59 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/the-easy-move-from-alto-sax/ The transition from alto saxophone to tenor, baritone, or soprano is fairly easy, and for bands with an abundance of altos, this offers an opportunity for improved balance. Here are some tips for easing the transition between saxophones. From L-R: tenor, bass (obscured by tenor player), contrabass, soprano, baritone, soprillo, alto. (Photo courtesy of the […]

The post The Easy Move from Alto Sax appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

The transition from alto saxophone to tenor, baritone, or soprano is fairly easy, and for bands with an abundance of altos, this offers an opportunity for improved balance. Here are some tips for easing the transition between saxophones.


From L-R: tenor, bass (obscured by tenor player), contrabass, soprano, baritone, soprillo, alto. (Photo courtesy of the National Saxophone Choir of Great Britain)

Equipment
   All too often, improper equipment results in unnecessary difficulties for saxophonists switching to another member of the family. While any good-quality instrument will serve a young musician well, great care should be taken with the mouthpiece and reed combination. Many saxophonists will produce their best sound with a mouthpiece of medium tip opening, facing, and chamber, and with a medium-strength reed; a 3 works for almost all middle and high schoolers with nearly any saxophone. Sometimes adjustments must be made, but this guideline works most of the time. Avoid using jazz mouthpieces in concert band, saxophone quartets, or solo classical playing.
   One other important piece of equipment is the neckstrap. Some of them will not work for every size of saxophone. Students should be able to adjust the neckstrap so that the mouthpiece enters the mouth directly, without unnatural contortions of posture, and so that the student will not be supporting the weight of the saxophone with the hands.

Tone Production
   Most problems that will arise from switching will be in producing a good sound. Any needed adjustments to the embouchure can be found quickly and by playing on the mouthpiece alone. This is an easy way for a student to learn what the best embouchure and air speed combination will be for the new instrument. They should match the mouthpiece to a reference pitch. A soprano saxophone mouthpiece, played correctly, should sound a concert D#6, alto a B5, tenor an Ab5, and baritone a D5. It should be noted that the student’s embouchure for the new instrument should not be that far removed from the one used for their previous saxophone. If students are doing something drastically different to achieve the desired results, guidance may be in order.

Soprano

   The soprano, used often in saxophone quartets but rarely in concert band and jazz ensemble works, is usually the least familiar to both young saxophonists and directors. When it is called for, however, it usually has an extremely important part, and soprano players definitely need to play with a good sound.
   The most common mistake when switching to soprano is taking in far too much mouthpiece. This will result in a harsh, strident, and uncontrolled tone. On soprano, a player new to the instrument should take in less than feels necessary and then add a bit more if needed. It will be nearly impossible to play the correct pitch on the mouthpiece if it is too far in the mouth.
   Always use a neckstrap with the soprano; this will alleviate a bit of the strain on the right hand and wrist. Avoid playing the instrument at the same angle as the clarinet; the soprano sax mouthpiece should enter the mouth at approximately the same angle as the alto or tenor mouthpiece. Students should avoid wrapping the right thumb around the back of the instrument.

Tenor
   Surprisingly, students have quite a few problems switching to tenor from alto. This frequently is caused by the slightly larger size of the instrument. Recently, a colleague asked me for help with a student who had recently switched to tenor. Despite all appearances of a correct embouchure, the student was unable to produce a proper sound. I found that the young saxophonist was unknowingly bumping the left-hand side-keys open, most likely because he was unfamiliar with the size of the tenor. Once this was called to the student’s attention, the problem vanished.
   Students switching from alto will need to take in a bit more mouthpiece than they expect. If they start squeaking or have a harsher sound, they have gone too far and should back off a bit.

Baritone
   The largest problem in switching to the baritone saxophone is the sheer size of the instrument. Smaller students may wish to try a harness instead of a neckstrap. Directors should make sure that students are not resting the saxophone on the floor or their feet while playing. All of the warnings about bumping keys apply to the baritone sax as well.
   Although I have seen some students take in too much baritone mouthpiece, it is a rare sight; students usually take in far too little mouthpiece. As with the tenor, students should take in more than they feel is correct, and if squeaks or a harsh sound occur, they will know that they have gone too far.
   A second concern with the baritone is the amount of air required to produce a large, beautiful sound. Students tend to tense up when playing this instrument. To prevent this, have students perform long tones, beginning on a written G4, crescendoing for four beats then decrescendoing for four beats, all with a large, beautiful sound. Have them do this, descending by half-steps, until they reach the lowest note on the instrument.

Alto
   Although the alto is the most common saxophone among students, some students start on tenor and have never played another size. As with alto players switching to soprano, the most common problem has to do with embouchure formation and the amount of mouthpiece taken. Students should work toward producing a B5 on the mouthpiece.
The full saxophone family, from sopranino through contrabass, spans nearly the range of a piano. One saxophonist, with the proper guidance and a few concentrated techniques, can gain fluidity and comfort on any of them in a very brief amount of time.

The post The Easy Move from Alto Sax appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
Learning to Read a Rehearsal, An Interview with Duane Chun /september-2012/learning-to-read-a-rehearsal-an-interview-with-duane-chun/ Thu, 06 Sep 2012 18:42:21 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/learning-to-read-a-rehearsal-an-interview-with-duane-chun/    Duane Chun, band director at Buena High School in Sierra Vista, Arizona has developed effective techniques for fast-paced rehearsals that keep students focused, even when band meets at 6:30 in the morning. He shares a few of these principles that will help both new and experienced directors. What led you to teaching band?    […]

The post Learning to Read a Rehearsal, An Interview with Duane Chun appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>

   Duane Chun, band director at Buena High School in Sierra Vista, Arizona has developed effective techniques for fast-paced rehearsals that keep students focused, even when band meets at 6:30 in the morning. He shares a few of these principles that will help both new and experienced directors.

What led you to teaching band?
   My father was career army, 33 years, and I went to five different high schools. With every move and transfer, band allowed me to fit in instantly. Everywhere I went band directors made me feel welcome. Music is the same in Mississippi and Arizona. We were even in Iran in 1978-79 where I went to the Tehran American High School, a private school with 3,000 students, many of whom were children of defense contractor employees. We had two or three football teams that played each other because there were no other schools to play. The band played the school fight song for every touchdown. It was an interesting time in the world and made you appreciate the United States. We came home when President Carter sent C-130 planes that took us off to Germany.
   At first I thought I was going to follow a military career and go into the army band, but that didn’t work out. I went to Arizona State, and band was my thing. It was a natural progression after college to teach high school band.

What is your approach to warm-ups?
   I really emphasize tuning. At the start of the year I spend quite a bit of time on how to tune because students often do not know what to do. I focus on the difference between being in tune and out of balance. Especially in marching season students have a tendency to overblow and end up very sharp or flat. At Arizona State, Richard Strange once gave us (wind ensemble) a 50-minute lecture on the importance of intonation (the result of a complaining trumpet player). Of course his reasoning and justification were inarguable, and from then on I knew I would never tune an ensemble to just concert Bb; I also tune F, G, and A. That way we address the tuning tendencies of all the instruments and have a better chance to find a good tonal center.
   We also look at what it means to play in tune at the loudest part, and how loud they can play before it crosses the line and becomes out of balance. Sometimes when we start working on a piece after the initial warm-up, they overblow and do not play the same way they did while tuning. I usually spend 15 or 20 minutes on tuning at each rehearsal for the first couple of weeks of the school year.
   Students should learn what to do when they are not in tune and not just rely on the director. I always ask, “if you don’t know, what are you going to do if I am not there?” When I first started teaching I relied too much on the tuner, and students ended up tuning more by what they saw on the tuner than by what they were hearing with their ears. Now, I emphasize having the band in tune with itself by focusing on understanding what is happening harmonically versus finding an absolute 440. By the end of the year I will ask a student who has an advanced tone to provide a reference pitch, but initially we use a mechanical pitch to practice listening instead of lining up the tuner’s needle or stopping the strobe from spinning.

What books do you use for warm-ups?
   I particularly like the Leonard B. Smith Treasury of Scales and Bach chorales. Our AP theory class arranges one of the chorales into a band key. Sometimes I will use the student arrangements in band rehearsals. Bill Humbert has also written eight warm-up chorales that I have adapted.

What techniques lead to effective rehearsals?
   Students know that I am predictable. If someone is caught chewing gum, I have a standard lecture that that no one wants to hear again. Students soon start disciplining themselves to avoid the inevitable consequences. It is the same with warm-up exercises. Students know we will do some type of tuning at the beginning of the period every day. When they walk through the door, there is no time to talk about Saturday night. They get the instruments out and are ready for the pitch after morning announcements. Establishing routines and procedures at the start gets rehearsals moving quickly and puts to bed some of the silliness and wasted time that sometimes creep in as a bad habit.
   I try to be an open book and tell students what I am doing in class and why. Because we do not have a long rehearsal period, only 55 minutes, and spend a lot of time on tuning, I stay on problems until they are fixed. As a young director, I would write a lesson plan, and my goal was to address each bullet point no matter what. I focused on starting at the top of the page and going all the way to the end, or I would start at the beginning when I knew I really should work on letter B. Now, I start where the problems are. I wasted a lot of time running straight through pieces, and it promotes bad habits.
   My lessons plans today are more about good score preparation so that I can recognize when I should stop and fix something. That was a hard thing to learn. I am a good judge of the attitude of the room and know when I should stop and when to keep plowing through. I like a fast-paced rehearsal and will always have questions in my mind and know what sections I want to work on.

How do you know when to stop the band?
   That is tough because you have to decide whether the problem is something that can be fixed now, or whether students should mark that spot for personal practice to be checked the next day. I always stop for blatant rhythmic or pitch problems, but I might not if it is a question of nuance or style. Last year we played a Scott Joplin transcription for band. During rehearsals it was either too rhythmic and straight or too honky-tonk and did not convey a true ragtime piano style. I challenged the band to find recordings that demonstrated the correct style. They found three or four good videos, and we listened to one during rehearsal. That cleaned up the style problem right away.


What other techniques do you use?

   I do not stay fixed at the podium. Many young directors seem glued in place. It is not unusual for me to walk to the back of the room to hear how it sounds. When I run a rehearsal, students know that I am listening to everybody. Anyone is liable to get asked a question. I usually ask a question of the whole group only when I am confident about the answer I will get and can use it to move the rehearsal forward. I try not to humiliate or embarrass students but instead want to set them up for success. I also always praise in public and discipline in private.
   I make sure that I know students’ names. In marching band there are 156 students, and it is easy for some to sit in the back of the room and hide. If a director knows student names, there is a one-on-one connection. Because I take the time to get to know them, we can have a conversation outside of school at the mall or grocery store. They are comfortable with me and willing to share what is important to them or invite me to a Boy Scout award dinner.
   Early in my career, I was a bit scared of my students. I had a barrier and did not want them to know me or my personal life. Now that I have taught for a while, I am more confident. This is experience that perhaps just has to come with age. There is often only a four-year age difference between players and beginning directors, and they have to know where the line is. One thing that helps is good communication with parents.
   I tell students that I will not be their friend on Facebook, but they have my cell phone number and can text me if they need help. A text I can ignore, if necessary. I tell students that on Star Trek, the crew could always get in touch with the captain by tapping on a communicator. I ask them whether they think the crew did that all the time or only when necessary. The message is that I am available if they need me, but don’t waste my time.

What is your approach to programming?
   I used to have a core repertoire that I repeated, but there are so many good band composers that I frequently listen to CDs of new music and ask other directors what they are playing. I like the music of Richard Saucedo, David Holsinger, and Samuel Hazo, and if Robert Smith’s name is on a work, I will do it. I don’t play the same things every year, other than Sousa. I love marches and always put two marches and one patriotic piece on a program. We are a military town after all.
   When the new CDs come out, I let students listen and pick one song they want to play. Invariably, they will choose a pop piece from a Broadway show like Wicked or a medley from the current trending teen idol. It does not mean that I will program it on a concert, but we can have some fun working through them, and sometimes I am surprised. For the other works, I pick grade 3 or 4 music that I know they can handle and two pieces that will stretch them like Robert Smith’s Inchon.
 
Do you ever have to overcome initial reluctance from students about a piece?
   Sometimes they do not understand how the work will come together at the performance. I remember working on Eric Whitacre’s Sleep, which is based on a beautiful poem. It is supposed to be a lullaby, but the band was playing it more like a funeral dirge. The band supports the vocal part, and at times, it was like pulling teeth to get them to work on it. They hated that piece initially. A community choir was to sing it on a program, and I frequently reminded them that their relatives were in that choir and they wanted to do well for them. In the end they loved the piece when it was put together with the choir.
   Another time Betsy Bright Morgan, trumpet in the Tucson Symphony, played Carnival of Venice with us. Upon first read through with no soloist, the students felt the band parts were unexciting, and they did not understand what they would be supporting. However, after Betsy came to a rehearsal, they quickly rose to the occasion. Their interest and intensity increased dramatically.
   When students understand and believe in the goals of the program, they become enthusiastic and work towards making it a success. For the last 10 or 12 years I have sent the student officers and section leaders to a leadership camp held by Bill Humbert. He is a great motivational speaker and teaches students how to support the director. They come back from camp with great ideas. Once they invest in the program, you have them.

How do you avoid discipline problems?
   Discipline problems go away when students have goals to work towards. One year we made a goal for making the local newspaper at least every two weeks, and they did. It was anything from advertising a fundraiser to highlighting an alum who had done something impressive or announcing students who were selected for honor bands. It not only inspired the students but was a good way to promote a positive image for the Buena bands. We have a good relationship with our community which is essential when we have to ask for money during fundraising efforts.
   Students also help determine what the band room looks like. Classroom management books say that students work best in a welcome and receptive environment. I let students take charge of the calendar and the bulletin board. We have posters and sayings on the wall. One says, “If everybody in the band was like me, how good would the band be?” They have taken it upon themselves to promote the image of the band. That goes back to maintaining a legacy for the band. Since I played in this program when I was in high school, it is very important to me that we maintain the standards over time. I marched the same field that they do.
   I have also found that peer pressure can be positive and negative, and encourage the older students to serve as good role models. A senior might see a younger student about to leave something valuable unattended, like a box of fundraising candy or an instrument. He will say, “I don’t want to sit through the fifty dollar bill lecture again.” (The lecture is about if you leave a $50 bill on a chair and walked away from it, would you expect it to still be there at the end of the day – even if your name was on it?) The first day of marching season is for new members only. It is an orientation session to go over rules and policies for the younger students. This year we are incorporating a year-long mentoring program called Bigs and Littles.
   For sectional rehearsals students bring me a lesson plan on what measures they think we should work on. I may tweak their ideas because often they try to bite off too much and want to work on an entire song. Sometimes I have to help with particular rhythms and fingerings but largely they have taken that upon themselves. I tell them that they are a reflection of me, and I of them. If they make me look good, we all look good.

How are your students graded for band?
   Currently band grades are calculated on a total point system based on attendance, preparation, performance, and participation. The two-hour marching band receives a full credit in the fall semester. I am working on a proposal to include an honors component because I have students who want to be in band but even an A will lower their GPA because they take many AP classes. I have some parents who want to have their children audit band. Philosophically, I would not mind, but unless I have a grade to hold over them, it hurts accountability. There might be a few who would benefit from this, but the district is not willing to do it. I have sufficient enrollment numbers that I do not need students to audit.

How do you make students practice?
   I try to identify measures to practice without putting an amount of time on it. To check their work, I might call on students to play measures in the middle of class. My best students in wind ensemble practice, or we would not be able to play the music. I tell students that if you want to play “Twinkle Twinkle, Little Star” don’t practice. The advanced group knows that if they want to make all-state or play challenging music, they have to work at it.

What common problems do you observe in younger directors?
   They often overprogram and try to play the 1812 Overture with a ten-piece band. Young directors should become familiar with the repertoire and pick music appropriate for their groups. The pieces they played in college will not help with this task. When I was in college we had to listen to recordings and put together sample programs that were realistic for school ensembles. They also should learn what sound they should aim for on instruments other than their own. Know the major performers on those instruments and listen to them to understand what they should sound like.
   In addition to the musical side, they will have to learn to prepare a budget and deal with parents. When I first started teaching, we had a strong parent association for the music department, and I was too young to tell them when they went off topic. The solution was for the vice principal to come to all of the meetings to keep them focused on music concerns. I feel fortunate that I had some very good mentors along the way who gave me sound advice that I was smart enough to follow.

How has the role of the parents’ association changed over the course of your career?
   It is a business these days. Our parents’ association is a 501c3, and I never thought I would know so much about tax law. There could be a whole class on this for future directors. When I first started teaching, the organization was just a nice group of parents who were there to help. Later, I learned that there are really two parents groups – the formal group with a president and a vice president and the group that meets in the parking lot after football games. It is sometimes difficult to find consensus between the two groups, but with experience I have learned which parents will be there in a heartbeat if I need help. The formal organization is sometimes the only way to get grants because schools are not considered non-profits in some cases. We sometimes send parents to a grant writing class at a community college. Many civic groups, like the Kiwanis, require elaborate budget and tax information. In the end you need both – a formal organization that provides structure, stability, and support for the vital short and long term goals of the band; and the informal help of people who may not be able to make every meeting but will be there when the call is put out.

What is the best experience you have had with your band?
   Many young directors are afraid to take groups on trips, but it can be so rewarding. I have had many memorable moments with my bands, including when my drum majors along with an active duty band dad had the honor of laying wreaths at Arlington Cemetery and Pearl Harbor and a band performance on the Great Wall of China. I taught English in China for the five summers before the 2008 Olympics. At the time China was providing incentives for Westerners to come and teach hotel and entertainment workers the idioms and practices of the West.
   I brought a jazz band to China with a total group of 40 people. With sponsorship the cost per person was just $1,600. We played concerts at several schools in China, but the highlight of the trip was performing on the Great Wall. There were thousands of people from all over the world standing around, and when we started playing “What a Wonderful World,” everybody just stopped and started swaying. I will never forget it. The students knew that they were ambassadors not only for the school but for our country.    
   

* * *

   Buena High School is located in Sierra Vista, Arizona, about 90 miles southeast of Tucson. The town includes Fort Huachuca military base. Buena is the only high school in the city with an enrollment of 2,200 and 200 students in the band program. In the fall marching band meets for a two-hour block in the morning from 6:35 to 8:30. There is also a freshman pep band although advanced freshmen may play in the varsity band. This year they will have an AP music theory class and a stage band. An assistant director teaches two hours a day in the elementary schools.
   There are six elementary schools and one middle school that feed into the high school. Because Arizona has open enrollment, students from the surrounding communities can choose to attend Buena H.S. Those that do are usually interested in the fine arts, choir, band, or drama. because other area high schools have much smaller music programs.
   Duane Chun has taught at Buena High School for 20 years. He had previously taught in Montville Township, New Jersey for seven years. Chun was a graduate of Buena in 1981 and took over the program from his own high school director. He comments, “We are still colleagues. He is the community schools manager and I am his assistant. We serve as liaisons for our community’s after hours use of district school facilities. After 40 years he is still integral to our fine arts program and continues to run our top jazz band.”

 

The post Learning to Read a Rehearsal, An Interview with Duane Chun appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
The Best and Worst from the Marching Field /september-2012/the-best-and-worst-from-the-marching-field/ Thu, 06 Sep 2012 18:30:54 +0000 https://theinstrumenta.wpengine.com/uncategorized/the-best-and-worst-from-the-marching-field/      We asked some top directors from around the country for memories of some of the best and worst shows they have seen over the course of their careers. Here are their responses. What is the best marching show or idea you have ever witnessed? Stephanie San Roman: The 2010 Cavaliers show, Mad World, […]

The post The Best and Worst from the Marching Field appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>
 

   We asked some top directors from around the country for memories of some of the best and worst shows they have seen over the course of their careers. Here are their responses.


What is the best marching show or idea you have ever witnessed?
Stephanie San Roman: The 2010 Cavaliers show, Mad World, was definitely one of the best show concepts I have seen. The concept itself was extremely creative, and the music, not just the title of each piece, supported the theme. For example, if your show is called Red, White, and Blue, and you pick tunes that just have the words red, white, or blue in the title, but the music is not tied together by a theme, the music does not come across as strongly. The audience might think the music was simply about colors and not a unifying patriotic message. The Cavaliers did an amazing job tying the movements together. The integration of the various elements of the corps worked together to create amazing general effect (GE). The guard, pit, drum line, and horns all played an equal role in the presentation of the show. Stephanie San Roman is director of bands at Oswego High School (Illinois). 

Patrick Hayes: In 1891 a group of San Antonio citizens started a parade to honor the heroes of the Alamo. This celebration has grown into San Antonio’s Fiesta, an 11-day annual event. A band festival was added in 1935 with over 3,000 band students playing for an audience of over 10,000. In the competition segment, each band passes the crowd and plays a selection of their choice, often featuring creative visual elements such as dancing. At the end of the night, a giant massed band performs a medley of songs with a guest conductor. While such a large performance is an amazing experience for students and directors, I feel that the community exposure is what makes it so special. In San Antonio, the Battle of the Bands is a household name and provides and excellent showcase for the benefits of music education. Patrick Hayes serves as assistant band director as Heritage Middle School in San Antonio and previously was director of bands at McCollum High School, also in San Antonio.

Joe Craig: If I had to pick one production that has stuck with me, it would be the 2010 Paranormal show by Tarpon Springs High School in Florida. Frank Sullivan and Kevin Ford, their design team, are among the most brilliant and creative people in this area, and I model many of their concepts in my program at Beechwood. This show was so special because of the level of storytelling. The show had incredible use of the field, inventive prop usage, and extremely demanding playing and movement. While this production was successful competitively, more importantly it was a very artistic example of our activity. Joe Craig is director of bands at Beechwood High School in Ft. Mitchell, Kentucky. His bands have twice been Bands of America Grand National Class A Champion.

Daniel Kiene: The best marching show I have been involved with was a Ninja show my band performed in 2010. The show came from a group called Countermotion, local guys who have worked with my group for a number of years here in the Richmond Hill area, although they also write for people around the country. The music is all original from composer-arranger Stan Phillips (son of one of the former band directors here at Richmond Hill High School), and the drill was custom written for us by Michael Thomas. The parts that made it outstanding included, among other things, Tai Chi being performed by the entire woodwind section during the opening moments of the show, while a voice over, voiced by the actor who played Shredder for the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, explained that the group would be going into battle and needed great training. The concept of martial arts body movement, drill work by Marlon Smith (including fans, flags, and assorted props) made this show one that stands out in my 21 years of teaching bands. We knew we had a winner when we swept every possible award at the prelims of one of the marching contests we attended and then swept the finals against bands much larger than us. Daniel Kiene is director of bands at Richmond Hills High School in Georgia.

Brian Willett: We recently put together a field show titled, Tribute, with a patriotic theme throughout. The show incorporated military memorials as props. We used Iwo Jima, Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, and Arlington National Cemetery in front of backdrops of the Vietnam War Memorial. We used the drum line as living props when they dressed and posed as the Korean War Memorial during our ballad. I think it is important to develop a culture in a program in which the director is open to working with the staff. The creativity of more minds is vastly improved over what one can do alone. I have been fortunate to work with Lee Gibson of Dance Sophisticates as my visual coordinator, Albert Lilly as my music arranger and assistant director, and Colin West as my guard director for most of the past 15 years. We do a nice job of complementing each other in what we bring to the table and present to the students.
   This particular show held such a commanding air about it because it was intensely personal. We used five sections of the Vietnam wall as our props, and they were 8’x12′ snapshots showing the names of five soldiers who died from Morgan County, where Monrovia High School is located. One of the fallen was from our hometown. My team and I had actually discussed this show for several years prior to putting it on the field, but it hit too close to home while my brother was serving 18 months in Iraq. The key to any great show is for students to buy into the concept. We took the field last year with a group that believed the message they were sending and that made it incredibly special for them as well as for the parents, staff, and audience members. We preach that each player should Do Your Job, and when we had audience members chase us down in tears as we were leaving the field into the parking lot each weekend, the students truly felt that they accomplished their goal. Brian Willett has directed the Bulldog Brigade at Monrovia High School in Indiana for 15 years. His groups have earned numerous honors including two-time Indiana State Finalist and two-time Bands of America Grand National Semi-Finalist

What is the most ill-advised marching show or idea you have ever seen?
Stephanie San Roman: Probably the worst show I’ve seen was a Riverdance program. The concept itself was not that bad; there is plenty of good celtic music for marching band. However, the show itself was based around one color guard member who did Irish dancing in front of the field the entire time. She was great, but the show was about her, not the entire group. It was a potentially good show that needed to integrate all parts of the group more.

Patrick Hayes: While The Champs 1958 hit “Tequila” may seem like an innocent and fun stand tune, I’ve seen it add hurt and insult to a homecoming football game. On homecoming day students arrived at school to learn that three of their classmates had been killed in a drunk driving accident. Students and staff suffered through an emotional day and home football game. During halftime, the band presented a fitting musical tribute to the students. In the fourth quarter, the band director had the band play “Tequila,” one of their favorite stand tunes. Part way through the song, the director realized his error, but the hurt had already been done.

Joe Craig: Possibly the most ill-advised show I have seen was a Winterguard production from 1997 that dealt with death and demons. It was simply too dark for high school students. The skill of the group was obvious, but the plot was truly unsettling. One of the performers even simulated a hanging death. It was really not appropriate.

Daniel Kiene: The most ill-advised show also belongs to me. I decided to do an iPod show where the band performed music from a variety of styles and pop artists. We made giant white iPod classics and had the guard use them as their main prop. Unfortunately, there are limited movements and uses for 2 foot by 3 foot iPods, and this wore thin very quickly. Further, we attempted to incorporate different marching styles including high step, show, and corps style marching. Teaching one style well takes a tremendous amount of time and effort to produce a recognizable style, so using various styles was not a wise plan. We also at that time used stock arrangements from a popular band music catalog, so there was little consistency in instrumentation, style of composition, and musical quality. I have spoken to a lot of directors in the last few years and when someone hints at a pieced-together pop show, I zealously try to talk them out of it.

Brian Willett: The least favorite show I have been a part of was one we had very high hopes for at the start of the season. This was my lesson in making sure that the goals of my leaders matched the goals I believed they could accomplish. It was also the end of allowing a senior class to talk over underclassmen. I have found that my groups have been immensely better when there is not one class with a sense of entitlement. 

What is the most valuable piece of marching wisdom you have learned or borrowed over the years?
Stephanie San Roman: The success of the final performance is a direct result of how much you can accomplish at the first rehearsal. This has been a huge motivating factor for me, and the idea transfers to all other areas of music and life. If you have 200 hours of rehearsal time and waste five minutes of each hour due to poor focus, that is nearly 17 hours of wasted time. We all wish that we had one more week to prepare before a big performance. If you could use those 17 hours more effectively, the extra week would be gained.

Patrick Hayes: When in Rome, do as the Romans do. Different areas of the country put different emphasis on marching band. In some places, the marching band may only play at home games and may even leave after halftime. Other parts of the country expect the band to perform whenever the football team is in public. Regardless of your own feelings about the educational value of playing seven minutes of music for months on end, consider what the marching band means to the school and community. When entering a new position, learn what traditions make that band unique and do not change them. 

Joe Craig: The most valuable wisdom has been simple: know your band well. If you know the strengths and weaknesses of your musicians, you will always pick music that the band will be able to perform well. If you know how the band marches, you will be able to give more specific guidelines to the drill writer. If you know what students enjoy performing, you will pick shows that they like to perform, which in turn creates a more exciting product. Finally, if you know your students, you will know their parents and can build the support from the community.

Daniel Kiene: Far and away, the most important piece of wisdom is that you can’t do it all yourself. It is important to use your strength as a coordinator to get the best people doing what they do best to make the program successful. Let your best clarinet work sectionals, while you make sure that the best arranger is writing the music and the best drill writer is working with you on drill. Many skilled hands make the work much more manageable. Your job is to make the overall group successful, not to protect your own ego by trying to do everything yourself. Amazing parents, great kids, and great creative partnerships will materialize when you move out of the way and let them get involved.
   This does not require a huge budget, but rather that you use resources wisely. Let good college students come in and help teach drill. Invite universities to use your class as a lab for their students to get their feet wet with a real ensemble. Have parents with mechanical skills maintain equipment or build props. Invite the community to invest in your group through donations that can be used to purchase music or drill. The more you allow the stakeholders to have some ownership of the program, the more everyone will pull in the same direction.

Brian Willett: There is a vast list of marching tidbits that I have stolen from great directors and friends over the years. It is important to remember and to remind students that no one is as good as all of us. Lead by example and you will bring everyone up in the process. Any director who tells you that they do not borrow and steal techniques each and every year they do the job is a bad liar. I have the luxury of being near some spectacular programs in central Indiana that are three and four times the size of my program. I observe and ask questions. One of the biggest mistakes I made early in my career was in not using all of my resources. This will help you strike that balance between running a group and the life you lead at home. For me, that involves being a husband, dad, coach, and member of the community. If it would help to type it twenty times, I would write, A great parent organization is vital for the success of your group. If you can provide a product that is good, parents will rally to you. You need to have the trust and support of the building principal to promote your program when others want to tear it down. Understand that what you do for students is immeasurable. You get to teach the life-long skill of making music that also comes with side benefits of leadership, teamwork, dedication, inspiration, and work ethic in a goal-driven activity that will feed these students long after they pass through your classroom door.

Share your favorite marching stories with us. Email editor@theinstrumentalist.com  

 

The post The Best and Worst from the Marching Field appeared first on The Instrumentalist.

]]>